FWIW, I tried installing Supacaz Super Sticky Kush last week on my road bike. It was a total fail. While comfortable and it appeared durable, it was too thick to tightly wrap around all the curves in my bars (they have an additional curve on the drops for the palm of my hands). Within a week it had come unraveled in numerous places.
I installed Lizard Skin 1.8 mm today with minimal issues. I wear padded, vented gloves outside so combined there is plenty of cushion.
I fully recognize that bar tape is highly personal but, for me, Super Sticky Kush was too thick. I suspect I would have similar issues with other thick tape.