That might have extended your TTE by a minute or two and changed your average power by a couple of watts at most but it wouldn’t have been enough to have made a big difference.
Yeah, even getting up the ramp for nearly 5 minutes didn’t make much difference. Anyway, plan builder has a 4 week SSB2 block (3 + recovery), and then I have prog 1 scheduled.
I found the same with the baseline test.
Grinding a couple of extra minutes probably won’t change the result at all, except your TTE which might help you choose appropriate total interval times going forward. If you did the test within trainerroad you can use the ride analysis to show this: ‘capture’ the active portion of the test with the sliders then move the slider at the end of the portion left and right. You’ll see that the average power for the portion barely changes.
I was thinking of doing one and a ramp in the same week too. If you do could you let us know your thoughts?
Edited: as KM points out on the podcasts even the best power meters will have a margin of error of at least a couple of Watts, a bigger number than slogging for another minute or two on the protocol.
Sorry to interrupt the discussion. But as someone without an ANT+ dongle and no Access to a laptop to install the workout creator: how would I go about doing the Kolie Moore FTP test protocol? Can I download a fit file and load it onto my Edge 530 to do it? I guess ERG wouldn’t work with that, right? Any other solutions/workarounds?
Start recording on your bike computer. Get on your trainer. Warm up. Ride to just under threshold for 10 minutes. Start gently ramping. Go till you can’t.
If someone has made the protocol in their own workout creator and then invited you to a team you can load it and do it as far as I know. Someone did that for some KM style VO2 interval sessions, I’m not sure if anyone has done it for the test protocol.
Will update on the Ramp Test. I’ve long struggled with the Ramp Test, so I’m interested to see how it compares now I’ve already a number to work to.
One of the points of the FTP protocol is to be able to recognize how it feels (a key skill). Erg mode isn’t needed, just ride
(His Vo2 workouts shouldn’t be erg mode either IMO)
In fact it has been done, and it is already in this topic:
Or like Eric has said - just simply ride and record it on the head unit. This protocol is not some magical thing - sit on the bike, and ride what you feel your FTP is.
Assuming you’re using an indoor trainer, I would suggest simply toggling your cycling computer to “indoor” mode. Then, simply use the lap function to start your test interval after the warmup, and hit lap again when you’re done/exhausted. That should give you a solid, distinct segment which will spit out an average power and clock your TTE. As far as the different wattage levels and ramp at the end within the test interval, I would think you could just “eyeball” those time periods within the test lap.
Totally agree. One of the main benefits for me
Ramp Test this morning - 34 watts/ 12.8% lower! Wasn’t feeling the normal pressure, but the legs gave up before the breathing. Never got the cadence going - there’s always something for me with Ramp Tests that I come away unsatisfied.
Anyway, sticking with the Kolie Moore Protocol, and my current thinking is to just adjust TR FTP to the ramp test FTP for the VO2 Max workouts this block. I have been manually adjusting VO2 max down, but I might just go with the later.
Ah wow, 34W is quite a difference. If I do the same pair of tests I will let you know the result. Right there that tells you why testing protocols are a hot topic. I think your strategy is a sound one, KM for FTP training and the TrainerRoad one for VO2 max, with the caveat that you are taking notice of perceived effort.
One of the most consistent themes I see here and on the podcasts is the value of riding to perceived effort even if you have access to accurate power. As he says, threshold intervals (minimum duration 10 mins according to him) should be ‘doable’ and if you are fatiguing quickly you are probably over FTP. Using that idea alone you won’t be 34W out of the real value when doing threshold work especially after doing one of his test protocols.
As for VO2 max I think everyone agrees that it should be unpleasant! Good luck and thanks for posting.
Kaweah was to be my Saturday workout (which is 5x10), but I was going to sub it for a Zwift race (which are pretty much threshold the whole way). I may do that tomorrow instead of Ebbetts. Not going to win the race anyway, so it doesn’t matter if that’s compromised! 
Hi All
I’m thinking of trying the baseline test at the weekend. I struggle with the ramp test and always feel in between gears when doing the 20 min test.
My question is when the power ramps up after the first two phases how quickly does this happen?
Very slowly. So slow that it changes your ftp by 3-4 W. You can also ramp it yourself if you are feeling that you went too easy in the first part. Or you can not ramp at all if you feel your ftp pretty well and go all out TTE over the duration of the workout.
As jarsson said, slowly. I made one in the workout creator and set that portion to ramp at 1% of FTP every two minutes. Seemed to work for me but don’t worry about the exact number.
I might actually just do Lamarck, fits with life schedule rather than Kaweah.
Don’t miss the point here, however: this protocol shouldn’t really be done in erg mode. The point of it is to spend enough time riding at FTP that you learn what FTP feels like. As you get better at this, you won’t need a ramp at the end. Instead, you’ll spend the first ten minutes feeling out your FTP for that day (coming in with an informed “guess”, in most cases), and then the next 30-60min riding at that power to help determine TTE and validate that FTP. If you’ve really got that FTP point dialed, you’ll blow up pretty quickly once you hit the ramp at the end and try to elevate your power, especially if you’ve been at it for 40 or 60 minutes.
Example: my test next week, I intend to do the progression 1 version. I’ll enter with an assumed FTP of 280W (based on a 15-min MMP test from last week). I’ll start the first segment at around 270W, slowly increase to 280 over that first ten minutes, see how that feels. If I feel like I’m at MLSS, hold it as long as I can. If it’s too high, back off to 275, if it feels easy, try 285… I will probably get to the ramp, but if it goes like most of my tests, I’ll settle out at a good FTP feeling and get about 30s into trying to ramp things up.
Did Lamarck, successfully, at an appropriate RPE.