All of that discussion on the Dylan Johnson thread got me thinking. Intervals.icu has a pretty good breakdown of TID over the years for me.
2017 and 2018, following SSB and short power/offroad specialty plans. It says 2018 was technically pyramidal, but with only 55% easy aerobic, there’s still quite a lot of middle zone in there. A lot of VO2 max work
I changed things up in 2019, but probably went too polarized in the power, doing mostly glycolytic style repeats (1 min hard with 30-60s recoveries) I think I steepened my PD curve too much, killing my endurance. I got a lot of short 1-3 minute PR’s, but race performance was meh… I was slightly faster, but it just felt like total hell.
And now in 2020 I tried to focus on doing my endurance training more in zone 1 of a 5 zone model, so still 10-20 beats lower than LT1. Life has caused my total volume to drop by about 10% this year, but I also haven’t been swimming since March. Of course with no racing in 2020, the intensity has dropped down a bit.
FTP has been pretty much the same throughout those 4 years, but my PD curve has change a lot within those times. I’m trying now to flatten it out a bit as I’ve found that the steep power curve is fun for MTB racing, but makes it a lot harder to run off of the mountain bike.
yeah, but those are also only as good as the data fed in to them, which isn’t always the best for me. If I was still a paying strava subscriber I could show the PB on a few segments around me I used as fitness gauges. For what I do know, I got my best outdoor 5 minute power this season, by almost 30 watts, but it looks like I didn’t attempt that segment last year. I’m still getting segment prs but the ones from 2018 and 2019 were mostly <= 2 minutes while last year was all longer.
Sure enough, Funny to see these old post sometimes.
Based on my initial use of AT, it holds some promise. I am seeing some odd stuff right now, but the early weeks were pretty good. Stuff to refine with new tools, but it looks like a good future around here
Nothing is preventing any testers from sharing whatever they want about the experience.
Per my discussion with them, TR’s preference is for all current beta testers to use the main announcement thread at the moment. That is the only preference that they have stated.
At some point (not disclosed directly to me), they plan to create a dedicated “experience” thread for everyone to use from that point forward. But for now, they can use the existing thread, as several people (me included) have already done.
So basically, as I suspected, the medium is a hard bucket. But medium exists in training. This way polarized is pyramidal as I assumed from the beginning
Yes, I know. But there is a lot of discussion about polarized as “never, ever go into the middle zones because then you will be very bad person”. My interpretation of polarized was always: you have two states - hard and easy. Easy is your endurance and everything above would be hard session. So do not do too many hard sessions and do not do too much middle.
But many people treat polarized as endurance and vo2 max only, when Seiler himself include threshold and sst in training (not to mention in that this “famous” study with 4x4, 4x8 and 4x16, 4x16 was done in threshold zone).
well, as they say here, one of the fallacies of the “polarised evangelists” (their words) is, that hard & easy always just refers to single sessions. Many successful coaches apply this hard & easy at other levels.
We agree on this. My comment would be that hard must be at a duration appropriate to the intensity. At pVO2max, you do a short work session [less than half an hour TiZ, depending on the individual]. That would be hard. At SS, the TiZ might need to be 60 - 90 - 120 minutes [depending on the individual] to count as hard; otherwise, it’s the ‘despised’ middle.
Hard is hard
Medium is hard
Easy is easy
Therefore everyone is training polarized.
Wait a minute… if medium is hard because we are getting adaptations, does that mean easy is hard if we are getting adaptations? So by this new Seiler logic:
Hard is hard
Medium is hard
Easy is hard
No pain no gain
I don’t know if one is doing it wrong when 4-5h feel easy. The #TrainSlowToRaceFast camp will have a different view. They will say most peripheral adaptions will already be obtained at 50% Vo2max. Adding to that many adaptions are simply caused by the mechanical stress (vascular sheer stress and so). Intensity does not have to be high for that. A higher intensity will suck you into a black hole, leading to overtraining. And it will prevent you from seeing God on those days. Therefore, if 4-5h do not feel easy you’re doing it wrong. You just have to check the twitter feeds by folks like A Couzens and so. Seems to be his obsession that everyone is training too hard.
Ok maybe my comment was only my personal, and limited experience. But even assuming 50% of vo2 max, it’s around 0.65IF (just looking at my wko estimation) - so it’s not hard but given the time pedaling it’s not a “breeze”. As I do not have years of endurance training behind me, 4-5h ride, even at lower wattage will be still challenging workout around 4th hour. It’s just different feel of fatigue than let’s say hammering vo2 max. So as always “it depends”.