Have had these for a couple years now and wanted to post an update. In case some alien finds this thread in a thousand years and wonders…
Some pros and some cons:
Pros:
Battery life has been a non-issue. Charge them every couple weeks and it’s a habit to do so. If I run them down (rare) the computer alerts. Have an electrical outlet near the bike storage spot and just connect them every couple weeks.
The charger connectors are slightly finicky, but again, not an issue once you are used to it.
The pedals connect and calibrate quickly and reliably to my Garmin Edge 530.
Very easy to move between bikes. 15mm pedal wrench and 2 minutes to set up with the app.
Cons:
Power pedals are sensitive to the crank length setting. Earlier Garmin firmware might default to 172.5mm cranks even if you set up the X-Power pedals at 175mm in the app at installation. That leads to power readings being incorrect. The latest Garmin firmware seems to fix that. Not an SRM “con” but something to know about.
Had an issue with L/R balance being off. Reinstalling the pedals using the SRM smartphone app seems to fix that but was annoying.
EDIT: Have some oxidation on the spindles. These are essentially polished steel. It’s cosmetic and can be polished out with a little oil, but annoying on expensive kit to see rust. This issue won’t affect newer pedals as SRm now coats the spindles. Cheers to @GPLama for noting this change down thread.
The pedal platform and cleat interface is slightly less good than Shimano SPD XT in terms of clip in and clip out. XTs are pretty much the gold standard for me. EDIT: It appears the pedal body has been updated slightly as well on newer versions of the X-Power.
Take Home
Unlike my SRM road cranks, which have been set-up and forget except for a battery change every few years (I do my own), the X-Power pedals take a bit more feeding and love. But overall they work well and have faired well to date.
Learnings
The biggest learning for me is not a technical one. Rather, it is that I don’t need power on my mountain bike. For long rides it’s nice to see the data, count the TSS and rejoice in calories burned. But the spiky nature of the data is much less useful to me than road bike data. Not a brilliant insight, but if you don’t need mountain bike power, save your pennies. On some long climbs in Park City this year, 60-90 minute efforts, I tried to use the power info to pace. That might have some promise with practice.
Am about 85% happy with these pedals. That’s pretty good considering all the magic at work to get good power measurement out of pedals. But in the end, for trail riding, I wouldn’t be unhappy to go back to non-power measurement riding.
Finally, SRM customer service is excellent. Whenever I’ve had a question, I use the smartphone application to send a diagnostic. The team reviews and responds very quickly and is helpful and informative. Even handling dumb questions kindly and throughly.
$0.02 and as always YMMV