Help Us Track AI FTP Prediction Drops After Outside Workouts

I think you could look at this whole summer of riding outside. I was training for leadville so I was riding outdoors April - August and the predicted FTP always dropped about 30 points over the course of each 4 week block, usually pretty dramatically during the last week (close to my starting FTP). I was pretty strict about following the training plan. I’m not sure how tight the margins are to qualify for failing a workout but the most obstruction would be a tight corner or passing someone that was obstructing the trail.

I am planning to start taking screenshots of predictions so I can submit a form (unless there is a way to retrospecively look at each days prediction). I honestly just thought this was how the prediction model works until I saw this thread.

Submitting a form would be great as it sounds like you were definitely running into this bug.

No need to screenshot everything. The team should be able to find what it needs.

I think we’re really close to getting a fix out for this, so hang in there.

Welcome to the forum, by the way! :partying_face:

@eddie Thanks for the detailed response. It is appreciated! The workouts are feeling pretty appropriate in general, with an occasional one feeling a little easier than the AI predicted. As of today, the last two workouts have been predicted to be hard to very hard, but felt more consistent with TR’s definition of moderate, and I rated them accordingly. Today’s in particular, I actually substituted a harder workout than AI chose (partly because I missed my last endurance ride due to life stuff) and it still felt easier than predicted. I’m happy with the increase, just learning to deal with the inflated number at the beginning of the cycle and not really expect to end up there. That said, so far the most recent prediction seems to be holding pretty steady, so we’ll see what happens. I did submit a form, but not with this data. Should I submit another and include it? Thanks for your help!

If any of your answers on the form would be different enough, then go ahead.

Yes, I’ve had to recommend a few other athletes to pick harder workouts from the alternates list in order to get the most appropriate workouts.

If you find that you’re consistently getting workouts that aren’t hard enough, that could be a good option for the time being.

Stay in tough and let me know how things evolve from here. I’m hoping we get a fix in place for this really soon.

Thanks for all your feedback! :handshake:

I can’t even begin to fathom how ready you are for this to be resolved. It’s a truism that nobody calls support because everything is working great, but this year has been next level.

Is there actually a fix coming or are you just hoping one is? This has been on TR’s radar for the better part of a year now with no resolution and it’s at the point where renewing the sub will not be worthwhile for many people.

I know this bug is a priority and binds some (but not all) resources…but it would be very nice and engaging to get some hints / teasers / insights from TR about some real new stuff and features being worked on. Besides this bug (and a hint about more granular RPE options which is a tiny nice change but no exciting feature) the engagement here and the platform have become a bit pale and stale.

I know you’re not allowed to share but maybe @Nate_Pearson could chime in here or on the podcast. With the release of TR AI @Nate_Pearson teased a more regular appearance in the podcast but that never materialized and now just feels like a PR stunt.

Honestly I think the podcast and this forum have become kind of boring and pale compared to the engagement and positive vibes from some years ago. I write this with positive intentions towards TR, you might want to share this internally (even though I think it’s not news to you).

@mjw0 Yes, I am ready. :melting_face:

@rusnak167 There is a fix on the way. It’s a big one, which is why it has taken a while. I’ve seen some really exciting things in a few recent meetings and I cannot wait for them to start leaking out. I think you’ll hear about it from someone very soon. :zipper_mouth_face: :crossed_fingers:

@Rizzi I’m sharing your message with the team. Keep poking us. I think you’ll hear back soon. :grin:

I very much agree with this.

Just for added context, I believe there is also an issue with indoor TR workouts completed on Zwift.

Maybe @eddie can confirm this?

This may or may not be relevant for you but I’m just adding it for context.

I agree that the only way to know if iTR AI works for you is to try it.

This is funny. Today I completed an intensity outside workout. Uploaded and marked hard on my survery. AIFTP prediction for this upcoming Wednesday moved from 296 to 295. Opened my calendar a few hours later, and the prediction had decreased to 290. :man_facepalming:

Hopefully the fix will come soon, I am very curious what else will be there when it is so big. Then you have me as a subscriber again.

Good news! I held on to a 294 FTP. One thing that might have helped was a tip from the help desk to enter post workout surveys for unscheduled rides. As an avid bike-commuter, I have a lot of rides that fall outside of my plan.

I do all of my structured intervals indoors and my outdoor rides are the zone1 or zone2 variety. So not a rare use case, but figured I add my data point.

Most often the outdoor workouts are either a planned dynamic long ride that I 90% of the time Idon’t load the workout on my head unit and just keep the ride in the prescribed power ranges as best I can (like shoot to push 75% for long sections with 55-60% for sections also etc). I rate the outdoor ride RPE and I think usually it is “matched to workout”… I have not noticed any change to my aiFTP prediction after… just seems to be pretty spot on. Maybe it changes a 1w up or down based on how well I held high zone2 sections.

Perhaps it is being rolled into TR AI version 2.0?

I think a big opportunity would be for AI to be able to create and adapt the training plan, rather than being in charge of only workout selection within an existing plan structure.

Sometimes I think “is it worth it” I have been doing mostly indoor rides too!

Oof. Have you tried playing with the volume settings?

I am not sure what you mean? I have tried several things incluiding cnaging volume over the last year but I get a promise at the start of a month of a higher predictive FTP but it goes down if I veer at all from the programme either adding or changing it. After many years at TR I think I need change tact and do less structure and less of the dreaded intervals and enjoy more group rides with the odd interval when I want.

Well I wasn’t implying anything, just trying different settings on the plan to see if you can get an increase.

Nothing wrong with bailing on structure and doing group rides … unless getting faster is your main objective!

Instead of doing TR year round I’m planning to do structure until spring then commute and club rides and structure on running.

I don’t think I’ve ever heard TR promise a predicted FTP.