I agreed with you post farther up, how should we approach the duality that the app has problems, but also try to help people who are using this app in its current state?
If anyone offers constructive feedback or tips to another user they get told they are wrong, and can’t they clearly see the app is broken.
From my perspective, it comes back to putting the ‘fault’ on the athlete rather than app. I don’t mean to be the one that’s trying to be negative on constructive ideas and opinions, but when the response is some version of ‘it’s not the app, it’s you’ I think it’s unfair.
So far as I can tell, TR has only acknowledged that there’s a bug with outside workouts. I think many users think there are way more issues than that. I asked on another thread for an explanation from TR on what is “TR FTP” is, how FTP prediction is working, how workouts are adapted by the AI etc but didn’t receive any response.
Anyway, I take your point that at this stage I’m probably not being helpful & am getting in the way of constructive advice, so will take a break for a bit.
I do my best to help people get the most they can from their training. If you disagree with my training philosophy that is fine! But I disagree that I am uninterested in getting value from TR where one can.
I do point tr fault. I can’t know how much of the user base is affected. Sharing calendar is useful to have a different opinion on your training. I do not doubt users expertise, he suggests that maybe he is fighting something. When I accepted higher ftp I wasn’t served with workouts with super high targets, mine was 15 watts higher, and I actually was spot on. Maybe his case would be the same.
I do 6 workouts each 120mins per month, other is trail running. Improvement is scarce month by month, but for a year I did increase my ftp with 22 watts. You are right…that’s low volume and it’s for maintaining fitness which looks like user is getting exactly that.
We shouldn’t default to putting the fault on anyone until we’ve had a chance to see what’s actually going on.
Right now, there are a lot of cases where TR is misbehaving, but that’s not the case 100% of the time, so we shouldn’t make that assumption until we’ve had a chance to analyze the training.
We never assume that it’s an athlete problem. That wouldn’t get us anywhere.
In terms of the known issues, I’m aware of the outside workouts bug. One question though, is that referring to any outside ride or only TR workouts completed outside? I had understood the latter but I saw a post here that me think now that’s it’s the former.
Other than this, I think I saw mention that TR structured workouts completed in zwift might also have an issue (possibly on zwift side) - is that correct?
My 2 cents: Similar experience here. I’ve learned to take the long-term predictions with a grain of salt. While the near-term forecasts usually match the monthly AI detection, I now prefer validating the number with an actual FTP test. Plus, backing off from obsessive 100% adherence and leaving 10–20% of wiggle room just to enjoy riding makes the whole process a lot more sustainable.
I am going to keep advocating that people turn off the mythical AI FTP prediction number. Train your best. Rate your workout honestly. Don’t chase a unicorn. Then, every 4-weeks, when you get your updated FTP, accept it if it feels right and matches your training experience. Ignore it if it’s wildly off. This is basically how TR use to be.