Polarized Training Discussion (Fast Talk podcast & Flo Cycling podcast)

w/r to TID I find it actually more revealing to look at actual power output distribution. In the zone distributions Zone 1 is inflated by coasting or “almost-coasting” which is simply part of riding outdoors. I don’t think those threr bar pairs to the left are actual sessions with the intention of riding slow.

While it does get inflated the average IF is still only .6. The full download is on my work computer but many power charts do not include zero with z1, giving null power its own bucket. Strava is the only one i know that includes 0-x in the distribution chart. Meanwhile there is a null grouping.

To combine some of the pro/elite thread posts you started here, michi weiss was doing his long rides around 200-220 watts for something like 4 to 5 hours for his base period. That’s like a very fit age group athlete riding at like 160 watts. For him, that should be around z1 to very low z2.

Also correct me if I’m wrong but most elite men at the international level are pushing 6w/kg right?

Depends on weight and rider type. Tyler Farrar was a grand tour stage winner, but was only a little over 4 w/kg at FTP. Taylor Phinney is about 5/kg, but when you weigh 85kg, that’s a whole lot of watts…

A lot of this comes back to sustainable training load. A 5 w/kg rider training 10-12 hours a week can probably tolerate an average IF of .8 for three or four weeks. Bump up to 25 hours a week and that IF plummets to .6 – or, that rider trains into a hole.

It reminds me of what Weber said about Tony Martin, in the context of sustainable training load. For Tony Martin, .7 is 300 watts. 6 hours at 300w? That’s Paris-Roubaix – so he’s not going to try that on a weekly basis, let alone on a daily one.

When I was in my 20s (and, from where I am at 53, I’d guess maybe 5.4 w/kg) I got the chance to train with some pro riders – doing one five or six hour ride with them was “easy” (or so it felt). Doing two in a row was hard. Doing three was impossible. But they would do that five or six days in a row…

That is helpful. Especially as I am facing a long old ride tomorrow and I can feel myself procrastinating already. 68% sounds way more fun than 0.70 IF.

Can I just check, HR Max is sport specific, not the HR max I’ve recorded for any exercise? I might be repeating the question, but I want to make sure I’ve got it right.

So my running max is 194, my cycling is 184. For my long ride it I should be shooting to keep my HR between 125 and 134 i.e. 68% - 73% of my cycling HRmax.

Then here’s that other question… Is that training intensity the magic bullet (i.e. promotes aerobic adaptions), or just being able to handle high volume of training. I suspect a bit of both, so people who say you have to train a s-ton when doing low intensity are forgetting the context… You have to train at a load that is right for you when doing lower intensities. If you are going from 10-12 hours at high intensity, you will probably not see much adaptions doing 10-12 hours of low intensity, but if you bump it up a few hours you’ll start to see those positive developments. Sometimes people throw out doing volume as an either or situation, but there should be a spectrum based on previous training history… many younger athletes cannot hang with the large volumes professional riders do, and it can take them several years to build up to that sort of workload.

your true max is probably rarely reached in training. Depends on the race type to generate it, or there are protocols to try and figure it out. Mostly it’s something along the lines of doing 3 or 4 minute VO2max style intervals on low rest, then for the last one you do 1 minute FULL gas, as hard as you can go and that should be your best estimate for sport specific max.

At risk of being Captain Obvious…

My time in zone (power) chart looks a lot like figure D. Except my total time is estimated at 1/3 to 1/4 of a pro’s week. So… how much of what we are seeing in pro training logs is first burning 2,000 calories “just riding tempo” for a few hours before or after doing the work bouts (intervals) for their day?

Since I never have to perform after riding 4-5 hours of tempo, because my races are TTs of 10-25 miles which start after a 15-20 min warm-up, I’m never going to take the start line (or hit a hard race effort) in a depleted state.

The questions we keep seeming to come back to for “regular Joe’s” are:

a) What’s your potential so you know how close you are to extracting max performance?
b) What’s the optimal training plan for 8 hours a week?
c) What’s the potential gain if I somehow manage to get to 16 hours a week or 20+ hours a week (and of course what are the best plans for 16 and 20+ – e.g loop back to B)?

All of this “what the pro’s do” seems somewhat not useful other than for fun. I’m struck by a comment in one of the podcasts (paraphrased): “When you see certain training and diet plans remember those methods were to extract the last 1% of potential performance from a single specific athlete, not a recommendation for other athletes”. Essentially saying: you aren’t Froome or Sagan so don’t replicate their training.

