What are your unpopular cycling opinions?

If only we could do this with Training Plans! :grin:

Sentyeh ECS. It’s awesome. Can run 12-14 speed cassettes. Though not many 14s cassettes exist so I run a SRAM 12s Force cassette and a 13s SRAM Force XPLR depending on the terrain. In the app you can do a global index but also micro index each gear if you want. Then you can save that info as a profile. So I can swap back and forth between 12s and 13s cassettes within 30 seconds. And in my short experience with it, it shifts maybe even smoother than SRAM, but below Shimano. It’s really nice. Can be had in AliExpress for like $450 right now (shifters, brakes, derailleur).

Just like wheels and frames, in another few years Chinese groupsets are going to be replacing the big Western brands. The fact that I can run 12s and 13s cassettes with the same shifters and derailleur, and the fact that once 14s comes out, I can still use the same group? That’s a killer feature. Makes you realize SRAM and Shimano could do the same thing but force you to buy a full groupset for no other reason than money. I don’t see myself buying a western brand groupset anytime soon.

Thanks. I’m not in the market but I will check them out. I am sure SRAM and Shimano are keeping a close eye on these competitors.

atm machine

That’s a cool feature and probably doesn’t require much effort to implement. And it would be nice if SRAM/Shimano gave more access the “backend” of their groupsets. Same goes for Flight Attendant where theyt could allow advanced users to tweak settings and behavior. The struggle that SRAM/Shimano would have implementing advanced configuration is the risk of giving users the ability to screw things up. The overwhelming majority of SRAM/Shimano business is OEM. It’s all about making it “just work” in a very specific way and minimizing the support burden across their huge customer base. Most people buy a bike with a groupset the same way they buy a car with a motor installed. People like us who are swapping parts between frames, tweaking gearing based on the course, etc. are like the people who are adding aftermarket parts on their cars and installing a “tune” to make them faster. It’s a thing, but it’s such a small part of the market that I can appreciate why SRAM/Shimano want to hide all that complexity from the user.

I wouldn’t be opposed to trying a groupset like that, but going with a fringe groupset does come with trade offs (particularly for electronic). Having authorized SRAM/Shimano dealers all over the world (and often at races) is worth something when you have a problem and need a quick fix. And 5+ years from now, what are the chances you can still buy batteries and get firmware updates for the no-name groupset? It’s cheaper and part of me wants to support new options in the market, but saving ~$500 compared to something like rival just isn’t personally worth it to me at this point. If they can make a legit impact in the market and build up proper support infrastructure, then it’s absolutely going to force SRAM/Shimano to respond. But really, until a no-name brand can reach critical mass and start shipping on complete bikes (ie - partnership with some of the up and coming brands like xlabs), I don’t see them making much noise.

Yea, that makes sense. The “easy” on paper but probably hard logistically is creating a dual system where bike shops would have more features and settings unlocked that could be tweaked. Or a training series that upon completion, gives to a code to “unlock” the system where you can now make more adjustments. Casual users would have no inclination to do the training or want to tweak their groups. If they did they could always go to the LBS and have them do it to maintain the warranty. And if any home mechanics wanted to go deeper they would be required to complete the training modules and/or knowingly give up their warranty.

But…on the other hand that’s a huge can of worms that I’m sure the big group makers don’t want to open and like you said, it’s easier to keep it closed so that everything just works.

Then you should be happy as there are always deals on 23 and 25mm tires/tubes.

Random question: have you ever been to Backyard Bike Shop?

I’ve a few bikes from the 2010s which are stuck on 25mm and I still love to ride them. Rim brakes, external routing, Dura Ace 7850 and 9000, just beautiful to work on and ride. People talk as if 25mm is like riding a masonry chisel, it’s not that bad on the road IMHO.

(Next time I’m back in Gateshead I plan to visit Backyard Bikes as I like Nick’s YouTube bike builds. Though I see he is laid up recovering from a massive gravel crash right now. I’m GeordieMullet by username, but living in Dubai currently, so Gateshead - the “Dubai of the North” - is a bit of a detour nowadays :wink: ).

Been riding mtb and gravel on current bikes but my road bike is a 2010 with 25mm tires, rim brakes, external routing, 10speed mechanical, and it all works great. I actually prefer the feel and performance of the rim brakes over the discs on my gravel bike. Shifting is clean and fast, both front and rear, and I’m actually doing it, not batteries, microprocessors, and motors.

My 2018 Cervelo won’t go past 28mm so I’m stuck there on my top end. Not too many sales on those sizes. I do think the tire size matters. I live in an area with horrendous roads, literally the worst I have ever ridden.

I, too, watch a lot of Nic’s build videos as well as other ones, such as his Swiss Epic ride with his friend Josh Reid. I don’t think Nic’s shop is under the bridge anymore, I think he was forced to move due to bridge work and is now in a smaller shop. I saw the posts of his accident and it looked awful. Not too mcuh info on his recovery after that.

As you can guess, I am from Sunderland but now in Texas. Slightly different. I am looking at doing a race/ride in the Northeast at some point as it seems the be the gravel capitol of the UK. I’d love to visit Nic’s shop if I go. I also watch quiet a lot of Mapdec videos, and they are based in the Lake District.

My 2006 steel Allez on 25’s floats along just fine. Yea, maybe a bit bouncy on chip and seal, but man, on smooth tarmac? Nothing better.

It’s like LinkedIn

Likely not unpopular: The whole SRAM vs Shimano debate is silly.

Maybe unpopular: The debate is silly because Campagnolo is objectively the best groupset out there.

Your talking about group sets with friction shifters correct???

Suntour FTW!

Jesus. I went away for 5 minutes and the unpopular opinion thread became the popular opinion thread :nerd_face:

They invented the slant parellelogram derailleur! The compact drive train! Command shifters! I’ll always have a soft spot for Suntour in their prime. And a grudge against Shimano for the anti-competitive practices that are clearly in the company’s DNA.

:saluting_face:
:slightly_smiling_face:

You gotta earn your bike. Not by being fast, but by being IN the sport. You want a nice bike, ride enough and know enough and then maybe, just maybe it’s OK to get one.

Edit: Expensive doesn’t equal nice.

Edit 2: E-bikes are excluded from the above opinion.

If all you ever do, is ride on a trainer; you are not cycling.