What are your unpopular cycling opinions?

Oooh, ouch.

I agree. I have used the ski erg and row machine at the gym. I don’t go around calling myself a rower or a Nordic skier. It is just exercise.

Your are pedalling :sweat_smile:.

I think the unpopular opinion here would be that you are a cyclist if you only ever ride the trainer

“What you do is not good enough for you to be called a cyclist, what I do is.”

We’re two steps away from what I call radical extremist cyclism.

This immediately made me think of the movie Gran Turismo, the true story of Jann Mardenborough.

Guy plays and masters world’s most realistic car racing video game.

Guy is given opportunity to drive a real race car.

Guy applies skills learned from video game to win races and become true professional race car driver.

Prior to getting into the car, he was a master of his craft in one realm and had great potential to extend his craft into another. I don’t think it would be considered elitist to say he wasn’t a race car driver before he was actually piloting a car down the road with some skin in the game. But it would be silly not to admit he had incredible talent and potential.

“It depends upon what the meaning of the word ‘is’ is."

So what you’re saying is, a Zwifter doesn’t become a cyclist until they ride outside on a real bike.

I’d say that applies to any stationary bike rider. Being a cyclist comprises propelling, balancing, steering and maneuvering a moving bike. It wouldn’t necessarily have to be outdoors. An indoor velodrome could count. Just pedaling a stationary bike doesn’t.

Is there a time limit ?

Let’s say at 6 years old you rode your schwinn a lot . Time goes on and your kids are having kids and your butt has not seen a saddle in 50 years.

Are you still a cyclist?

:thinking:

No. But you “used to be” a cyclist.

What about that form of gymnastics performed on a bicycle?

Artist

I think this wins the thread for the most unpopular opinion :laughing: at least in my book. Well done!

The interesting part to this is that I bet most of the “not cyclist” people would probably agree they’re not cyclists. My wife rides a peloton bike for exercise. I know for a fact she doesn’t consider herself a cyclist. She even owns bib shorts and cycling shoes, but she’s not a cyclist, she exercises. Heck, I bet most of them don’t want to be labeled a cyclist, at least here in America.

Now perhaps more of the Zwifter crowd likes to think of themselves as cyclists, so I’m not sure where we draw the line. If you ride Zwift all day on your Zwift Ride or Wahoo Kickr Bike and don’t even own a real bicycle can you call yourself a cyclist? If I own an indoor rowing machine do I call myself a rower?

But at the end of the day, does it really matter if I’m a cyclist or not? If a person rides Zwift all day, does it affect the world if they call themselves a Zwifter or a cyclist or just a guy that exercises?

Depends on the context.

Riding rollers indoors ticks most of those boxes, but the “movement” isn’t really going anywhere. I do all my indoor training/riding/racing on rollers and it’s a pretty decent proxy for “cycling” when you are riding/racing with others in Zwift. I’d personally consider zwifting (stationary or on rollers) to be a flavor of cycling, it’s got too many cycling elements to just call it exercise IMO.

It ticks off one, balancing, and then only restricted to one situation, upright on rollers.