Lol we don’t personally know each other. I had the same dillema back in 2018ish when I bought my entire Ui2 groupset, DA mech was the same price and I’m just thinking “who would pay the same amount and sacrifice all the benefits of electronic shifting to save so little weight that they would never notice”.
I’ve been talking to my LBS about my new TT build and he indicated that the new DA could be outfitted with 4iiii PM’s.
Apparently the crank construction is more symmetrical this time, which is apparently needed for higher data accuracy. Dunno about 4iii, but if it doesn’t come close to Quarq dub, it‘d be a little upsetting.
105 brake hoods kinda suck…big and bulky.
The wild card in this is gonna be GRX. GRX 800 mechanical brifters are essentially the same hoods as Ultegra mechanical, only the blade is different. I would not be surprised if some product managers start doing some mix & matching between GRX, Ultegra and 105 to hit certain price points (even on road bikes).
As noted above, mechanical Ultegra is a huge OEM cash cow for Shimano. The question will be if consumers are willing to make a trade off down to Rival AXS (and the substantial weight penalty) in order to get electronic. For me, I’d stick with mechanical but my gut says Shimano is gonna lose some market share to SRAM in OE spec this year.
Seems odd since Shimano bought the pioneer cycling division, PMs and all.
From various Cyclingtips mentions, disc brake fiddlyness improvements are supposed to be a big focus from this new generation of Shimano groupsets. That’s the most interesting potential change for me, rather than an additional speed, semi-wireless etc. Haven’t seen anything firm on that yet though, and it doesn’t seem to be something easily spotted on a leaked spec sheet, pic etc.
Second most interesting would be how Shimano approaches power meter integration, whether it be through their own power pedals, or crank based. Hopefully thet contribute to the trend of power meters being more ~reasonably priced. Atleast to my amateur visual eye, the new crank design/symmetry should be a plus on the power accuracy front of a crank based meter is part of their offering.
Interesting because those do not look like the brifters seen on the DSM bikes earlier this year.
I do think that´s individual to your LBS - not officially DA built
Love love love the di2 GRX brifters. Hood shape, the flat on the blade agrees with my hands, and the slightly rubberized coating is
.
As a whole I have a small but unsubstantiated suspicion that OEM pricing on GRX to bike companies must be pretty competitive for various reasons, and that many gravel bikes (in comparison to road bikes) from big companies are actually priced with a smaller margin compared to road bikes of a similar level/spec.
Not sure why a product mgr would include too much GRX on road bikes to hit a price point though. Cranks would be a no due to q factor and need for matching grx FD. Rear derailleurs all come with clutch which would be atypical for road. That just leaves the brifters.
Not sure. I didn’t dwell on it too much since all of my other bikes have Quarqs and I’d like to stay on that route for some level of consistency.
While I agree this is the direction, I disagree with the speed. imho, the Ultegra mech price point is too important for frame manufacturers for them to embrace Ultegra di2 as the only option.
My guess is that DuraAce mechanical gets dumped this generation, but we see Ultegra 8100 12s mechanical (possibly released in 2022), with 12s 105 mechanical following some time after that. But as for the 8200 generation c. 2025, you may see di2 only, and perhaps the democratisation of electronic shifting at the 105 level as well. Beyond the middle of the decade, if you want premium mechanical shifting, hello Campy.
But all this is just my guess. Anyway, if the embargo date earlier in this thread is right, we find out in a week or so.
I know this is all slightly off topic, but I am indeed a mech Dura Ace owner, and I think it’s unfair to say that electrical is simply ‘better’. It’s different.
I personally love knowing my fingers are directly powering the shift, the speed of it, the timing, the clunk/click. It’s part of the joy of riding a bike at its simplest. I also have Force AXS, and though I love that, I miss mech if away for too long.
Another uneducated guess…
We will see an electronic 105 within the next 12 months…
it will be the current ultegra Di2 but remade as 105.
I can see a path where Shimano will have
ultegra 12 speed Di2 only
105 11 speed mecanical and Di2
DA with whatever new wireless/semi wireless tech they have.
From a manufacturing standpoint it make sense.
they would rebrand current ultegra as 105. They have to invest 0 to do this. They can command more money for it tho (compared to current 105/ultegra pricepoints).
New would be the Ultegra and DA 12. They share many things so it make sense to have the DA have wireless so they can justify what it will be the stupidly high price.
105 Di2 will probably be close to price to current Ultegra Di2, maybe a few hundred less.
Ultegra 12 Di2 will probably be closer to current DA Di2 (probably abnout half the difference)
and DA Di2 will make the dentist of the world blush with its price.
Again… This is what I would do if I was in charge of Shimano trying to make money.
I just went from Ultegra 11 mech to Ultegra 11 Di2 on the tri bike.
I would say that if I was riding a road bike, I would probably dont mind having a mechanical groupset.
But on a TT/Tri bike, I thing its a whole lot different. So many advantages!
Like be able to change gears out of aero is a huge advantage.
Also it 1000x better to just press a button to shift from aero, that using the mechanical shifting.
For tall riders also easier to play around with shifters and Hand pole position, if UCI regulation gets in the way.
Mech and Electronic both have advantages but it seems like the advantages of electronics outweigh the potential drawbacks which is why more and more consumers are buying them, and there are more electronics than ever. That is unless you’re simply cynical and think that electronic shifting is just a conspiracy by Big Bicycle to get you to spend more money
Well that woudl be my guess…and that ssumes Shimano does away with a mechanical Ultegra, so PM’s could use GRX shifters to develop an attractive price point mechanical option. This is completely a SWAG and limiting it to 11 spd could do away with the idea entirely. Just kinda spitballing more than anything else…if I was still doing product stuff, I would look to see how I could use whatever parts were available to hit my desired price points.
Agreed 100%…but we are in all likelihood in the overwhelming minority. First rule of product management is that what you like is not necessarily what the consumers want.
I’ve ridden several different electronic groups and have always been underwhelmed. I much prefer the positive engagement of mechanical. If I could find it, I’d be tempted to get a DA mech group before it goes away.
Shimano has never done this and I don’t expect it now…even if they use the current Ultegra Di2 as the base technology, they would still likely do a cosmetic overhaul.
THE critical question will be how the new groups will impact OEM sales, not riders buying groups aftermarket. Shimano has never introduced DA & Ultegra next-gen groups at the same time, so this is highly unusual. Was DA delayed due to COVID or was Ultegra moved up in the development cycle? My gut says DA was delayed and Ultegra is “on schedule”, but I have no insight as to whether that is what actually happened. But given that Force AXS has been out for awhile, I doubt that Shimano would have been that far behind in a similar group to match that.
And FWIW, it is my understanding that a 105 Di2 is confirmed, but not certain on timing.
Sure, but the point was that keeping ultegra/da tech around in a different cosmetic package is essentially a money printing business. If they can keep prices similar to what they have now, O&M will be able to still offer good mechanical options for less expensive bikes (you know the normal $2 to $3k entry level bike now days)
Yeah, I don’t know what the pricing looks like, so it is hard for me to speculate…in electronics, one truism is that stuff comes down in price…except for the bike industry, where it is used to drive prices up.
In theory, the pricing on Ultegra Di2 should have come down with improved volume, mass production and lower pricing in technology over time. But we have never really seen that play out in the market.
It will also be very interesting to see how the ongoing IC shortage will impact availability.banking on electronic may prove to be a massive short-term mistake.
The whole bike industry is banking on the current boom
It will be sad to see what happens when things calm down and bikes are no longer flying off the shelf.
Will the LBS die?
Will prices come down?
Will bike makers start dying off?