Not stupid at all! I had the same question a while back.
White sugar and caster sugar are the same, assuming they both dissolve.
Brown sugar has molasses which probably isn’t optimal, but I haven’t looked into it specifically.
Powdered sugar is white sugar (crushed smaller), mixed with corn starch. Corn starch is not as easily digested/absorbed during exercise and should be avoided.
Oh! That’s good to know. I had mistakenly thought it was a much larger amount of corn starch. I would have little fear of using it if the 10g/200g ratio is true.
In Sweden that would cost me about 8 dollars per water bottle if I were to use maple syrup that’s how expensive it is here for real Canadian maple syrup…
@Dr_Alex_Harrison
Any thoughts of this product? I came across it today and curious on your thoughts. With all your contributions to the forum you’ve become to go to guy for questions like these
Is there a difference in consuming sugar in solution vs in “harder” form? I do wonder about GI issues that many people get (no personal experience, but I don’t think I’ve really pushed the limit with high-sugar drinks). I’m really just wondering because I can easily eat a bag of Haribo (or similar) sweets in less than an hour, and they are around 80-90g carbs / 100g. A bag is between 150-200g. No issues with eating 200g, ie 180g carbs, in less than an hour. Is the problems the added water in drinks? Or do the gummy sweets just take longer to digest, so even if I eat them in an hour, I don’t actually end up with all of them digested in an hour?
Yeah, maybe they accumulate. But I can easily eat a big bag of Giant Strawberrys for example on the bike, so its not just on the couch. To be fair the most I’ve eaten in total is two bags of sweets like that, over the course of a maybe 6 hour ride, so wouldn’t have pushed up against the carb digestion limits. Though it never feels like that would be a problem, I have to pace myself or I’d scoff them all early on.
Giant Strawbs are 82g carbs/100g. They are slightly too chewy, but still good. The most carbs I’ve found are jelly beans with 89g/100g. I don’t actually eat most gummy bears because they usually have gelantine and I’m a veggie, but I also find them a bit too small and too hard to eat quickly. Current favourite are “Harry Hippos”, 86g carbs/100g, easy to eat, and come in 200g bags for just over £1. So much for my very sophisticated fuelling strategy!
After reading through these threads for the last several months I have been experimenting with bottles. I have tried the Gatorade (for flavor), sugar and salt combo described by Dr. Alex and found it a bit sweet. I was able to stomach it, but it was not “refreshing”. Lately I have been doing approx 1/3 Gatorade/sugar/ malto w/ 1/2 teaspoon table salt. I found this works for me and is a bit more appealing. What do you think the ratio is?
I’m not racing so not necessarily looking for optimal, just good enough. Now that I’m putting 90g in a bottle I do notice a positive difference at the end of the ride (typically 2.5-3hours). Before I just dumped a scoop or two of Gatorade/malto and was on my way.
Also, funny enough to an earlier post of Dr. Alex, I notice once I put over 95-ish g in my bottle I start to get stomach issues. So if I wanted to go more, I definitely need a bigger bottle to increase the water/ carb ratio.
This has pretty much been my experience with gatorade + sucrose. I can drink it as ‘fuel’, but it is too sweet. I did a ride when camping in Yosemite in 100 degree weather with no ice for the water, and drinking this stuff warm was definitely not ‘refreshing’ I still drank it, and I think it fueled me well for the ride. I find that this mix is working well for me - only downside is not great taste with all the sweetness. Luckily for now my cheapness is outweighing my desire for better flavor
Does anyone have an issue of doing this and being hungry on the bike (liquid only)? I have done the Gatorade + maltodextrin and Gatorade + table sugar up to 110g carbs per hour and still get hungry compared to when I eat 50-60g carbs and about 100 less calories per hour of solid food I dont feel hungry throughout my long rides