How to tell if FTP is correct without taking anything resembling an FTP test

I don’t think that’s correct, you are conflating a description of what FTP is with a definition. Here is a quote from Chapter 4 of Friel’s Training Bible that I assume you refer to (I only have the Kindle version, so I can’t give you a page number; emphasis mnine):

I could similarly quote Coggan.

Both authors define FTP as a measurement (of a proxy of) AnT (anearobic threshold) in a “field test”. They distinguish between AnT and FTP because of the way they are measured, e. g. proper lactate tests in a lab vs. 20- or 8-minute steady state effort. That seems perhaps persnickety, but scientifically, it makes sense.

I think “hour power” is a just a description (as opposed to a definition) that comes from time trialists who are indeed able to hold roughly FTP for the duration of a 40k TT (although also here there is an element of pacing). Without specific training you won’t be able to hold your FTP for one hour.

6 Likes