Dylan Johnson's "The Problem with TrainerRoad Training Plans": it's gonna be a busy day around here

PErsonally I started with a long and slow approach, then went to sweet spot build MV, then moved to sweet spot base HV, and then after about 7 months of “base training” I got some physiological testing and was told that once it makes sense, based on the specific needs of my physiology, that I should move to more of a polarized approach.

Mostly spend a lot of time at fatmax to increase capillarization and mitochondrial function, and then some really high intensity stuff with full rest inbetween for some structural muscular work.

I am just finishing up 8 weeks doing this, and not only have I seen further improvements, but I feel fresher.

It took me a while to fully absorb the stress from the sweet spot high volume, but I think the long deep 7 months of base REALLY set the stage for some great adaptations now.

I get re-assessed this weekend, and atm I am in the shape of my life.

I even ran my best ever 10k ( broke 36 minutes, yay! ) off of 1/3 of the volume I used to run, and only a handful of actual run workouts.

It’s working.

1 Like

What was your FTP when you started and what is your FTP now?

Typically in the past when in season ( 2016-2017 ) I’d peak around the 325 watts mark on the road bike, and then on my TT bike I’d be about 5% lower, so a good 20 minute effort on my tt bike would roughly match up with my road bike FTP.

Starting this progression in the off season after about 2-3 years of mostly focusing on my running ( and then hurting myself from possibly over running ) I Rode for a while before finally getting the guts to assess at 272. I knew it would be down as I had a half iron in 2018 that was 15% lower power than the previous 2 years that I’d done the same race, and had been cycling even less than that recently.

Going from 272, I climbed to 316 by the time I was done sweet spot high volume 1.

I have an assessment this weekend, but based on a recent 20 minute time trial on my tt bike at 339 watts, some of the online racing I’ve done, and the intersection of my power curve vs lactate heart rate based on a step test, and then a pretty damn tough workout last week based on the estimated FTP, which was meant to help me verify my estimated ftp, it appears I’m roughly 340 watts at the moment.

Find out on saturday what the number is, as well as what the training progression will look like going forward. Based on the results so far, and the room I see I still have to grow on the vo2 max side of things to raise the ceiling, my guess is that it will be more of the same, though at a higher intensity given the increase in fitness.

1 Like

As far as progression here is my personal experience, your mileage may vary

2019 season: SSB1 &2 and General build - huge gains made and setting all kinds of PRs
2020 season: SSB1 &2 and General Build - tiny gains, barely any PRs for power though still moved forward a little
2021 season: Traditional Base 1,2,3, short power build - all kinds of all time power PRs and feeling better than ever

6 Likes

Following up after my lab testing, “Lactate balance point” ( can be a proxy for lactate threshold or ftp ) was pegged as 333, with my balance point power zone as 331-350.

Best overall assessment I’ve had to date.

Also saw the BEST vo2 numbers I’ve ever reported which shows the ceiling is getting bumped up significantly and will allow me to further exploit higher ftp numbers once i start to focus on bringing the floor up to maych the new ceiling.

Pretty stoked.

1 Like

What does Dylan say about the TR polarized plans?

They don’t really exist yet so not sure, maybe the a few hundred folks in beta are better suited to answer that. So far the response has been seemingly mixed from our users

I don’t understand you answer. Hundert people ?

Everyone has access to the polarized plans - you don’t have to be in the AT beta to access them

Goto Profile->Early Access->Enabled Polarized plans

1 Like

The polarized plans were brought out after the Dylan video (in response to ??) I don’t think his channel is about commenting on everything that TR/Zwift does, just training in general

Didn’t know that. Just enabled, don’t see them yet but I’ll see what happens tomorrow

They are only visible on the website (not the apps).

You can load them to your calendar from the web, then the workouts are available in any app for use from your calendar.

What if… The video by Dylan was planned with TR to bump the intro of Polarized training plans!?

Ha, sorry. Conspiracy theories floating around here (mother in law - QAnon).

3 Likes

I can’t find it now, but I made a meme with Charlie from “It’s Always Sunny…” and his crazy board with this exactly.

5 Likes

13 posts were merged into an existing topic: Polarized Training vs. Sweet Spot (Dylan Johnson video)

A post was merged into an existing topic: Polarized Training vs. Sweet Spot (Dylan Johnson video)

As you may see, I moved the new DJ video that was originally posted here under a more appropriate forum topic, the original DJ POL video. Please post in that topic rather than this one since this topic was specifically about the TR plans well and was before they even offered their own POL plan version.

Heh. that’s funny. I thought the same thing when I first came across Dylan’s “unique” format after watching the “Ask a cycling coach” podcast for some time. He wasn’t the first to use scientific studies to prove a point.

2 Likes

Does it matter why they started it?

Of course, why would he not say this regardless of whether it’s completely true or not?

People’s taste change and attention spans are shorter than ever. An 11 minute video a different offering than a 2 hour podcast.

I don’t disagree with you that this format lifts ideas from Dylan’s, but your claim that they “ripped him off” may be a bit unkind to the actual history of this format. I like them both so I guess it doesn’t matter to me.

8 Likes

Kudos to the TR team for having some sense of humor. I’m a fan of both DJ and AACC.

13 Likes