Tacx Neo Smart Bike (dedicated bike)

I don’t remember feeling/seeing that much flex, unless one doesn’t tighten the lever. I can shoot a short video clip tomorrow. Though to be honest, I’m not sure how many people sprint like that dude (hunched low with your nose touching the display). Maybe I’m just doing it wrong.

I’m interested in such video as such flex doesn’t affect only the handle bars but everything attached to it (phone support, display, tablet support, fans).

Maybe all the incoming smart bikes flex or have play in their own way due to their adjustments, and it’s only really visible on the NEO bike because of how much it extends vertically with the tablet installed?

This single official video highlighting a potential weak point in the construction makes me step back from planning to get the NEO bike tho.
A mature trainer seem to be a less risky bet, and available.

Looking forward to your review tho: even though the NEO bike is not available yet, it’ll definitely help with deciding between trainer now vs smart bike later.

Here’s a quick little video from my phone. I hold about 800w for a bit (3-second average power duration as shown on the display at the time), so actual power is a bit higher. I purposefully put a bit more forward lean into it than I normally would.

https://dcra.in/2m6r05z

Either way, nothing concerning here. I then (without even mounting the bike) pressed forward and in the same motion, on the Wattbike Atom - same thing. I can’t really think of any indoor bike that doesn’t have some give in the handlebars.

Looking back at the YouTube clip again, it’s super obvious it just wasn’t tightened down. You can see they aren’t using the handles, so it was probably a bit loose and they were like ‘shrug’, it’ll do donkey. Or, as is also likely the case - there’s tons of things I don’t notice/realize while filming that you do later on from a different angle.

Finally, as for things on the handlebars, while I had nothing on there for this quick 2-second shot, I usually have an iPad up there (and have had since spring, I just had it removed in my pile of Eurobike junk still on the floor from emptying out the rental RV), plus a phone, and a few Garmin head units.

Indeed, that “float” is no worse than we get with a bike mounted on a rigid trainer. The frame flex leads to motion at the bars that most people don’t even realize is there. This bike seems fine to me.

Same here.

While the Wahoo bike’s Frankenstein frame shape prevents mounting of a 2nd cage in the usual place, it’s not clear why Tacx, having a more conventionally shaped “frame” on their bike, haven’t included a 2nd cage.

Using a 2nd bottle while on a trainer is hardly niche stuff - I’d have thought it’s commonplace (eg. I use 2 in nearly every session).

Seems lame (and poor design) to be asking folks to drop several grand on an all-in-one cutting edge fancy indoor trainer only for it to omit something so basic but useful as provision for a 2nd bottle.

I bet v2 includes 2 cages!

Awesome @dcrainmaker! Thanks a bunch for the video, it’s super interesting.

It’s also a sound and gear shifting demo :smiley:

  • You manage to shake the cockpit a bit here as well, in the uncut example it’s easier to understand that with your body movement and the effort intensity it’s probably not really noticeable :+1: A lot less movement than on Garmin’s video tho, seems fine indeed.
  • 0:12 some element (panels?) vibrate in resonance with the flywheel.
  • 0:15 0:16 gear shifting, so quick to bring the cadence down, you can hear it.
  • 0:25 a bunch of gear shifting in the other direction: seems really responsive.
  • Overall it sounds louder than I imagined, but it’s hard to tell with the mic’s automatic gain control. I’m sure they’ll be comparisons with trainers + drivetrains.

Buy a 1000ml ? mount a second or third on the saddle ?

Why design something appropriately when you could duct tape a cage to the “seat post” instead?

On your $3200 cutting edge trainer :laughing:

I think we can agree that Tacx missed a step with the single cage (same as Wahoo). I think WombleKiller was just offering up a solution to deal with it in the absence of an improvement from Tacx directly.

Could always wear a USWE or Camelbak… :grin:

Never go full MTB on the trainer :wink:

I didn’t say it was the best options, I just pointed out that there are options … and why make a big thing out of duct tape when there are loads of cheap options out there, and is done in tri a lot, and theres no need to bodge it on. They should have put a second or third bottle cage on there, but there are lots of cheap options $10 one from Tacx

When it comes to deciding which smart bike to buy I woudn’t be worried about a second bottle cage, and it wouldn’t be duct taping it on (unless of course that was forum bullying)

In general that video makes it sound hideously loud. It’s not. It’s just the mics doing funky things in a concrete box that is the studio. :slight_smile:

On the cadence, yeah, it’s like the 2T - crazy quick. Having not warmed up for that, my legs did a solid WTF when I shifted.

“Forum Bullying” ???

I used to design certain things so have a low opinion when folks get what I see as the basics wrong in their designs.

There are lots of obvious “workarounds” for holding additional bottles - such as a table for instance - which most of us will be quite familiar with, none of which would be as necessary had the designers not omitted such an obvious, inexpensive and basic feature that nearly all regular bikes possess…

As a design decision it fails the “Make things as simple as possible, but not simpler” test.

The fact they didn’t include one on the Neo Bike, when it’s such an obvious thing to do and there appears to be space to include one, makes me wonder whether there’s more to this than meets the eye? Probably not, but you never know…

Sorry, I took the “duct tape it on”, when as as you say “that are lots of obvious workrounds” as a form of forum ridicule, my bad wrong end of the stick, appologies

Whats interesting is none of them appear to have 2 water bottles, and being smart bikes, it doesn’t really matter where you put them, so they all have space for them, to be honest the downtubes is the least convinent place to put them, as you have to stop pedaling in order to get to them, which is why I always put the water bottle on the table beside me, even the tacx tablet mount gives you a third bottle on the handlebars which is handy

Reaches over to side table and grabs 2nd or 3rd water bottle

The Wattbike Atom has two bottle cages, but I don’t want to buy one of those… :wink:

The obvious reason that some of the bikes don’t have them is because the “frame” shapes are unconventional vs. regular bikes, while the Atom (& Neo) can accommodate them, so makes sense to include them.

I’m guessing you mean that seat tube (not downtube) cages aren’t that convenient for withdrawing a bottle, requiring you to maybe stop pedalling briefly, but what I always do is empty the downtube bottle first, then swap the bottles over, so I only need access the seat tube cage the once.

I’m looking to replace a Neo/bike combo with Neo Bike at some point (moving the the Neo/bike combo to another place where I train…), and giving me a neater and cleaner trainer setup. Having only one bottle cage would require some workaround or other, probaby fitting a shelf alongside or something, avoidable if they could just have fitted a 2nd cage in the usual place.

Clearly, first world problems and all that, fully acknowledged, but most consumer gripes are just that, so no apologies for me preferring X to Y when I’m paying the big bucks. IMV, the omission’s a design misstep, but obviously opinions vary! :grinning:

I was thinking the same thing.

I can’t imagine why they can’t fit two water bottles, but for both companies to overlook it seems somewhat unusual…

The only rationale I can apply is a comment from Eric Minn @ Zwift. In an interview a couple of years ago, he said the majority of Zwift rides and workouts there were 1 hour or less.

The number of people going longer was a small number overall. If true, I could see companies choosing 1 cage since 1 bottle per hour is common.

That may be a reach, but it’s hard to understand why they overlooked something so simple.

Tacx twitter account posted an “AVAILABLE NOW” graphic
https://twitter.com/tacx/status/1172547990457745408

The website linked says the contrary in my region however.