Xplr vs t type (gravel)

I have both Red XPLR13 and X01 Transmission for the same bike. I just swap the cassette, chain, and derailleur. The whole thing takes maybe 10 minutes since its always the same bike I don’t even need to fine tune the shifting. I only need the 52 for about 1 or 2 long and steep climbs around so I just swap when necessary. Flatter rides I like the 13 speed better.

BTW- Around here “long and steep” means 29 miles with 6000 feet of elevation gain on a rocky, dirt road.

3 Likes

Good to hear. I have XXSL on my MTB and now 13 speed on my gravel bike and that’s my plan as well, swap over when needed. Do you use the transmission chain with a road front cassette? Or your 13 speed chain with the transmission cassette and derailleur?

I use the transmission chain with the 10-52 and a Red Chain with the 10-46.

2 Likes

Just a PSA, there is some talk that Sram could release a firmware/software update that would open their XX/GX/X0 T-Type transmission rear derailleurs to shift a 13 speed cassette.

4 Likes

My problem is my body weight at the end of the day! I’m a lean 210lb and ftp is 280-320 depending on if I’ve been consistent. I have dieted to single digit bf% @ about 200lb but ftp tanked massively and it was counterproductive

Climbs are my nemesis, my road bike has a 35/33 lowest gear, my local “climb” has me averaging 300ish @ 60rpm in bottom gear, at the end of a long day a 25-28min threshold effort isn’t much fun just to stay upright.

Maybe a 52t isn’t such a bad idea…

1 Like

My problem isn’t weight as much as age with my FTP declining to about 270 (from 340) as I got to my mid-sixties. So, on my gravel bike I have a 38T chainring because of the steep climbs. Compared to 35/33 a 38/46 is over 20% lower gear. And the 38/10 high gear is about the same as a 50/13. On the downhills I just spin or coast. They are never the challenging part of the ride. Simply changing the chainring for different rides can make a big difference.

3 Likes

As others mentioned, the new shifting changes for MTB and e-bike (Hyperglide+ and Transmission) hold the chain at set points while the chain engages. If you’re in a big cog with a slow moving tire, it’ll feel slower. Transmission AXS waits for a set point in the cassette to shift (not sure how).
One thing I found, I think the fancier XO / XX cassettes have more ramps than the GX one. Additionally, SL is XC only, it might have different logic for aggressiveness.
I actually think cable shifting, specifically Shimano HG+, is WAY better than metered eshifting for MTB. Being able to move the RD 4 gears in one push is fantastic.

Glad to see SRAM allowing 13sp on current stuff. I fully expect to see Red XPLR and XX SL to merge into a non-ebike “1x road/gravel/XC” group with a mid-derailleur. Trail/Enduro doesn’t really need all the gear steps/cogs and weight savings XC and gravel do; they just need price point options, gear range, and durability.

2 Likes

Yup. That’s also why shifting with larger range cassettes is slower in the easier gears even though it is noticeably faster on the speedy end of the cassette.

I really hope you are right. This move would make a lot of sense to me, it’d be great if you could use the same RD with a 10–52 and 10–46 cassette.