I also want to know if I should be tracking the carbs I am taking in on the bike (toward my daily total). Because 30-60g per hour will quickly reach or overshoot a goal of 120carbs per day 
on a longer group ride/training ride. At this moment, I am aiming to hit 30-60g on my more intense rides and not adding it to my daily total, as the exercise should be utilizing that added intake. Anyone else skipping tracking those macros?
I use pecans and almonds to top off my fat goal.
I have heard tracking the protein and fat are the critical ones. Tracking everything keeps me from kidding myself, when I do it. The only mention of 120g carbs I recall was the USDA recommendation. It wasnât what Dr. K recommended for athletes. Getting in his goals for protein and fat crowds takes up a fair bit of daily calories in a baseline total number. Fuel training volume with âenoughâ carbs so that you donât feel depleted.
From the video I remember it was important to get sufficient carbs in the two meals before a big event. That could mean not eating in deficit on the rest day before a big ride. No need to go crazy with heaps of rice, but just error on the side of a little more.
Also recall them saying a 45min recovery ride doesnât need to be fueled like a 75 min anaerobic workout. No need for a big sweet water bottle on the former, but the latter workout can benefit greatly from having the available sugar.
I like many people in this post enjoyed the podcast but got a little confused. So 1g fat and 1.5g protein per KG for my weight minus 2kg, 120 grams of carbs to keep my brain working. Is that the way to lose weight and on days I have a hard ride increase the carbs a little in the two meals before the ride?
3 Likes
I think that would result in a too low calorie and low carb diet.
I ran all the numbers and came up with an average daily carb budget of 330g and that would be running a deficit in order to lose 1 pound per week. (That is also budgeting workouts.)
It seems that you still have to have a sense of oneâs daily caloric requirements and then know how much to cut back on in order to run a deficit.
To make it more complicated, you can eat more carbs prior and after key workouts and then less carbs on easier endurance and recovery days.
1 Like
To add to that, my take is that if one is not losing weight with whatever calculation method, then they need to subtract calories from the daily base budget.
I got this idea from an old Stronger by Science podcast. Calculations are great and all but in the end, are you losing weight or not. If you tracked calories and one month later, you havenât lost a pound then youâve found your maintenance level. Thus if you wanted to lose 1 pound per week, you do the math and subtract 500 calories from your daily allowance.
Then you keep going until you hit your goal or you stall out in weight loss and then subtract a bit more while maintaining Dr. Kyleâs protein and fat targets.
3 Likes
From listening to this pod + prior ones with Dr. Pfaffenbach, my takeaway would be as follows. Let me know if this makes sense or if there you see any flaws in this? I too am a little unclear on how to calculate the âmodulatingâ carbs, but this is what I have come up with! I am going to use myself as an example.
General Guidelines from Podcast:
-
Fat: 1.0-1.2 g/kg body weight. Do not go below 0.9.
-
Protein: 1.4-1.8 g/kg body weight. The values thrown around are a little all over the place, but I have locked in around 1.8g/kg from previous podcasts.
-
Carbs: âModulateâ for the work being done. Go carb heavy the 2 meals prior to big workouts. Calculate your basal metabolic rate w/ normal life activity. Plenty of calculators online. Then remove calories from fat /protein, and the net calories should be met with carbs. Eat more carbs than your BMR when leading into big workouts. Example below.
-
Do not set arbitrary goal weights - eat your protein, fat and eat for the work being done. Your body will follow suit and get to where it needs to go.
-
Do not attempt to eat an arbitrary low goal weight - instead, go in 1-2kg steps
-
Eat healthy, whole grain type carbs during normal meals. Plenty of fiber / vegetables. Eat basic carbs on the bike and right before.
Myself as an example:
-
Current weight = 170lb (77kg). I probably have some extra visceral fat that I could drop to make me faster! I would love to get to my ideal weight for racing bikes! (thatâs why we are all here right?!) Set macros for 165lb (75kg) and see where this takes me.
-
BMR (Mifflin-St, Jeor Equation): 1721 calories + 800calories for baseline activity = 2396 calories
-
Fat: 1.2 g/kg x 75kg = 90g/day or 810 calories/day
-
Protein: 1.8 g/kg x 75kg = 135g/day or 540 calories/day
-
Carbs Baseline Day: 2396 - 810 - 540 = 1046 calories/day = 261 g/day
Typical Session (1-2hours): Eat an extra 100g/meal for 2 meals prior
Big Day (~3hours): Eat an extra 150g/meal for 2 meals prior
Race Day or Massive Day (4+ hours): Go with the more typical carb loading of 8-12g/kg body weight. So eat an extra 750g of carbs for (2) days prior to race.
Math below:
1.5 hour training session, I burn around 1300 calories (per Strava). Subtract out carbs during and immediately after session (1300 - 500 calories from gels and drink mix) = 800 calories. So preload the 2 meals prior (dinner and breakfast in my case) with about 400 calories/meal from carbs or 100g/meal. Similar math for a Big Day.
