This is the point I am trying to make. With gravel, I don’t care what your FTP (1 hour) is, but rather what can you hold for 3-5 hours etc.
FTP should only be use to set power for FTP and SST work, not z2, not VO2 max, not anaerobic etc etc.
Gravel has embraced everything that it used to be against: elitism, gatekeeping, and arbitrary rules are rampant.
Agreed
True to a point, but it’s been trending away from this over the last 5 years in my experience. Many of the gravel races I do have evolved from small packs (or solo riders) on the road to larger groups with sprint finishes of 10-20 at the end. It’s still a lot of heavy pedaling compared to sitting in a group on pavement, but the speeds are going up in gravel and group dynamics are more significant. I think a better comp these days is classics racing rather than tt. There are fast sections where you save huge watts in the pack, but with a bunch of selective terrain sprinkled in. Attrition is still a big part of it, but pack skills and ability to sprint at the end have become increasingly important.
It’s also a question of how a person rides/races and the nature of the course. If your primary goal is completing the distance on a long “adventure race” format rather than trying to finish as fast as possible, it’s still going to be more like a solo/TT or TTT with a small group. At the big national bucket list races, that’s probably the majority of the field just doing their own thing. But for most of our smaller regional gravel races, they now play out more like road races from 10 years ago with big groups and road race dynamics (with all the good and bad that comes with it).
But they’re tied together. If your FTP is higher, your 3hr power is going to be higher. A rising tide raises all ships. If you can hold 80% FTP for 4 hours, then when your FTP increases so does that 80%.
-
Minimum effective dose.
-
It’s hard to predict the future.
-
I, for one, welcomed our AI overlords.
The Western bike industry doesn’t deserve saving and I think some brands going out of business is good for the overall health of the industry. Chinese brands can and should fill the need of reasonably priced bikes and groupsets. I think a big shakeup is due and might rattle some feathers but it’s the best thing for the industry. Prices have gotten out of hand and we need more Chinese brands undercutting the Western market to force them to compete.
I realize this is an unpopular opinions thread I hope it’s ok to discuss still ![]()
I just don’t see how more jobs going away will improve the industry. Sure you win short term with cheaper stuff, but mid term ppl lose their jobs, move to lower owing ones, have less disposable income ==> can’t afford even the “cheap”.
Maybe if that was only the bike industry. But it seems to be all industries atm.
Yea I meant it more that it would hopefully help all of the ridiculous pricing. The big brands charging $15,000 for a bicycle is wild. If Specialized loses millions from their yearly profit I wouldn’t really care. If Trek or ENVE had to downsize I wouldn’t really mind. If SRAM or Shimano report losses I wouldn’t lose sleep over it. To me the industry as it is needs a shakeup. Yea that might mean bad times for some people in the short term, but hopefully better in the long term for more. Maybe it forces some of the western brands to change and adapt rather than maintain the status quo as it were and continue to raise prices. I know I’m looking to build a new bike and can do so for fractions of what Western brands are charging. And you can now have Western quality for a tenth of the price. The newest generation of groupsets is on par with Western brands and even offer features that put them ahead. Western brands don’t have the better quality sell that they used to. You can get the same quality or better for a quarter of the price.
To your question about job losses. Sure it sucks. Yes people might lose their job. And speaking of industries where people should lose their job I wish the whole AI industry would just crash and burn but I’ll try to stay on topic. Yes, it would be bad. But I think it’s a necessary bad to ensure a better future for the bike industry. You have to crack a few eggs to make an omelet as they say. Honestly it’s not great either way. Either the industry keeps getting more out of hand or people lose their jobs and the whole industry resets. Both kind of suck.
I will never buy a Chinese knock off frameset. Or components, groupsets or wheels.
Point;
Counterpoint;
I am retired and on a fixed income. I built 2 bikes with Chinese frame sets. I could not afford the big name frame sets.
People should stop complaining about AI training programs.
Just hire a coach if you want a program tailored to you.
Yep. Shimano is def on par with western brands.
What about Chinese frames, groupsets, and wheels that aren’t knockoffs?
When any industry is broken, it’s usually better to pull the bandaid off and fix things in a disruptive way. Some companies will reinvent themselves and survive/thrive, but the ones that aren’t willing & able to make dramatic changes will be gone. Trying to incrementally make improvements to a fundamentally broken model just prolongs the suffering. If you have a job on a sinking ship, it can often be better to lose that job to force yourself to go find one in a better space rather than waiting for it to go under.
As Specialized would say - “Innnovate or die”. But innovation can’t just be about flashy new bike tech and marketing, it’s just as much (or more) about business model, manufacturing, and supply chain efficiency.
Or… you can always buy last years model used from someone who upgrades every year! ![]()
- I, for one, welcomed our AI overlords.
That’s right. The Joes welcome them. We all should.
My local lbs carries X-Lab. In 3 months they’ve sold over 70.
What groupset are you using? Shimano Ultegra Di2 is pretty cheap these days and Rival can be had on deals frequently. I can see buying a frame but a groupset? No thanks.
AI is not ready yet to take the lead autonomously in most applications, including for something as complex as individualising training plans for athletes, amateur or professional.
Where AI does excel is as an assistant to make suggestions/recommendations that the user can approve or not. When it’s clearly wrong it must be simple for the user to overrule.
Within a couple of years AI might be ready but it’s not for certain yet - the last yard being the most difficult etc
[not sure how unpopular an opinion that is, but not universally agreed I guess]