Agree. For myself, not habit exactly but: inertia, familiar with an ecosystem, does what I need at present. At $99 a year even if there is a $50 a year substitute I’m OK not spending time to switch.
On top of inertia, its a feel good story. Emotions count. I’ve enjoyed being a TR customer and seeing the platform evolve and time to time testing new functionalities. The people seem decent and the support is spot on for the rare minor problem. I like what Nate is trying to accomplish even if I’m not the target use case.
$10 a month I’ll continue to support TR and keep the current workflow. More than that and I’ll switch.
Emotions? Yes, I’ll be disappointed if the legacy price commitment is broken. Is it the end of the world? Of course not. It is not even a big deal because in the end this is a hobby for weekend warriors with the luxury of both time and money. Including time to make forum posts (LOL)
Since @Power13 is going to ask the upper limit (love ya man): I’d say $15 a month ($180- a year) is pushing it for the current functions and how I use TR. That doesn’t mean $180 is a huge expense, or that TR isn’t worth $180 a year. It means its not worth that to me so I’d switch to another workflow.
There is probably a good lesson in this entire discussion: Never give a Ford man a reason to go shop for a Chevy. Unless you own both dealerships.
Too complicated. Just raise the annual/monthly grandfathered amounts by a set amount across the board, plus add the delta values of any future increases as and when they get implemented.
Dear all,
How about all the talk regarding diversity, bla bla and make cycling more democratic and accessible to the entire society?
In reality our sport is becoming more and more posh and only affordable for a certain group of previleged people. It’s okay if you only want to race against the rich who have the time and money to afford bike racing, and not against the best humans from all demographic groups… go for it.
I won’t to quit cycling as it is my passion. but i don’t want to support this kind of “financial performanc selection” anymore.
Considering the increase in bike prices and cycling stuff within the last years and especially months …some people are just happy that they are still able to afford the maintanance of their gear and stuff…
Long story short; Why not dropping prices to be become more attractive for the not so wealthy?
Besides i am a loyal customer and dont like being called a grandfather-client who is in charge for hindering TR to be further developed. just as reminder all those loyal long-term clients kept their subscription running even in times when they where not using the service for months or even years.
BG, Sebastian @Nate_Pearson
Well, we are talking about a luxury (advanced training app) on top of a luxury (recreational to competitive cycling), so that must be kept in mind. TR doesn’t have to be a “one stop stop” for everything from the least common denominator to the cream of the crop. They can make it whatever they want it to be.
No different than the range of bikes we see from low cost to debt inducing halo bikes, there are training options from free to many thousands of dollars per year. TR is somewhere in the middle between the free stuff, around other similar paid apps, and far more affordable than a live coach option we see mentioned here as well.
TR can do what they want, but trying to be everything to everyone can lead to real failure at any or all of those levels.
I don’t have any inside info, but basic thoughts on maintaining the salaries of employees, technical support (servers and other hard items) are all part of running a business for profit. Maybe they could cut some corners and such, but that may only be possible if they are running a notable excess (again, none of us know).
I understand the sentiment, but don’t think it takes into account the reality that surrounds what TR is and how it likely needs to operate if it’s meant to continue forward.
Legacy at 129 here. Trained with TrainerRoad quite a bit but my life changed a lot in the last few years. I I didn’t cancel because I liked what the company was doing. I’m not riding competitively anymore, I have to 2 kids now and just commute by bike and maybe use TrainerRoad on the weekends, if that.
If the price were to raise, I’d cancel my sub as I don’t see the need for it. I might go back after a few years when the kids are older, maybe on a monthly basis or go somewhere else.
I’m not trying to complain, just sharing my view in a very specific situation.
I dont think that if one really has passion to ride the bike loads of cash is necessary. I have a 10 year old cyclocrossbike, not light nor heavy, nothing posh, just does the job and surely is not on the upper scale pricewise.
I sold my “posh” Kickr and bought cheap rollers, love it, dont need more
I got an Edge 530 for 160€ on Black Friday and have the cheapest Forerunner for 150€. I dont buy expensive clothing or bike parts, just the necessary spares like tires etc one simply needs to exchange once in a while And this way I have lots of fun cycling, for not much money besides an initial investment for a bike. And used 2nd gear is even cheaper.
Yes, I have a Powermeter, but even that I got after 10y of cycling without and I got the cheapest left crank available, no need to spend more or even to get one at all.
And yes, maybe I wont become the most fastest around, but the limit is rather me than my gear.
There is no TR, Systm, Zwift or anything needed to become a good cyclist, this is luxury which helps but you get it done without it too. For example already the Garmin Training plans included with the 530 are absolutely fine. A good book helps too, aint expensive. Online there is plenty of sources for free too.
And btw. I live in a former communist country in Eastern Europe: My wifes uncle wanted to become a cyclist but was forbidden to do so, because his father was not a fan of the regime at that times.
So he worked and earned money, saved money wherever possible, exchanged and traded with folks for bike parts, got smuggled stuff from abroad, reused old parts and built himself a bike - super heavy, absolutely non posh, completely improvised. Even today he still uses it and man, he can be fast.
One can certainly get that impression but the fact is that all the training tools that were available to Eddy Merckx et al are still available today - for free - except for the bike itself (and adjusted for inflation, a new basic race bike better than anything Merckx ever dreamed of is about the same cost now as it was in 1970).
But there’s more - Even the modern tools (e.g. Cycling computers, HR straps, power meters, indoor trainers, etc and sweet carbon framed bikes too) are available super cheap on the used market as MAMIL’s shed last year’s stuff for the latest and greatest.