Does this make sense? Or I am missing something? Now this is definitely a shift in my mindset and will take some getting use to. I definitely succumb to the âearn your ice creamâ mindset that a lot of people have. I always feel fine having treats and stuff after a big day. But pounding a bunch of carbs pre-ANY WORK is mentally challenging for me.
7 Likes
That suggests not maintaining a calorie deficit to lose weight. I donât think I heard them say that.
Maybe just setting protein and fat targets would work for skinny guys trying to lose 5 pounds?
1 Like
My understanding in his logic is that you set your targets for a body weight that is achievable, like 1-2kg less than current weight. And eat your macros based on that. Then once you get there, you adjust again. I am paraphrasing but that is the gist I got from this and the prior few podcasts with him.
1 Like
Right but he they only talked about fat and protein macros in this podcast not how to run a calorie deficit.
I love it when Kyle comes on. Heâs soo good at explaining how things work.
Next time he comes on, will you ask him whatâs in a good recovery drink? He keeps saying, as long as you have your recovery drink, you donât have to concentrate on refueling carbs. But never mentions whatâs in it.
Thanks for all you do! After, consistent TR work since January; I set all time records in 1-20s and 3-8min this weekend. I set the previous records in my 30âs. Iâm 50, so crushing my 30 year self!
3 Likes
Doesnât that mean, âdrink some carbsâ?
I seem to recall them saying that exact fueling wasnât that important. They were stressing the two meals before and after.
Yea, but he says get your recovery drink. Is that just a bigâol carb bomb or something else?
My perspective as 50+ yo where improving body comp seems to be getting harder and harder⌠15-20 pounds less weight (all other things being equal, and thereâs the rub) would make a HUGE difference in my results, but who knows what my body can actually do. The advice to not set arbitrary goals and timelines was to account for the differences in how we respond to diet inputs, our genetic makeup, and how it never is a straight consistent trend even when we are doing things ârightâ. I would love to find my six pack for the first time in my life, but that may be a lost cause and wouldnât necessarily translate into better results.
I took away that a slight calorie deficit would be necessary, but being depleted for workouts wonât get you where you want to go either. So we anchor our diet with protein and fats (need to keep the protein and fat metabolism pathways humming along), and do enough carbs to perform. If you arenât moving the needle down after a few weeks, thereâs room to cut some carbs out. If you are cranky and not hitting quality workouts, maybe add some.
Maybe itâs similar to setting a FTP goal. Just because you pick a number and date doesnât mean your body will respond on that timeline, or that illness or injury wonât set you back. The process goals are more under our control, like goals on how much sleep to get, the quality of our diet, how to make recovery days better, keeping life/work balanceâso that high quality workouts are completed each week. Then our body will respond as it will.
7 Likes
I resemble that remark! In my twenties, I could start training in the spring and lose 5 pounds a month like it was nothing and hit race weight by June or July. At 59, I lose 5-7 pounds calorie restricting and then quickly hit a plateau wall that feels impenetrable.
Iâve gained about 10lbs each of the last two years. Thatâs not something I want to continue.
1 Like
Thank you for the analysis! I am that same weight, although our age and height are probably a little different (6â and 42 in my case). When I used this calculator, it shows BMR of 1686 calories for me, so very close.
If I take the âlittle to no exerciseâ (i.e. we will add in the bike workouts separately), it shows 2,024 calories/day.
âLight exercise 1-3 times per weekâ comes out to be the 2319 calories which is pretty close to your number. Are you choosing that category due to strength or other âoff bikeâ workouts?
My strength sessions usually record somewhere in the range of 300 calories each, which I do 2x per week, and then the 1 hour walk would be about the same.
The flaw in that analysis may be presuming that âlight exercise 1-3 times per weekâ would require burning that 300 calories each day, but I think that may be overstating it..
Another thing to keep in mind is that Strava/Garmin include BMR calories in their totals to make us feel good..for example I did a 1:45 recovery ride which it said was 154 âRestingâ calories and 843 âActiveâ calories. So only the âActiveâ calories should be added in?
1 Like
I found this too vague and technical at the same time (and Iâm an MD). He also sounded anxious.
Needed more examples rather than biological theory.
Starting with a question which couldnât t be answered was a bit weird. At least find an athlete you do have all the data for (there are lots of us).
GLPs also needed a mention, some athletes have BMI>35.
Final please, can you always convert to Kg in weight discussions please.
4 Likes
Memory testâŚhas TR done a podcast that discusses the challenges on making lifestyle changes and habit forming to stick to the nutrition plans we make?
Itâs easy to calculate macros, but Iâd love to hear and read forum threads on what others have done to really dial in sustained changes. That daily chocolate snack with the afternoon coffee, eating the same amount of calories on a rest day as a big training day and overeating because the food tastes nice are tougher to tackle than VO2 workouts.
Thank you!
2 Likes
Checkout pods with/by Eric Trexler about energy expenditure. Has been eye-opening for me. I wonât link anything just because I donât want to step on TRâs toes on this post, but if anyone (like me) struggles with weight loss even on high volume, learning about how efficient our bodies become and what theyâll just âshut offâ to stay the same weight is kinda wild.
3 Likes