Disclaimer - This will be read by many people as stirring the pot but I’m honestly asking for opinions, thoughts, observations… I have been dedicated to using Trainerroad extensively this year so I’m obviously a fan and simply looking for opinions.
I had lunch with a friend last week who casually had taken notice of the number of TR rides I’ve posted this year to my Strava account. By my count, 114 Trainerroad rides so far this year out of a total of 229 possible riding days (8/18/19 - 1/1/19 is 229 days so far this year).
He said he tried TR for a few months and follows a lot of TR employees on Strava and said that I use it more than the employees use it. He says the fastest folks he follows do not use the trainer as often as I do, not by any stretch, and asked if I had noticed the same. Bottom line, he thinks I am overusing the trainer this year just based on our time riding together and feels I should get back to riding outside a lot more often. Ouch, that hurt a little.
I told him that Pete seems to be pretty damn fast and uses TR frequently and I sent him this video where Pete says “90% of his time is spent on the trainer.” He was quick to point out that the actual results may be a bit different from the proclaimed usage.
I didn’t think what he was saying was likely the case, so I explored for myself and took a look at the last 4 months of Jonathan, Pete and Nate’s Strava accounts. I have to say, I hadn’t really focused on the data as a casual observer, but after a quick review, I came away surprised.
Jonathan
August
15 rides posted
0 Indoor TR Rides
1 Outdoor TR Ride
6.67% TR
July
28 rides posted
1 Indoor TR Ride
3 Outdoor TR Rides
14.3% TR
June
16 Rides posted
0 Indoor TR Rides
0 Outdoor TR Rides
0% TR
May
33 Rides posted
4 Indoor TR Rides
0 Outdoor TR Rides
12.1% TR
Total 9/91 = 9.8% Total TR Usage
Pete
August
10 rides posted
1 Indoor TR Rides
0 Outdoor TR Rides
10% TR
July
17 rides posted
2 Indoor TR Rides
0 Outdoor TR Rides
11.8% TR
June
8 Rides posted
0 Indoor TR Rides
0 Outdoor TR Rides
0% TR
May
14 Rides posted
1 Indoor TR Rides
0 Outdoor TR Rides
7.2% TR
Total 4/49 = 8.2% Total TR Usage Maybe he meant 9%?
Nate
August
18 rides posted
9 Indoor TR Rides
0 Outdoor TR Rides
50% TR
July
33 rides posted
17 Indoor TR Rides
2 Outdoor TR Rides
58% TR
June
20 Rides posted
14 Indoor TR Rides
0 Outdoor TR Rides
70% TR
May
24 Rides posted
10 Indoor TR Rides
1 Outdoor TR Rides
46% TR
Total 53/91 = 56% Total TR Usage
Me
August
11 rides posted
7 Indoor TR Rides
0 Outdoor TR Rides
64% TR
July
25 rides posted
21 Indoor TR Rides
0 Outdoor TR Rides
84% TR
June
15 Rides posted
7 Indoor TR Rides
0 Outdoor TR Rides
47% TR
May
25 Rides posted
18 Indoor TR Rides
0 Outdoor TR Rides
72% TR
Total 53/76 = 70% Total TR Usage
*My math may be off here and there but the above is pretty close
I 100% admit that they all race more than I do and a lot of the rides they post are races. That I understand. There are other rides posted, race warm-ups, video shoots, MTB skills rides, vacation rides, etc., where riding on TR just isn’t feasible and those skew the percentages some. They also likely don’t post every single training session to their Strava account.
All that said, what am I missing? Less than 10% of Pete and Jonathan’s Strava posted rides are on Trainerroad? There are plenty of long group rides, chill rides, flowy singletrack rides, all the things I’m giving up to “get faster.”
So are they already fast and just deciding that they don’t need structured training any longer? Nate is obviously building towards his Road Cat 2 and he uses the product many times more than the others. Is it as simple as that? Once you are fast, no reason to keep training with TR?
I am honestly very surprised by the lack of, let’s call it, “traditional” Trainerroad usage by Jonathan and Pete (e.g.- pick a workout/plan, jump on the trainer, ride the workout, post results to Strava). Isn’t that what the entire platform is built around? Eliminating junk miles and unstructured training in favor of getting “more results from your hard work when you couple custom power-based workouts with a properly structured, discipline-specific training plan.”
While I’m ok (not thrilled) with my FTP gains for the year using structured training, I’m a bit conflicted by this. Is this just a case of, “Do as I say not as I do?” I don’t honestly care whether they use it or not but I do care about my progression and want to take the best path available. The two fast guys don’t seem to use the platform as much as I would expect or as much as I am using it. That does make me wonder if I’m doing what’s best. Bottom line.