Last winter I rode the Pirelli Cinturato 32mm and it appear to me bullet proof, there was absolutely no puncture…
Rolling and grip feels not like a race tire, that absolutely true.
The winter before I used the Panaracer Slick in 32mm. Very nice rolling and grip, but I had several punctures, However the sealant fixed all of them.
The Panaracer Slick plus. I have also, it replaced my worn tire on the back. Rolling is not smooth as the normal version. But because I rode the plus only 1000km in spring, i can’t really say anything about protection.
Panaracer GK I currently ride on CX for hard pack. One can ride it on asphalt, but is not optimal.
Overall I don’t think there is one best choice…