VO2max testing and training - how hard should it be?

Would the same hold true for power then? My highest one minute power was from trying to chase down an attack at a Crit course…it was into the wind and I really wanted to bridge the gap. Made it, but blew up shortly thereafter and eventually dropped from the race.

Should I not take that highest power?

Same with my 20 minute power. There’s a Cat3 climb near me that I like and I set my best 20min power up that climb.

Should I ignore that and look at ones that I’ve repeated? I’m quite new to all this training stuff and I’m struggling with my “numbers”. I’d hate to be making things more difficult for myself.

Thanks

So what’s abnormally fast? For me 100-110 is fast, much faster than my naturally selected cadence of 75-85 (off road rider primarily) - there does seem the be an agreement than 100 -110 rpm is a sweet spot for VO2 max intervals. Comes down to the concept of race specificity to me, if my concern is drive 110-120% FTP for a certain time, power targets make a lot of sense. If I’m trying to simply improve heart stroke volume, power targets make less sense - RPE and HR then seem to supersede the work I’m doing if I’m simply trying to tax cardio vascular function close to max uptake.

Please pick this apart, I’m just trying to understand the different approaches.

I’ve read too many posts on VO2 Max at this point, plus I’m an idiot with a double digit IQ, but I thought the point of a VO2Max workout was to get your HR up to a level that was at/above/equal to your VO2Max heart rate?

I was under the impression that VO2Max was not a power number but related to HR?

Surely the figures you use should be recent and in a comparable setting. I.e. in the last few months and on the trainer.

post your picture! When I go really hard for 2-5 minutes it leaves me slightly dizzy/confused, unable to catch my breath, heart is pounding, and my legs feel like jello. A fish out of water is my best shot at a picture.

I’m doing it right then. :laughing:

OK, makes sense. I’ve been really only doing Z2, SS, and a few FTP workouts up to this point. There’s been some VO2 but as we know in the TR plans they are relatively short.

It sounds like I should be doing max efforts at least every 2-3 months perhaps? I could take my 5min and 1min from my last Ramp. But I’ve not done a 20min threshold interval yet (I’m in General Build…looks like I have some FTP intervals coming up).

I’ve seen other users mention “feeding their power curve” is this kind of what you’re saying? Max efforts to get max power for time frames in my current fitness level?

That sucks.

A lot less so than HR.

And on HR, each person can be different. Maybe adrenaline before/during a race has less impact on you than me?

If John Glenn was able to keep his HR to 110 before being blasted into space for the first time, maybe there are people who can control HR before/during a race :man_shrugging:

No. Seems perfectly fine.

90-95% heart rate max for intervals is where you want to be.

Tom Bell knows what he’s talking about:

You can’t really exceed your max HR (well, you can, but only if you’re really hot, or dehydrated, etc.). As example, I despite repeatedly turning myself inside-out trying to break a lab record for VO2max, I kept hitting low 170s.

The point of VO2max intervals is to try to raise your VO2max. If you’re already decently trained, the most effective way of doing that seems to be longer intervals at/near VO2max. One way of assessing whether you’re going hard enough is to look at HR, another is to look at power.

The latter is really the better indicator, as it establishes a minimum - OTOH, you’re HR can be really high even if you’re not at/near VO2max. Still, it is often all the people have to go by, and there is a misconception here that 90% of max HR (about 85% of VO2max) is “good enough”, which is why I’ve been talking about it.

I feel the same after a kilo, even though my VO2 is not maximal. Same is true if I bonk.

One last question. I used that 180 as my LTHR for setting my HR training levels. Which has quite an effect them I believe.

What numbers should I look for in setting my HR levels? Just look as some other harder efforts.

I was super pumped for this race, lots of adrenaline and worked so hard for 60 minutes staying with the front group that I blew myself up. Actually rode to the finish at Z2 because I was cramping so badly. Called my wife over and pedaled to the car so she could help me off my bike. I doubt I’ll ever do an effort that hard again.

OK, so now my question is; What is my max HR (for setting HR levels so I can properly train)?

I’ve been told that I should not use the 180bpm I held for 60-90 minutes during a race as my LTHR. Does that mean the 201 I saw at the end of a crit is not my Max either?

Should I set my max HR at something I’ve seen during training multiple times?

Don’t use outlier values correct?

Unless it was unduly hot during that crit, or your data shows a big spike in HR only over the last few seconds, I’d call it 200 and move on.

“ To find your LTHR do a 30-minute time trial all by yourself (no training partners and not in a race). Again, it should be done as if it was a race for the entire 30 minutes . But at 10 minutes into the test, click the lap button on your heart rate monitor. When done, look to see what your average heart rate was for the last 20 minutes. That number is an approximation of your LTHR.”

Surely if you exceed your MaxHR… you just have a new MaxHR (or you didn’t have a true max beforehand)? I appreciate ‘environment’ may elevate your HR in general, but it’s still your MaxHR right?

Is there anything out there to debunk 90% of MaxHR not being “good enough”? (Not disagreeing, 90% of MaxHR for 3-5 minutes x any number of sets isn’t that hard for me personally), but from what i’ve read, % of MaxHR is the best shot we’ve got of a proper vo2 max workout without actually measuring vo2Max, and power is a poor distant relative in prescribing vo2 workouts (not saying this as fact, i hate it… totally goes against how i’ve been training for 4 years!).

Meeehhh…I wouldn’t say it’s poor prescribing…just that the ubiquitous “120%” is good enough for most people (the old TR blog post on VO2 kind of detailed this; that info is now gone). IOW, doing 120% intervals will probably capture a decent enough portion of adaptations in both VO2 and “5 min power” to make most people faster.

I lab tested at 67.9 ml (O2/kg/min) when I was 48. At 52, I’m still pretty close @ 66 ml (O2/kg/min). Does it matter? No. I still get smoked by my local ‘friends’ on a regular basis.

I can safely say, a lab-based VO2 test is HARD A.F. I wanted to vomit in the mask – but the worst part is that once you ‘blow up’, you need to keep the mask on while the final numbers are calculated.

p.s. It does allow you to properly calibrate your “HR Max”… in other words, the HR max I recorded in the lab is only rarely exceeded on the road or TrainerRoad sessions – and then, only for very very fleeting moments, measurable only with things like a Hadron Collider!

p.p.s. For me, that VO2 max was 123% of my FTP