1 minute power challenge - GCN

I dont use AI in my training at all, it has its uses but blindly trusting it is just irresponsible. Its why I asked for sources, at least then there would be something one could verify.

I briefly played around with 1-min power a few years ago. My record was 8.5w/k.

Fatigue will cut into performance quite significantly here, so doing the effort day 1 after a recovery week, or even after a complete vacation, tended to produce the best results if you’re going for a PB.

Pacing wise, things were usually: 15s easy, 15s oh this is hard, 30s of I am actually dying.

For me at least, weightlifting seemed to have a bigger impact on it than any training I did on the bike. I’d do maybe one or two efforts a week just to keep my body used to the pacing and pushing through the imminent death feeling at the end. Think training like a track cyclist.

Just amazes me how all these pro level cyclists exist on the TrainerRoad forums.

We’re talking about a 1000w, 1 minute effort.

You don’t need AI to know that’s extraordinary, I don’t understand why we’re going into semantics over AI usage and what type It is.

The majority of cyclists are not doing 1000w for 1 minute.

TrainerRoad have a video https://youtu.be/Ac1Xo6LiXp0?is=R0L6AJ4OnvfXhJdp

I didn’t realise I was addressing the 0.5% best TrainerRoad subscribers personally In this thread, I do apologise. Please continue producing world class wattage and coming to the forums in your downtime between the Olympics and various other races you’re competing/ winning.

Huh? Is anyone here claiming to be doing 1000w 60s efforts?

No one claimed otherwise…

If we scale down Jon’s goal, then a 1min 10W/kg target is similar. Not many amateurs will ever do that, but I imagine most elites would hit that without too much difficulty.

I just think it’s fun to have these slightly mad goals, especially when they make you think differently about your training. I generally just really like to ride my bike. I have a loose-ish structure most of the time, but the bulk of my training is done on feel and all on the bike and all outside.

So, putting a firm goal in that requires a rethink is exciting for me - especially coming into winter. I am lucky that I have a well stocked (and much neglected) gym in my basement. So I’ll give it a go. And as Randomcoach says, think of it as 10w/kg not 1000w and it doesn’t look as mad.

I think you can get there!

Let’s get this going on Kalshi, who’s with me? :laughing:

Just in case you are referring to my comment about semantics I will clarify if you like: you were - knowingly or not I don’t know - conflating two quite different AI technologies in order to score a point against 3113 for having called bullshit on the accuracy of recursive word generators while simultaneously patronizing an AI-based training platform. This is a false equivalence and I thought it relevant to point out the error.

If you were referring to another semantic point about AI then feel free to ignore this comment.

You are quite right about your other point though. We don’t need AI to know that 10.2W/kg for 60 seconds is impressive.

I did 10 w/kg ONCE ever. It was my first week with my new team race bike ( we had just gone onto being a national trade team, same as US domestic elite ) and I was doing my best vo2 numbers of my life. I tend to naturally be more of a 1-2 minute guy, and with enough training can leverage it out to about 5.

I was super excited about the new bike and absolutely destroyed a 1 minute hill on a local group ride.

I think I could get back there again with specific training, so far I’m doing 8.5 on a good day though.

Getting older also sucks.

I don’t really understand your pissy attitude here, but whatever. I already explained to you the rather plausible mechanics of 1000W for 1min for strong anaerobic riders, but let’s focus instead on the 10w/kg part because many cyclists like to think of power in relative terms.

10W/kg for 1 minute is not an extraordinary feat. I can do that as referenced earlier in this thread, and guess what? I have won one cat2 race in my life and been upper mid-table in the cat1 races I have partaken in. And mind you, this is not American cat1, this is back-of-the-woods Finnish cat1 racing which is closer to american cat2 level. Our “national level” stars are bad conti riders at best. We have a couple good riders in Europe that are competitive in conti/pro conti and that’s it. And yet I know many riders personally in our ranks who can do 10, 11 or even 12w/kg (the sprinter guy I mentioned) for 1min. So either our riders are secretly superstar level, or your claims just don’t add up!

