What are your unpopular cycling opinions?

Yet almost all frames are actually handmade.

Joe

4 Likes

Back in my day we just called it stretching! LOL.

Yeah I guess I just don’t find that compelling enough to watch on YouTube. I did go back and peruse the channel history to refresh my memory and he’s obviously an experienced cyclist. I’m really surprised after practically living on his bike for several years that he struggled with DK200, I would think someone who tours that much would have no problem with the longer distances.

Anyway, leaving this topic now because I’m not trying to jump all over PLP. Everyone can ride their bike how they desire.

3 Likes

I’ve got a soft spot in my heart for Vegan Cyclist. He kind of acknowledges that he’s a bit of a tool, but it’s hard to hate on ‘your boy.’ Just watched his UnboundXL video. As a piece of content, it’s really, really well done (footage and editing).

12 Likes

His content has gotten really good over the years. The Impossible Ride series he’s doing with Jeremiah Bishop is phenomenal.

5 Likes

There’s the unpopular opinion that finally annoyed me :rofl:

3 Likes

Mission accomplished.

1 Like

Yeah, I know a lot of factories in Taiwan are still hand making frames, so I dunno why the folks at the handmade festival are using that term to differentiate their stuff?. I know many commercial metal bikes are hand-welding, but these robots are probably really good at welding and could do a better job than I could with the TIG right now. I worked as a brazer making heat exchangers, and I thought about going into framebuilding but I couldn’t handle dealing with picky cyclists all day everyday. I became an ironworker/welder instead. I still ride carbon bikes though, and those are definitely hand made.

2 Likes

Custom frames are like the gluten free diet of bike production.

It’s a fantastic solution to a problem most people don’t have.

11 Likes

I think his video quality is quite good from a scenery capturing and ride perspective, but I do find him kind of hilariously annoying. Seeing him photo bomb an interview with Isabel King (on Delaney’s channel?) was a classic.

Also, “I’m blind in my left eye right now because of a concussion, but that’s OK. I’m used to it - your boy used to do MMA” or whatever is easily the most memorable line on cycling Youtube I’ve heard.

8 Likes

The current recipe thread is why so many people don’t like cyclists; someone makes a joke and every cyclist has to over-analyze it, explain why the OP is wrong and argue their mundane opinion :cry:

25 Likes

Right? I thought it was a pretty good analogy for a problem that’s brought up again and again here and on the podcast and lot of places. But it’s not a perfect model for all of training so we must correct it!

10 Likes

Same reasons restaurants all advertise “Homemade pie.” Words are meaningless :smiling_face_with_tear:

Ha I was thinking the same thing. The forum is almost becoming painful to visit because it’s just a bunch of arguing about why someone is wrong. The Keegan posts are the same. Nobody can be happy he’s a good bike racer because he’s not “world tour” or from Europe I guess. Can’t we just let the dude be good and dominate how he wants?

10 Likes

Mechanical shifting sucks

Come at me now :grin:

3 Likes

This reminds me of mine: the vast vast majority of people who claim that electronic is “far superior” to mechanical shifting had poorly setup mech setups. :stuck_out_tongue:

8 Likes

The need to think about 5+ batteries in preparation for longer rides sucks. :wink:

8 Likes

The only benefit of mechanical is not having to charge batteries every once in a while (hence why I use it on some bikes)…other than that I’ve recently learned that it merely takes a (new) cable not running well into the housing to significantly impact shifting quality apparently…so I’ll stick with my contrarian view on mechanical groups :stuck_out_tongue:

1 Like

I’ve known more people lose front / rear / all shifting with electronic gearing in the last two years than ever with mechanical shifting (that wasn’t a cable tension tweak to fix).

And in the worst case that a cable snaps, it’s pretty simply to jerry rig the rear derailleur to be stuck in a sensible gear rather than the 11 cog with mechanical.

Battery life is one thing but there seem to be an extra class of technical gremlins with Di2 & AXS. Mainly Di2 cables getting cut when people remove and replace their seatpost on a trip, but also general water ingress seem to be a problem for some.

4 Likes

Mechanical vs. Electronic is the Tubular vs. Clincher of yore.

6 Likes