Nota bene: you can’t rely on HR for any of these tests. In a lot of people there’s decoupling, in some people there’s not. One of the big factors here is the slow component, which can be elicited even without reaching vo2max, even if the heart rate itself is what one might consider “vo2max”. Which is something that should probably ignored in this context. Even then, HR requires much more context. Look at the power curve, not the HR.
Did another attempt at this today, I’ve done two of these type tests before, the first go I just got the pacing all wrong, the 2nd attempt was good and a few months ago when I was peaking for a big race. Then took 2 weeks off and then did a bit of a V02 block for 2 weeks and easy few days and this was a test to set my current position to start sweet spot progression for base season (using longer SS intervals)
Ended up averaging about 302W for 30 mins. Bit disappointed as last time did 309W for 40 mins BUT that was at peak fitness not like now after off season and about to start base. Could have stuck it out for few (say 5) more minutes but didn’t see the point. Also motivation/energy levels seemed bit low today, not sure why! FTP somewhere in 295-305W region, call it 300. Time for base to start. Will likely start with 2 x 20 mins at 90% and progress from there.
Why bother with 2x20?
If your TTE is close to 40 minutes, 2x20 is not putting any sort of strain into your body. You can do 40 minutes at FTP so 2x20@90% will be probably as effective as doing 1x20 threshold workout ![]()
Only one workout at 2x20, then 2x25, 3x15 etc. Break myself in gently! If feel fine will extend 2nd interval.
Ok
But it will be rather barely maintenance work for you in my opinion.
What would you suggest then for a sweetspot progression block over (say) 6-8 weeks with 2 sweetspot sessions a week plus 1 other (plus 3 runs)?
Where would you start? As only managed 30 mins today (ok likely could have held on to May be 35 at max) I think 40 mins in zone would be good start point?
The progression you have propsed is good but for threshold. The 90% you can hold way longer (and way I mean 2x or longer after some training). So basically if your TTE is 40 minutes and you want to start very gentle 3x15@90%, 4x15@90%, 3x20@90, maybe 3x25, 4x20, 2x30, 3x30, 2x40. 2x a week is a lot time to recover even if sustained power is not your strong side.
Edit–
And I am really sorry if I sound condensending but many people here very underestimate their ability to do longer intervals. And they are hard when you start training but then, you can really easly do them without any problem.
One question I have regarding sweetspot intervals in this context - how important is progression?
There is a lot of talk of going through a progression of interval lengths, and I do understand that training needs to get harder/change over time to remain effective.
It does however seem to me that most SS workouts in trainerroad have fairly short intervals - lots in the 10-15 minute range.
If I can do 2x20, or 3x20, why should I go back to shorter intervals with more rest? Is backing off and doing a ‘progression’ better than doing the longer intervals that I can do, but with much smaller changes in duration? Putting it another way, it seems that often to get the ‘progression’, workouts start out too easy, so that at the end of the block they can be more along the lines of what you can really do.
I haven’t been following a plan this year, but I plan to get back on one soon, so this will become a lot less academic and more practical for me in the next few weeks ![]()
I’ll piggyback and agree 100% 90% tte should be way longer like 2x. Once u get your ftp set right its not too bad:)
I understand (probably) this from TR point of view, and from new user perspective. But then comes the individual perspective and adjusting the training to your needs. If you can do longer intervals and more of them - definitely you should do them:) If I can do 90min of SST in one go without much of a problem, starting with 3x15 would be a little bit pointless from adaptations perspective.
Of course then is the training composition. If I want to stack workouts like in HV plans then probably doing 1x90, 3 times in a row would be too much. So then shorter TiZ workouts have their place. So basically every workout should be considered as part of a bigger whole, not in isolation.
But, I am no expert in this and probably have only scraps of knowledge in comparision to many smarter people here and some coaches.
IMO the short intervals are because the FTP tests in TR often overestimate FTP. Not just the ramp test - even with 20mins, you still have a significant anaerobic contribution. If you look at it the other way round, if you did a 10 mile TT, would you aim for your FTP, or slightly above?
As a consequence, the sweetspot intervals in TR are really at threshold for a lot of users, so 10min intervals are ok. And the threshold intervals are more like long, low vo2 intervals, so having them at 10 min max probably also works. Also those usually come later in block, and the assumption is that FTP would have increased before them (bringing them back down to threshold).
Yeah this 100%. I’ve been looking through completed workouts and Donner in SSB2 seems to be a breaking point. 3x12 minutes just under “FTP” with 6 minute rests should be doable by absolutely everyone who’s made it through SSB1 - and yet I’m seeing about a 1 in 4 failure rate for those who used the ramp test to set FTP.
No judgement here - I failed Donner the second time through base - that was my first clue something was wrong.
You would aim to go as fast as possible, and end up riding it over FTP - but isn’t that what the 95% correction factor is for?
And as we all know, emergent physiological phenomena are easily reduced to simple linear equations without any loss of generality.
You could still follow a TR plan in part by doing say, the weekly Saturday progression from Olympic Triathlon Build Mid Vol? That would start you out with 4x9 Threshold with generous 1:1 rests and 75 mins at Tempo, and progress you to 5x10 with 1:2 rests and 75 mins at high SweetSpot. Comparing how the RPE feels during those alternating workouts would probably give you clues about your strengths/weaknesses and what might help you to work on (shorter and higher, lower and longer). I think calibrating RPE is a part of the KM testing philosophy.
The TR plan progressions are achievable for most I think, that’s the business model. The cost of setting interval goals that are too long or ambitious and not completing your whole planned progression is feeling like you failed, being confused about where to go next or what else to try, and losing the opportunity to complete more aerobic work which you could have done with less ambitious targets. The cost of completing your whole progression at less ambitious targets is nothing except maybe wondering what you could have achieved if you’d gone all out. But you just did that with the FTP test right?
I didn’t say that it was accurate.
I was just pointing out that you wouldn’t use your power from a maximal 20 minute effort or a 10 mile TT as your FTP, which is how splash made it sound.
TR sweetspot intervals are also rarely just 90% of FTP in their base plan(s). This week I did Mary Austin, Leconte & SS90/60 1x60min. The two TR workouts were somewhat challenging and got painful towards the end. The 60min @ 90 was easy in comparison.
My apologies. I thought both of those were considered largely sweetspot.
I did the Baseline test a week ago.
Ramp Test: 301W
Baseline Test: 294W for 35:42
First thought to me was that it was way harder than the ramp test both physically and mentally. I’ve always recovered quickly from the ramp test, whereas this was really tough and I took a rest day the following day. Other thing I noticed was that I didn’t sett a single power PR. Not sure what to take from that.
Decided to go with 295W moving forward just for the round number. Did 3x12@92%, 3x15@92%, Clouds Rest, and Reinstein -1 this past week and felt really good. I think having done the Baseline test twice now, I think its won’t be so mentally tough in the future.
Well 35 minutes is the absolute rock-bottom bare minimum TTE - some would even say it’s too short and should be at least 40 minutes.
So either you were riding above FTP for 35 minutes which is totally possible (and would explain why you were so wiped out the next day), and your FTP is a bit lower still, or if that really is your FTP then you should work on extending your TTE, which will likely provide the foundation required for lifting your FTP.
