Follow the Plan - Predicted FTP Goes Down!

I took a look at your calendar. The only thing I noticed was that it looks like you might have failed your last over under and haven’t done one in a bit.

There is a weird thing where your last over under is lower than the previous ones. I imagine if you execute it will go up.

Thanks!

I am starting a Build phase.

It is a masters plan, because I’m 64 and it seems appropriate. I can change to balanced. Adding a third hard session seems a bit daunting for me, but I’m willing to try it. I thought that ‘demanding’ would be more productive, but maybe I am mistaken about that.

I don’t do interval workouts outside - just regular mountain bike rides. And I virtually always rate my workouts in line with what TR expects.

OP is going to ski tour not TT. 250 or 260 doesn’t make any difference.

I’ve just took a look at your plan. It looks like you’ve haven’t rated many of your outdoor rides and have done an unstructured outdoor ride in the place of a hard/very hard session on a few occasions, palisade over under session was rated very hard, and there were a couple of significant pauses during your most recent over under session. I think these may be the reason for a similar (+/- 1 or 2%) ftp this time out compared to the previous one. Especially if you only have two hard sessions to bank in progressive overload.

You have a lot of yellow days also, so focusing on recovery so you can nail those hard sessions consistently every week is where you’ll see the biggest gains. Three sessions may be possible if there was less of a ramp rate between each week. This is something worth experimenting with. Nail the recovery and smash the hard sessions :ok_hand:

(Edit: See Boysey had much of similar notes) Looks like a lot of freelancing the plan? Skipping/replacing/etc

Why are you doing so many Not Rated outdoor rides each week? I can’t imagine that TR AI is able to it’s job very well without data points to fill in the picture for it.

Plan ahearance, consistency and good data will help TR and most importantly that FTP :slight_smile:

BTW (for everyone) Recent workout info, how its going, a link to calendar or screenshot help with response and assistance

Thanks very much Boysey and ntisdell. I realize that I completely forgot to rate those outdoor rides. To be honest, I didn’t realize it was important.

Normally, I follow the TR recommended indoor rides. But the weather has been so nice here lately that I have been riding outside instead.

I will go back and rate those rides. Thanks again!

@Boysey95 said you could change from demanding to balanced on the slider in the training plan approach.

I don’t think he meant to go from the masters to non-master plan. I would stick with the masters plan.

imho I wouldn’t change anything, but I didn’t want you to be confused on what they were explaining.

Masters Plan with a dynamic weekend long ride for me… love it! (45yo) it isn’t the best with both workouts near each other Tue/Thur — but I only have time for a long ride on weekends so it works well. (plus, need a long run on weekend also … lol I have a problem)

I will stick with Masters, Demanding, because that seems to be the right plan for me.

I understand that my outdoor rides may have skewed my AIFTP, especially where I was replacing hard plan rides with moderate outdoor rides. But that should have gone into my auto-predicted FTP today (which was up 0.8%). It shouldn’t affect my 28-day out predicted FTP, if I’m at 257 today (which I am) and I’m following a Demanding General Fitness plan.

I have gone back and rated all my outdoor rides, and my new 28-day out predicted FTP is … drum roll please … 253. It went up from 252 to 253, but it is down from the 257 that was auto-detected for me today.

So if I follow my TR plan for 28 days, my FTP is projected to decline by 1.6%.

I mean, it’s obviously not a huge decrease, but it is demotivating. I don’t want to train hard for a month and see my FTP go down.

I mean, threshold is A metric of fitness. But it’s by far the end all be all. I’ve had situations where I’ve been dropped by people that have 20w less on their FTP than me because they have been doing a lot of 40/20s where I’ve been doing more sweet spot work at the time. I just couldn’t handle the accelerations anymore.

FTP is a measure of their aerobic abilities, its absolutely important. Saying its not is just wrong. Them following the plan and ending up lower than where they started months ago is a good indication that something is wrong with the plan.

Agreed, if OP was racing on the road it would be different. However they are planning a activity that is primarily going to be relying on a good aerobic engine. FTP provides an excellent measure of that.

Yeah, I agree. But I guess since his goal is a skiing trip, might as well base everything off of HR…no power meter on skis :wink:

So after reading “change the approach to balanced” many times on this thread, I went ahead and did it, and my FTP detection in 27 days from today went up by 10w. HAHAHA…

Yesterdays prediction had me going from 314 to 317 on Nov 2nd.

Now, it’s giving me easier workouts and it’s supposedly going from 314 to 327…

I too feel totally lied to by those AI Predictions :stuck_out_tongue:

He got good general adaptations from cycling that will translate. For those 5w up down actually means nothing and will not negatively impact his performance. If he isn’t ski touring regularly his form and efficiency is what matters. His fitness will surely will go down a bit with altitude and he will feel it. I live on at 1km elevation, on trail race with at 2-2.5km above sea level I definitely feel the lack of oxygen. He is on good path, maybe chose wrong approach at the beginning. Ski touring is not a joke. Cycling will not help you a lot on skiing back. Local cross ski team is putting a lot of biking for low impact aerobic benefit.

There’s things I want, there’s things I think I want… - Stereophonics

:slightly_smiling_face:

Yes that was just a suggestion he may want to consider, masters plan works really well for many people. adding in a 3rd hard interval with a more conservative approach could yield more benefits provided recovery is taken into account.

Have you been doing a lot of outdoors training until now and switched to inside recently. I think there’s an issue with the TR model there.

Why shouldn’t it affect your predicted FTP?

My take after taking a look at your calendar is that it is indeed having an effect. There are a lot of indications in your previous block that you are training too hard (doing to much) and that has a negative impact on your FTP progress. The Ai seems to have picked up on that and is indicating that if you continue down this path it will get worse and your AiFTP will decline.

Since it has only briefly been touched upon I would like to just point out that the explanation to why your AiFTP is declining is quite obvious. The difficulty of your planned workouts is steadily decreasing through the block. It makes sense that if you actually have to do easier and easier workouts to be able to complete them then your AiFTP should be reduced. Of course, if you feel that you’re on top of your training this doesn’t necessarily make much sense to you and here is where you then might have to do some changes to your plan. Changing your approach has been suggested. If the main goal is to have a figure at the end of the block that is as high as possible this is probably your best bet. If however your main goal is to actually do the most productive work than manually changing workouts if they still are regressing is my suggestion.

3 Likes

Thanks again everyone. Super interesting discussion for me.

I changed my plan from Demanding to Balanced, and my predicted FTP 28 days out went from 253 to 269! From down 1.6% to up 4.7%, in 28 days.

I guess this speaks to the people who said that I am training too hard and not putting enough emphasis on recovery. This is entirely possible, given that I am very (perhaps too) motivated.

It is hard for me to believe that, by taking an easier approach, my FTP will increase 6.3% more than from taking a slightly more difficult approach, but I’m certainly willing to give it a try. Let’s see what happens.

I think the key here is that the Ai has planned your next block based on the assumption that having a demanding approach is too much for you and that you would fail.

If you remember your old workouts you can compare and see that your new plan has a reasonable progress through the training block (and not the regress you had before).