When I saw this I was initially really excited. On Sunday, I sat inside like a dummy churning my way through Junction while it was sunny and 65-degrees outside because nobody in their right mind would try to do Junction out on the road and Iād figured Iād rather log the quality than the enjoyment. So seeing this was like a godsend.
But the more I look at this and dig into it the more my excitement waned. While I LOVE being able to now click on a workout like Junction and get a valid outdoor training alternative, I feel like there is also a lot of extraneous stuff here that is really confusing to me.
For example, as @GeorgeAnderson and @hvvelo have pointed out and highlighted, there are a lot of TR workouts that donāt NEED an outside alternative. Some of the workouts with complicated or difficult to execute structures deserve an alternative (Iām looking at you Junction and Spanish Needle). But others, like Mount Goode, or Kaweah, or Galena, or Antelope are so simple in structure that theyāre ideal to transfer outdoors as is. In fact, the outdoor alternative version of Kaweah +1 is identical to Kaweah +1 except that is has a different name and the warmup is 3-minutes longer. That just seems ridiculous; complexity for complexityās sake.
Even more confusing, some of the outside alternative workouts are almost exactly the same as some of the indoor workouts that then have their own outside alternative. The outdoor alternative ride for Mount Goode is Polhill, which is almost identical to Antelope, but then Antelope has itās OWN outdoor alternative called Poker Brown that is COMPLETELY different in structure from either Antelope or Polhill.
I really feel like this is a wildly complicated and overengineered solution to a much smaller problem; namely identifying those specific (and much smaller number of) workouts with structures too complex to realistically duplicate outdoors and creating a simpler alternative workout that provides the same physiologic stress adaptations.
At the same time, I donāt understand the wailing and gnashing of teeth about exporting workouts either. As several other posters have poined out, making power target based workouts in - for example - Garmin Connect or Training Peaks is ludicrously easy; it took me 10 minutes during my lunch break to replicate the next three workouts scheduled weekend TR workouts. At which point they can be exported to and run on the head unit.
I guess I really just donāt understand the excitement about this feature nor the angst about native head unit exporting. Frankly, Iād have much rather seen a few tweaks and updates to the calendar feature such as TSS projection bars and plan start finishes indicated in the TSS timeline.