Thanks Ryan. I’ve looked at a number of units and the H3 sure seems to stand out. Got a new road bike on the way so likely will grab one early next year. Thanks for the post!
So did a one hour workout on trainer road. Couple of observations… On literally the very first half pedal stroke there was a grinding noise, so literally like one second, but the rest of the workout was pretty smooth sailing.
of note:
- Using the small chainring made it feel not quite as smooth as my old kickr which I always used in the big ring. I could feel a tiny bit of pulsating? Just not as smooth as if the flywheel had been up to speed via the large chainring.
- On very short, hard intervals, like 10 seconds at 460 watts, the trainer doesn’t get you up to the target wattage because it takes its time climbing up to it. Not a big deal to me, but noted.
Well Saris support is awesome. My H3 as I posted earlier was making a clicking noise even when not pedaling. It still works fine just the noise.
They are sending me a new unit via fedex and a pre-paid return label. No back and forth and hassles. Too notch in my opinion.
To your points
- You’re comparing one trainer in the large ring to another in the small ring. They all feel less “smooth” in the small ring, and you hear/feel pulsing and some vibration. Try the H3 in the big ring and its much more buttery
- If you crop the file after the ride and let’s say your 10 second interval is from 4:00-4:10, highlight from 4:02 to 4:12 and you’ll be right on the power. It takes 2 seconds or so longer to ramp up, and also 2 seconds or so longer to ramp down, so all its really doing is shifting your interval over 2-3 seconds but when you see your “scores” on the screen, they are not adjusted for this ramp up and down.
on point 2, at least on Kickr 2017 I’ve found it possible to hit short 5 / 10 /20 second targets. It is a skill, some discussion about it here:
and secondly “what @Cleanneon98 said”
Regarding personal preferences on small vs large chainring, as a counterpoint to Chad’s small vs large list I’m going to give you my Large vs Small pros:
- large chainring gives same FTP as outside rides
- large feels more like riding outside (small ring feels unnatural)
- large challenges you to work on a smooth pedal stroke
Small chainring is quieter, however noise in large ring hasn’t been an issue for me. No one has proven hitting precise targets in Erg is better. In fact all of my biggest fitness gains involve doing interval work outside. Cycling is a sport where large power variations are the rule. The large ring is closer to riding outside in my experience of doing long climbs and a lot of riding in the windy flats. There is genuine difference of opinion on “climbing feel” of large vs small, so not everyone will agree with my experience.
Just did another ride, this time in big ring. Felt smoother and everything seemed to work OK. That said, I don’t have a power meter on my bike to compare wattages, but I’m not too concerned about it. I’ll do a ramp test soon to set my ftp for this trainer, so as long as its consistent moving forward, all good. ![]()
My recommendation is to pick either big or little, and stick with it. Whatever feels “right” is a good way to pick if you aren’t comparing to outside power!
Large ring for me all the way. When I tried the small ring way back I felt like I was pedaling so slow. I know this is not the case just like the feel of the large ring much better.
Just an update for you all. Received my new trainer from saris support including a prepaid back. Took it for a couple of rides already and it works flawlessly. Build date was 12/9/19.
I realize it is early but Saris CS was top notch so if I do have problems I know I am in good hands.
Picked up my h3 from montana on the 23rd. Used it in montana on the 23rd, Canada the night of the 23rd, the 24th and 25th. So quiet I dont have to turn anything up. Its awesome so far. Have only used the small ring so far. It’s on my rocker plate and that is taking some time to get used to again as I’ve been using rollers.
Same situation here. New unit should arrive Friday.
The initial high torque squeal went away before I got a chance to fix it, but recently I’ve got a loud clicking, though not every ride.
Emailed a video of the sound to support along with proof of purchase and they shipped a new unit. No questions asked.
Bummed to have issues with expensive kit but can’t fault the customer service.
The new one has been flawless and really like the trainer. Issues are bound to happen on any product but it is what the company does and how they stand behind it really for me is what makes a customer for life.
I got my H3 a couple of weeks ago, and now have a number of rides on it. Power seems in line with both sets of pedals I have, but the trainer does seem to do some smoothing (or maybe that is just a part of the way measurement is done. It is quite, and while I did have some creaking from hard starts the first few times I tried it, those have gone away and I have not been able to reproduce those recently. Erg mode is very smooth which I have very happy with.
Overall I’m quite happy with it. Hopefully it will be more long-term reliable than my kickr that it is replacing.
Picked up an H3 two and a half weeks ago. Coming from the original hammer, the H3 is a massive improvement. For me, the noise reduction is the biggest improvement.
My one complaint is that I can feel “slipping” in the resistance pickup when doing hard starts/sprints (set on ERG mode). Anyone else have this issue?
Two week check in, I’ve done a few trainer road rides on my H3 now. Other than about 2 seconds of a sort of dragging sound during the first couple pedal strokes of each ride, it has worked flawless. I haven’t done any hard sprints on it, just basic erg stuff on TR. I don’t have another power meter to compare it to, but I really don’t care about that as long as it is consistent with itself. I settled on using the big ring and middle of cassette as it feels very smooth. I can live with some of the power numbers maybe not being as accurate on the big chainring (higher flywheel speed), just want decent consistent workouts. ![]()
So I got an answer from Saris about the upper pulley
The part about the belt growing side to side sounds like it makes sense, but it doesn’t because the belt would actually get narrower (look at a funny car doing a burnout in the pits and watch the tires balloon and get narrow when they spin up) but then again it doesn’t since they still made the lower pulley ribbed.
Also their analogy of “designing trainers to withstand a few thousand watts, not a few hundred horsepower” is comically bad since the trainer is rated to 2000w which isn’t even 3 horsepower.
I finally got my H2 updated with the latest version of Saris Android app (1.0.39) with 7.1.1 Android on board.
Question for all: Do you perform re-calibration after trainer firmware update?
Thanks! It worked. I calibrate the trainer every other workout and will do so after update just to be sure.
I’d think that it’s a good idea.
Do you have some sort of vibration with additional noise in ERG mode on your H2 when resistant is changed from 100W to e.g. 200W on the small ring at the front?
When target resistant is taken for couple of seconds then those “vibration” get a little smaller.
Looks like big ring at the front is not affected or at least there are additional vibration going due to bigger flywheel speed…