TR and all the training apps are great but you can get really really close on your own with free internet & podcast research, $15 for a copy of “Training with Power,” and a pen and white tape to stick the day’s workout on your stem.
The reality is there has never been a cheaper time to train well on the bike. While it is luxurious and a tad easier to buy and use all the bells and whistles, they are not absolutely necessary and certainly don’t have to be new if you do decide to use some of them.
Ditto. I was a strong user and proponent of my Alternate Base and Build timing (even applied in Specialty one) to deal with my progressing age (around 45 when I needed to apply those changes). I did those alternates successfully for 2 seasons, after having real trouble with the default timing just prior to that.
Fast forward to last March when I got on to AT, and I followed the default 5/1 Base timing and 4/1 Build, while using AT. I had full success and great compliance, all while leading to my all-time peak FTP and W/KG after 6 years with TR.
I won’t claim that the AT changes will work for all older athletes, but I can say it is far better than we had before it. In that light, even though it’s not the “masters plans” that were teased only ago, I think it delivers at least part of that solution.
Sure, I have no idea. But based on what I have experienced along the way, some tools/features are “switchable” in the sense that they can be controlled on an “independent” basis.
My experience comes from getting some beta access at a couple times over the years. I have no idea if that “sticks” and is the way it continues once something gets “full release”, of if it gets “absorbed” in a way that no longer leaves it possible to switch separately.
Again, even if that internal structure exists or doesn’t, I guess I don’t see how it really affects the discussion.
Maybe? But we really have no idea. It could be that the accounting side (billing) has no connection to users services (features). We simply don’t know. And even it it IS there, still doesn’t change the current state from what I see.
PL was 7.2 and I failed midway through a 7.8 PL workout (week 4). AT dropped my next SS to PL 5.9 workout then a 6.1 on Saturday. Week 5 I completed a 7.8 PL workout and finished the week completing a 8.4 PL workout. So I had a struggle, AT gave me easier workouts that week and I felt refreshed enough to tackle Week 5. Granted, AT had a gentler ramp rate but I used AT to chose harder workouts in Week 5 because I felt good.
I was just answering your question would you leave…I would. In fact this debate has actually given me the confidence to cancel my legacy subscription as I’m essentially paying for something I don’t really use… out of loyalty, for fear of losing something when actually there are better (IMO) options out there. It looks like I’m not the only one.
Wow, 810 comments in a week.
I may not be saying anything new here, however, I did want to share my 2 cents with TR.
I would strongly prefer for Legacy pricing to not change and there to be one simple pricing model, one price gets everything.
Disclaimer: I am on a lower legacy pricing level having been with TR about 4 years I think.
I should also note that I will be 47 soon and I am doing cycling for general fitness and if I can get a bit faster that would be nice. I have never and will never “race”. I enter gran fondos and cycle with a club in the spring and summer. I am a mid volume rider. I also started using Dialed Health this fall and like it for general fitness and good idea as a masters athlete. Based on this I am not at the pointy end of things and probably don’t need the latest and greatest if you will. Probably just regular riding at a mid volume level with some variety is good enough for my situation. This may suggest I would support a tiered approach, however, changing the current model would leave a bad taste in my mouth. I also find with tiered models there is usually one feature you want in the higher tier (probably designed that way) that almost forces you up to a higher level, or, you just don’t pay at all.
So, if pricing went up and or legacy pricing was maintained but current features state was frozen I can see myself:
Staying as is at my legacy pricing and feature level (no additional revenue for TR)
Starting to shop around and check out and trial other services (e.g. Fascat, Zwift, Systm, Rouvy, RGT, Fullgaz, …) (no immediate revenue impact for TR)
Possibly canceling TR for other services if pricing is similar (reduction in revenue for TR)
Possibly only subscribing to a service for a portion of the year (e.g. 6 months). This is a costly sport and subscription services can ad up and I am not a fan of them in general (i.e. whoop). (Could net same or less revenue to TR on annual basis)
I will continue to use and enjoy TR and AT for now and stand by to hear of any changes.
TR don’t offer any free services (apart from initial trial) so wouldn’t have access to it unless somebody is a paying subscriber. And while people may give their data for free to Strava, Garmin and TP (though I think a better way of putting it is that they’re exchanging their data for a service), I’m sure those companies won’t give it to TR for free.
I’m just speculating, seems the team on the podcast quite often pull out facts from their own data to support the point they’re making so just guessing it’s a valuable resource for them and that more people moving to only using TR for periods of the year might undermine some of that value.
IIRC on the Feb 2021 podcast TR data and ML were cited for dropping SSB HV from 5 to 4 days of SS. Prior to that I made the case that it should be dropped down to 2, or 3 max, of SS. Using the TR number of hours in HV plans, going strongly pyramidal I’ve seen better fitness gains and overall fitness. Counterintuitively my ‘VO2 to Threshold relationship’ went up dramatically when I started doing (off-the-shelf plan) more zone2 and fewer intervals. At least from where I sit, AT seems unaware of all that. And as an aside, over five years ago Coggan laid out the evidence that the VO2-to-threshold relationship should be individualized for everyone, not just masters. Personally I find a lot of value using iLevels and WKO, but its not for everyone. Good on TR for coming up with a system (AT) that supports individualization.
Curious how a monthly subscription to TR works. I’ve always been on the yearly subscription.
If on the monthly subscription and, as an example, you “take a break” for the summer, do you keep all the data accumulated over the time you were active so when you re-start the subscription in the winter, you just pick up where you left off? Or do you have to start over as if you’re a brand new subscriber?