Andy Coggan has posted a heuristic that for the average well trained cyclist, your 1min power is roughly 2x your FTP (“roughly” and “average” being the important parts here). That would equate 10w/kg for 1min with roughly 5w/kg FTP. That is very good and often equates to around cat1 level, but there’s lots of people here on the forum with 5w/kg FTP – there’s even dedicated threads for it! And the funny thing is that 5w/kg is still wildly away from actual pro ranks, where the pointy end does 6.2-7w/kg for long climbs at the end of long stages in grand tours, Pogacar does 9w/kg for 4min on La Redoute and so on. The pro level is so alien that people can’t really grasp it. I have no doubts whatsoever that most of the pros (save for some really diesel guys) can easily do 10w/kg for 1 minute when fresh.

So 930W. :sweat_smile:

Seems so much more achievable now.

Agreed, looking back at my data the best I have done is 9.9 for 60s. Thats without targeting it. Could I do that right now? No, but I am confident I would be able to break 10 for 60s, however 1000w for 60 is probably out of reach for me.

Agreed, that is a significant drop in required power.

I think it’s a waste of time, respectfully.

Given the choice, I’d take a 2w FTP increase over a higher 1 minute power.

And this is coming from someone who’s naturally anaerobic and highly trainable in this aspect. My reasoning is that anaerobic capacity is largely genetic, and beyond that, the trainable portion has a short shelf life, and most people (including myself) would never have a chance to use it outside of obscure Strava segments.

It would be less of an issue if there weren’t a non-negligible opportunity cost associated with this type of training, but there is.

Funnily enough I think I might lean the other way or at least of sort of!

I have (or did before healthi hiccup) enough pace to hang with the club in the rides I want to go on but the short to 10 min efforts are always a bit of a weakness so I’d happily take holding a decent w/kg for 10min over a ftp bump.

While I can only look the bike I’m taking it to heart and moving the kettlebells as much as I can with emphasis on legs most times. No idea if it helps, or what riding is gonna feel like but half the fun, if you’re not a pro/decent racer, is the proces.

1kw for a minute is def out of reach, but in the last 3 years I peaked at 256W for 5 mins and 822W for 5 seconds so in the new year when I can ride properly and have had 3 months of dedicated kb work who knows if I can pass 950W for 5 secs and improve my 1 and 5 mins PBs?

I have a pretty good aerobic engine and would rather have a higher 1min. A lot of race winning moves need the ability to throw shortish punches, which 1min lends itself to.

Reading alot of talk. I’m just gonna whip it out and get this measured. 1min power = 601w @7.55w/kg.

Whoah - did you actually do the test based on this thread to get us going?! :exploding_head:

My priorities are opposite to yours. My FTP is high enough already, and in racing, it’s short punches that wipe me out, so building my sprint and 1 minute power would be more sensible.

Besides, it’s just fun to try something new. Getting back in the gym is interesting and keeps training fresh.

I lost my mind for a second there and watched the video in the OP. I know, what was I thinking, right?

Ollie did a one minute test on Zwift and later that day on a hill climb to set a baseline.
His plan is to a year long, starting by doing four months weightlifting, with no quality on the bike. Then switch up in March.

I think my target is pretty soft, but first my ten year younger self:

I’ve recently done a few one minute efforts while trying to snipe some KOMs in my area and I was able to a lifetime PR which is pretty incredible. Granted - I don’t have any power data from my heydays in my 20’s over 20 years ago.

Best one minute effort is 567 watts at 66 kilos which is good for 8.6 just about. Getting to 10 watts/kg would require another 100 watts for a minute, a very painful long minute. It sure would-be fun having that much oomph for a short effort but getting it would be a lot of work. So far all of my training these past few years has been for gravel races, so this would be totally different.

Since it’s the off-season, I have just joined a gym and will be doing dedicated strength work while having shorter bike sessions. I may give it a bit of try - perhaps just to be able to snag those short segments in my area for a while. It would be fun to have a different training approach for the time being.