@GilbertsGrapes had some criticisms of the CP based models vs the FTP based models. I think it’s an interesting topic so here we are.
FTP is a useful metric in that it’s simpile to communicate, a single number, it’s a simple concept, power I can do for an hour, and it is easy to test, go hard for an hour. It falls short in that it isn’t an accurate predictor of performance in anything other than a 40k tt and is only useful for designing workouts in so far that most people are mostly the same and the workouts can be made conservatively enough to be useful to most people.
Adding additional parameters, i.e W’ and peak power, allows for a much more predictive model to be created. Given the amount of data collected on riders and the computation power generally available it is much more reasonable to use the more complex model than it was 20 years ago.
CP + W’ also folds nicely into the active research/study going into polarized training as CP can be a reasonable predictor if LT1.
I’d be interested to hear others opinions on the topic, especially @chad and @Nate_Pearson.
I’m beginning to think that, yes, for the vast majority of if, the classic levels will work just fine for us. But also agree that semi & pro riders might require more precision in their power training.
You can have two riders with very similar FTP one that has snap, the other that can crank hard for 20 min, and another that can go all day. Their FTP is the same, but their ability to deploy their ‘above aerobic work’ is dramatically different.
The only accurate way to find LT1 is to do a lactate test. That’s why it’s largely useless in my opinion. Even if CP/LTP don’t directly line up with LT1 a margin of error could be established based on the available metrics to get a good range of where LT1.
I think the filtering maximal/submaximal efforts is a non issue. If you find a harder effort that one is maximal. If an effort isn’t harder than any other recent effort it obviously wasn’t maximal. In my mind part of motivation for FTP vNext, be that CP or something else, should be eliminating dedicated testing.
Why is testing good? Testing doesn’t make us faster it just tells us how fast we are in a more objective way. If you can get to that objective answer from the mess of day to day efforts then you can spend more time training to get faster than training to test.
If a sprinter is doing structured training to push his max power or increase his 10s power doing an FTP test is close to useless and his progress isn’t captured anywhere.