Caster Semenya has testicles and a vagina. So what is she as defined by you? God gave her both? Where does she fit on your sliding scale? Is this a genetic defect according to you? Do you get to decide what she is as the system says she is a woman.
Semenya is an intersex woman
So I agree with the answer of different classifications depending on circumstances. To be decided by women’s governing sports body in partnership with the woman in those sports!
I can use the word OBJECTIVE to describe CRUEL and OFFENSIVE language as you are being OBJECTIVE!
Do you realize you are forcing your perceived reality on others with cruel and offensive terminology. It is your reality. Everyone’s reality is a little bit different based on location, experiences and everything else! There has never been a need for you to use the word butchering or even go there. There is no reason for you to attack someone’s mental health on this topic. There is no need to attack doctors or parents for them wanting there kids to be happy. There is no reason at all to use terms like SO-CALLED! As a SO-CALLED objective person you are just being cruel.
“not all mentally ill men who believe they’re women”
OH MY GOD! Need I say more?
LASTLY I want sport to be fair. I want women to be safe and compete fairly. If any woman has an unfair advantage for ay reason it needs to be looked at. At this point in time I believe this requires different classifications as right now it certainly seems unfair. But that’s only my opinion. I trust Women will decide the best way for this to work out. They usually do!
There are exceptions in every sport. That’s one of the reasons we have drug testing. I actually think Drug testing is fair.
Thanks for keeping me up COVID 
NOT