I’m assuming most people who use TR have a very specific goal in terms of improvement, it could be their FTP, holding onto the local group ride, or beating their time on the local loop, etc.
I know I’ve seen a lot more progress being consistent with my structured plan over 3 months than last summer where I skipped a lot of workouts for fun rides. Not all miles have the same impact, especially if you’re time-crunched or it’s your first go around with training.
Over the summer I’ll probably do more outdoor riding and try to hold onto the gains I’ve made so far. But I also know, based on past experience, that I may not see as much progress without being consistent.
My personal obsession is nailing the 3 main workouts of the week. I call it an obsession because it’s a process goal for me. I have goals that I personally want to reach.I’m obsessed being successful in my goals. Doesn’t mean everyone has to be dedicated and persevere how I want.
I was picking up on that as well… however you bring up a good point.
Allow me to flip that around to “TR knows better than you” and I believe that is an unspoken assumption of anyone that strives to precisely follow plans.
On the podcast, Coach Chad is quite clear (to my ears) that modifying the workouts is positive and something you should do. Or the plan might be ‘just right’ for you and no modifications are needed. At least thats what I hear.
The real challenge is trying to figure out how to coach yourself while using the TR plans as a template. I say that from my own personal experience, and from trying to help my sister and a friend with making decisions about how to modify the plans based on how they feel, ability to complete certain workouts, and what to do when “life” interferes.
For me the bike the bike started as training tool, it’s a way to get/stay in shape. However, the more I ride outside the more I understand the “adventure” side of it and the joy of riding outdoors. But for the moment my indoor trainer is my “gym” (whether that is correct or not).
If it is a nice day, and I have the time, I will always ride outside. Generally I will do my trainerroad workout outside on those days, if one is scheduled, plus some ‘extra,’ whether it is zone 2, a ride to a coffee stop (or brewery), or just cruising around smelling the roses for a while.
I think that is an interesting perspective to bring up. It would be interesting to see how people who see TR as ‘the coach’ vs a tool that facilitates self-coaching aligns or doesn’t align with views on executing plans with precision. I am still curious about how that all aligns or does not align with experience as a cyclist or training experience.
Personally, when I started using TR I went low volume so I could add my fun / joy / unstructured endurance / whatever you want to call them rides to my plan. That way having fun and enjoying riding was part of the plan and I would never experience guilt for skipping workouts or modifying workouts to have ‘fun’. And it gives me room to add rides to my plan that focus on skills development or other activities that don’t have the most training benefit.
I think if you enjoy it, you are doing it correctly. One of the things I love about cycling is that there are so many different things to love about cycling and everyone can pick their own set.
No friends, a lot of self-steem issues, fear of being bad at something, do not like the roads near my home - 98% time inside to become better at something that I do not utilise in real life and workouts give me some sense of acomplishement, riding alone outside - does not.
Good point, it seems obvious to me that the only reason someone would be paying for TR in the first place is because they do know better than you, otherwise why waste the money? IMO if you are spending the money than you are admitting that you want someone else to tell you how to get faster and you have chosen TR for that purpose. Even if you begin to diverge from some of the TR plans eventually, isn’t it only because TR gave you the tools to decide for yourself that there is a better way to meet your goals?
If it is for the workout environment than you are admitting that TR has better programmers than you and you are paying them for that.
Would you keep paying a coach that isn’t making you faster? I think it is kind of funny to pay money for a service and then question others that pay money for the same service but are trying to maximize their returns.
This is coming from someone with laughable workout compliance because I will always ride outside when given the chance. I never ride the trainer from March to October But, I have also been able to improve my FTP from the low 200s to 280 over three years of this. I’m cool with it, sometimes half assing it is good enough!
This feels like one of those “worry about your own work instead of your neighbor’s” topics.
My only point by flipping the statement on its head is that sometimes stock plans work well for some, but not others. The TrainerRoad app and trainer control is best-in-class in my humble opinion. TR app and workouts/plans are well done, but for those of us that struggle with recovery it can be a challenge adapting plans to our own response. Sometimes it seems like having a beginner/intermediate/advanced knob to control the number of intervals (dose) would be better than Low/Mid/High volume (frequency). In other words, I want more frequency AND need to dial down the dose in order to recover.
Does plan builder accommodate this, at least to some extent, when it asks for your experience with structured training? I know that sounds like a different question than the dose control that you’re after, but I imagine it would have a similar effect.
For me (not judging anybody else), this is the tipping point. If I skip an hours TR workout, once a week, for my team Saturday Bash, am I losing or missing something?
In my very personally opinion, the resounding response is no. I can get so many other benefits stepping away from the plan. Mental wellbeing is top of that list for me. Yes, I’m fortunate that I have friends to ride with. Breaks my heart to read a couple of comments in this thread that seem to suggest other TR users don’t have that.
That said, I do acknowledge the years of experience (Coach Chads Brain) that have gone into developing TR Plan Builder and I’m never going to tell anyone that my approach is better. I just need that mental reset, once a week. That’s how I keep my TR sessions productive.