48 hour rule podcast confusion

I just listened to the 26 minute podcast where Jonathan talks about two versus three hard workouts a week. It became clear on the podcast that three leads to better bike fitness. I’m now confused because I’ve been using plan maker for several years and it’s only giving me two hard workouts a week. I’m in my 50s so that probably explains it, but I’m in excellent shape and think I recover very quickly for someone my age. Im disappointed that AI can’t see this and maximize my gains with 3 hard rides suggested.

Are you using a “Masters” Plan?

I am. But I still want to maximize my fitness

Masters plans are only 2 hard workouts per week.

How many hours are you doing currently?

Indoors -3

Outdoors - 4

You could try one of the plans with 3 hard workouts a week and see how that changes things.

TR ai does not change the number of hard days per week that I am aware of.

When choosing masters variant of the plan you are basically telling ai that you need more recovery and slower progression. No system except your super natural brain would know that you can handle more. TR is doing exactly what is supposed to do.

Key to understanding this is knowing what is and is-not AI.

The workout picker is AI - it takes the information on your calendar about what type of workout is planned and picks the best one depending on your current fitness and level of fatigue. When this works correctly (as it always has for me) it’s like magic.

The plans themselves are not AI driven though, they’re templates that the athlete can swap around and alter as they please - adding volume or altering the number of intense workouts.

Also the AI does not control volume. The “check volume” function is required to be enacted separately.

The AI does not tell you if you would be better on a 2 intense day or 3 intense day plan - that is also an athlete driven choice.

The AI also does not control the red/yellow days - that uses classic tss-related rules. The AI fatigue management is more subtle - slightly easing off intensity of workouts as required.

Basically the AI will maximise your gains based on what you tell it you want to do.

That is super helpful. Thanks for the explanation

You could change to a non Masters Plan and adjust the recovery slider if you felt you needed more recovery and see what happens

One thing to consider - 3 hard days might not maximize your fitness. It might be too much and you might start failing workouts, resulting in worse fitness than 2 hard days.

Depends on the individual, their age, volume, what they’re doing off the bike, a whole bunch of things.

Try it out, see if it works for you, but just keep it in the back of your head 2 might end up being better.

As I have gotten older I have found that two days between hard efforts works really well for me. (And as a running coach have found it works really well with developing high school athletes as well). This may mean some weeks there are three hard workouts others two.

At 70 I’ve belatedly come to the same conclusion.

Great points. I’ll stick my neck out of the window here and add one assumption I have: in order to confirm your quick recovery after a hard day, TR would need to use data such as your resting heart rate, sleep quality and HRV. They don’t have it in their models. Happy for anyone to tell me otherwise.

I think on the non-technical side - they could just ask a quick survey of how rider’s feel… how do your legs feel? (burn going up stairs or tieing shoes, stiff/sore, DOMS?) how do you feel overall fatigued/dragging/badshape? 0-10 feel? etc - just like a real coach could ask and adjust with.

This could work. I know they do show some smileys before each workout asking for your motivation (or something similar), but that’s already when the workout is about to start.