After about a year of really interesting discussion, it seems to me the recipe for Joe’s returns to:

  • One to two good structured interval workouts per week during the work week
  • Long tempo rides on the weekends for as long as you can fit in (3-5 hours)
  • Pick a reasonable plan and be as compliant as possible in sticking to it
  • Work toward actual riding at FTP (MLSS) for a real hour (durability, resilience, etc)

If you aren’t working, or are amazingly motivated and able to add time… the prescription of 1-2 hard workouts a week still stands, then you add a lot more time in Z2 and reap those benefits.

*** Looking forward to the ML/AI analysis of TR logs when that finally comes out.

-Mark

We also need to remember that there’s more than one reasons why the pros train as they do, e.g. Pol.

Yes, they do have to train to perform after a high level of kJ depletion but that same depletion (aka Endurance work) is also developing a strong aerobic system which provides the basis for (and greatly contributes to) most other levels of intensity.

So even if you (or any of us) personally are never having to race past a state of depletion, a ‘pro style’ aerobic development will still greatly serve your 20mi TT efforts.

That said, Joe Average can still adapt and apply the same kJ depletion training to his/her own specific situation.

I did an hour of power on the indoor trainer by setting off at just below FTP for the first 10 min in erg mode, then upping the % of FTP intensity to FTP for minutes 11-45. From min 45-60 I had to adjust the intensity back down to 99%, when my cadence dropped from the previous 90 rpm average down to 84 rpm.

Yeah, we dont’ get to see when they are applying those power in relation to the segment of their ride. From the many posts @sryke has posted, many of the pros are doing significant tempo periods in their longer rides. I think that long distance athletes also do more of a periodization strategy with regards to intensity distribution than the athletes Seiler has studied for the polarized model. Also, he usually only studies VO2 max increase, while fractional utilization is a big part of race specificity for cyclists, but not quite as important for athletes doing 10-50 minute races.

it’s all about building a huge Turbo-Diesel. May it be for a 3-weeks-stage race or 280K one day classic. The one who dies the least wins, all about fatigue resistance. And Tempo/SST within longish rides seems to be the method applied, even at this time of the year. Last 3 years for a pro tour team leader, rode in Monteal last week, now back in Europe.

The only exception is Valverde. He just rides with his buddies. Day in, day out. Group ride after group ride. No apparent structure.

a new one, stage race domestique, Jan/Feb 2019. Threshold is pretty easy to figure out …

No idea what all those charts mean, but you definitely have the correct number of tabs open. :stuck_out_tongue:

I have a question… If I’m following tr lv progression of standard plans From base to build to specialty… am i making A mistake? I honestly am so burnt out on this theory shit right now… I’ve been tracking my time in zones and find that the tr plans do in fact stay away from the Coggan tempo zone Soo aren’t the tr plans mostly in agreement with polarized? With the caveat that tr plans make the claim that heart rate is not a good reliable marker for how your muscles are performing? I think tr should invent a special implant that we can put under our skin which measures lactate and reports via Bluetooth to software. Then we cyclists would have a much better picture of how we are recruiting our muscles.

the other caveat is that the TR LV plans do probably apply more of a 50/50 approach between the z1 and z3 in the 3-zone system.

4 hours on a trainer is hard core

I’ve also done a couple over 5 hours and they are no joke. Wrecked me for a couple of days after.

Zwift gives a special jersey for a ride over 100 miles so you can show off your badassery on the island.

I’ve just stumbled across this paper which says that one way of determining LT1 is to do a variety of 8 minute sub-maximal tests. I just wondered if anyone else had seen it or would like to have a read and comment on it.

Interesting! And I knew it, we all come boack to good old Conconi! Well, not really but reminds me a little bit of the early 90s.

Will definitiely give it try, seems pretty easy to implement. Would approach it slightly different.

The only caveat: they had folks do 60rpm cadence. This is low. I can tell from my observations that heart rate is quite impacted by cadence. We can’t say for sure that the PD relationship holds for more realistic rpms as well. Furthermore, those threshold wattages in Table 1 are low. And then, young men. Does this hold for masters as well?

Finally, this paper hasn’t been cited once by any other paper. Does not have to mean anything but this is always a little bit odd.

From the discussion:

grafik

HOWEVER: while this may be interesting from an academic perspective, personally I don’t see the value of knowing LT1 or LT2. There is no clear anwser on how to train these thresholds. Should you stay well below LT1 to train it? Or at LT1? Or slightly above it because you actually have to stress it in order to see improvements? Or a mix of the three?

The cacophony of different belief systems is testament for this lack of clear evidence.

No need to implement it for me, I just carry on with my training.