Legacy Pricing of TR

Yes! I totally appreciate the feedback.

You’re right, there’s always more to do.

When we release features, we make decisions on “will this add value”? The tough part about that is there is always more value to release.

For AT, we are 100% sure based on our metrics that there is a huge improvement for the vast majority of our athletes (even masters riders). We even had a 70+ year old rider who was stuck at an FTP for years raise it 20 watts and win a national championship and he credits AT.

When we look at what features to build, we think about how big of an impact it will make. For running, we know how many of our athletes do run activities based on Garmin/Strava sync. It’s about 20%. So a decent amount.

For AT, we know that 89% of our athletes are using some part of it.

For AT work, we had to decide how to prioritize features against other ones. We made the decision that AT was needed to have the foundation of the other features you’re talking about (different duration per day of week, different intensity per day of week, different rest/recovery periods, automatically changing intra-week intensity based on performance).

We could have waited to launch AT until we did all of those features. But if we did that, we’d have the same people on the forum complain that we didn’t get anything out (which was happening just before AT launched because it was such a big feature and took a while).

For the planning team, their current priority is to get AI FTP Detection out. We chose this because of the implementation lift (relatively easy, hard ML part was already done) and the number of athletes we see in our database has improper FTPs because they don’t assess. And we know that 75% of the athletes that do assess are very interested in using our AI FTP Detection.

Please PM these to me and I’ll ask more questions and/or we can do a call.

I read most of the thread but … 812 posts so might have missed some.

I am on $99/ year and have been a member for a number of years. There have been times where I have had ~6 months gaps when having a new baby etc. but have kept my membership because I am grandfathered. I would have canceled otherwise and restarted when I was back training. I also like supporting TR in general because it seems like a great company, which I cant really say about any company other than my favorite café locally.
BUT!
I do see that the value I am getting for $99/year is INCREDIBLE. I have had some experience with personal coaches, and those plans were $100-200 per month and for me TR was the better option.

If Nate were to provide one or two tiers of pricing that would be fine with me but I would prefer to just have one level so I can try stuff like group workouts. I don’t use it much and wouldn’t pay for it individually, but I like having the option in my subscription. I would rather pay more to have the new features expedited and quality of existing improved.

There are always cost limitations for each person, so if the TR cost changed to $500/year I would need to weigh the options but at the current costs $180-$200 a year for TR i would have no problem losing my status to see new features implemented faster and better and support TR.

Love what you guys are doing, and the open communication to the community.

*I also believe that Nate wasn’t trying to mislead anyone by saying the cost wouldn’t increase. Times change and I can’t imagine any other company providing this level of transparency and apologizing that they may be changing what they had previously promised.

Everything is there, you don’t lose your history. I did a couple of winter seasons in 2014/15 and 2015/16 and can see my workouts and data in the calendar. Obviously you start on a new plan, etc. Not sure how AT will handle it.

Good point. Interestingly, Apple ended up paying a $113 million dollar consumer fraud settlement over some of those “bugs”.

The post you quoted said unfulfilled promise. Not a broken one.

Not sure why you are saying we’re taking a post out of context when bryce said point blank

“You will be able to import swim and run workouts just like outdoor rides”

Not, we think that’s a cool idea, we’ll think about it.

  • True for that one, but “broken promise” has been mentioned specifically about the R/S feature discussion by others. Getting into semantics here, which distracts from the point.
  • Was there a promise or delivery date attached?

That statement may yet be true once they release whatever they do, whenever they do.

Legacy user since 2013. I do most of my training Nov thru May. At 99$ it was not worth going monthly. I definitely do not use all the TR features. I DO love TR, the podcast, and the crew. Not that any of this really matters, but I help coach the local nica team, any kids that want to train offseason, I recommend TR. Same goes to my biker friends. I think I’ve sent out 10 referral codes, and have at least 6 fellow bikers on the program right now. Peace.

I was watching this video earlier and it made me think of this thread and a lot of sentiment expressed… particularly 2min 50s onwards. Yes I know Shane doesn’t mean TR but I couldn’t help thinking of this and what many users have commented on and complained about.

it would be interesting to have a demographic breakdown of the feedback in this thread

Sort of. I suppose. But are people purchasing TR based on promises of future features or based on what TR currently is?

Nate and the TR fairly transparent about a lot of the features they’re working on. Obviously some they keep a bit secret for as long as possible but in their podcast they have lots of open discussions about ideas they may or may not come to fruition.

I’ve been using TR since 2014 and always find it to be a great product.

I was listening to TR Podcast 317 today (one of my personal favourites) and in it Nate and the team talk about the best way to make yourself faster and they all agree the best way to make yourself faster is by getting fitter. I totally buy into this and know lots of people that have tried to buy speed by investing in expensive equipment. I don’t have the luxury of throwing lots of money at expensive kit, that’s why I choose to invest in my training through TR.

It seems strange that a company like TR, who’s aim is to make everyone fast is contemplating changing that ethos too, we’ll make everyone faster, but those that can afford it even faster, through the following extras…

I know they need to make money in order to reinvest in development, but couldn’t they do it in other ways? In the same Podcast they talk about how often you change your bibs. Could they not develop a clothing line that TR members could purchase, after all, we all need to replace our training kit.

TR, I think the product is great and I love the idea of getting faster, so please keep up the good work. But don’t exclude the less affluent.

Definition of promise: “A declaration or assurance that one will do a particular thing or that a particular thing will happen.”

TR has made multiple assurances that we would be able to import other activities into the calendar ever since the calendar was released. While you may be technically correct in that no specific time frame was given, many of those assurances did come with statements similar to Nate’s earlier in this thread that “road maps are opening up”, clearly suggesting that we would only have to wait a little longer. I have renewed my membership a number of times based on those kinds of “assurances” from TR staff. I’m sorry, but I’ve grown far too tired of so many “assurances” from TR that have drug on for years to not roll my eyes when the CEO again states, “road maps are opening up” in reference to these issues. Promise or no promise, TR has lost all credibility with this subscriber. I wish you the best. I’m done with this discussion, and I’m done with TR.

I think it’s not about leaving because the price hits $X (thought that’s certainly a factor). For me it’s more about, as the price increases for TR, it becomes less of a no-brainer to keep it and shopping around makes sense.

that should not come as a surprise, does it?

Just my $0.02 for @Nate_Pearson and crew:
TR is a deal at my legacy price and keeps getting better all the time.
Don’t do tiered pricing and complicate your business model. Charge what you need to in order to keep developing at the pace you have and keep killing it. Don’t over think it.

And that’s why there’s no TR equivalent for nordic biathletes. Not even a niche, a sliver of a sliver… :stuck_out_tongue_winking_eye:

And now we return you to the regularly scheduled content on this channel… :sunglasses:

this, exactly. also, i won’t pay more than my current 189 per year. that’s my threshold and it’s too expensive as it is. love trainerroad but there comes a limit…

How many weekly intensity days to the polarized plans have? You asked for plans with fewer intensity days, TR delivered them, and you gave them a D-.

Other than the close to consensus that changing the legacy pricing would be wildly unpopular, only a vocal couple people here seem to be upset about anything feature wise. And Nate’s posted surveys and the overwhelming majority of people like hearing about upcoming features. So I think your take is off base.