This workout is not recommended

The problem is the AI FTP estimate fluctuates and is often inaccurate. Am I missing something?

I’ve shared this with the team.

Thanks for the suggestions!

I’ve been doing more inside workouts as of late, just in the last two weeks using my head unit to do “outside” workouts indoors just to see what would happen. I’ve noticed the same trend, workouts that are “not recommended” are often moderate or hard in RPE. AI FTP detection had detected me at 217 after some unplanned time off, I manually adjusted from 240-somthing to 230 . all of the workouts have been appropriately difficult. Seems TR AI is really conservative, to the point of making it so that an accepted FTP would have likely led to worsening my already poor training.

I’ve had to ignore almost every TrainerRoad workout in 2026. I’ve had a plan in place since January, and at the beginning of each week, I look at the scheduled workout and replace it with a harder one that I think will fall into the “hard” range for me.

I also switched off Predictive FTP and have been ignoring the AI FTP detection over the past few months. Despite setting all-time PRs, TrainerRoad continues to predict that my FTP is lower.

Eight months is a long time to have a “bug” in the software. At what point is it no longer a bug and becomes a fundamental problem with the way the system was designed?

Unfortunately I am inclined to agree. I am luckily in that have legacy pricing. at this point I am happy to support TrainerRoad because I believe that they will get past this and make it right. I will admit though the main reason I am still using the platform for training is only familiarity as the AI features are seemingly useless for me.

It’s now mid-October, do you still feel the same?

my optimism is definitely waning

Coming up to a year now…

Somewhere between 2.2 and 2.6%, it seems…

How it went:

Not sure why the predicted changed afterwards, is it basically cheating off it’s own notes/data?

Is your FTP correct? A predicted and actual easy rating for a threshold workout seems strange.

We had a whole thread about it, people throwing out allegations that I was gaming the AI or something by not responding appropriately.

Whether it’s accurate or not, I’ve never touched my FTP number since AI FTP became a thing, so I can’t tell you if it’s right one way or the other. I’ve never thought over unders @ 95-105% particularly challenging though, especially at the short 9 minute blocks they are prescribed in the 4-5 threshold workout level, where the AI FTP seems to like to keep me? Like 120%, yes, 105%? Not really.

Have you tried doing the over unders at a higher ftp value to make them as challenging as they are meant to be? I have always been under the impression that these should at least “hard” and borderline ‘very hard’ as far as workouts go.

Agreed. And I just choose significantly harder workouts. But even when I complete them, if I rate them as “hard” the following week it’ll drop my PL back down.

Based off of what assumption?

Not trying to be combative, because I asked the same question in the other thread and nobody could answer.

Isn’t your FTP supposed to be your 1 hour power, or 95% of your 20 minute power? Then why should 9 minutes at a time with a solid rest interval in between be hard to very hard?

Just because it’s “threshold” doesn’t really mean it’s hard, it’s just the zone you’re working in. Same reason working at VO2max for 5 seconds isn’t hard, but 3 minutes is. My interpretation, at least.

True , but they should have you produce lactate and then be forced to clear it whilst operating around your maximally steady state, that is inherently challenging. Riding at your maximum steady state is still hard, the overs are basically gaming your system such that 6-12min intervals with ‘overs’, are like much longer unchanging intervals at your steady state. A hard/very hard workout depending on fatigue.

They could be moderate in uncommon circumstances if you were pinging and well rested and carbed up, but I don’t think they should ever be easy

I agree with what @Boysey95 is saying here.

Over/Unders should be hard at a minimum. Clearing lactate right around your FTP shouldn’t be super fun.

If you’re doing an over/under workout and it doesn’t feel hard or very hard, either your FTP is too low or you’re doing the wrong workout. If TR prescribes that type of workout to you, let me know and I’ll take a look.

1 Like

Pabst,

Just to add a bit more on O/U or Threshold intervals in general…

FTP or lactate steady state is or Threshold - are often referred to as your Hour effort or power. However it was never really meant to mean that or used in that fashion. It varies widely how long someone can maintain their FTP or LT .

Depends how the FTP was arrived at (ramp, 20min, estimate based on training), how fresh people are for the test, type of athlete (sprinter, long TT specialist, etc).

As Nate always used to say “yeah you could maybe make it an hour if someone held a gun to your head” lol

With over-unders - that added amount over 100% ftp really puts a hurt on your RPE for longer efforts - …especially if you are using an estimated Training metric like FTP/critical power/estimated LT/5D Power profile, etc.

QUICK GOOGLE SUMMARY:
The Original Intent: Coggan originally framed it as the power you can sustain for approximately one hour (often linked to a 40km time trial effort). [1, 2]

  • The Actual Time-to-Exhaustion (TTE) Range: In practice and scientific literature, a rider’s actual Time-to-Exhaustion at true FTP typically spans a range of 35 to 75 minutes

  • Fitness-Dependent Variability: Studies tracking riders performing steady efforts at their designated FTP showcase a clear spectrum across experience levels:

  • Recreational/Amateur riders: Median duration of 34 to 42 minutes.

  • Well-trained riders: Median duration of 47 minutes.

  • Professional athletes: Median duration of 51 to 75 minutes.

@eddie
You are welcome to take a look at my training history if you think it’d help draw better conclusions for the discussion. I will warn you though that I am not a well disciplined athlete, and take vacations here and there, run sometimes more than I bike (especially when travelling), etc. My weight is also down ~10 lbs from the beginning of the year, and roughly 35 lbs from 2 years ago.

I reached the same 170bpm at the end of 9 minutes, for all 3 blocks w/o any HR drift. HRmax is 203.

I thought it was easy, I tacked on another 15 minutes of 75% FTP at the end because I had a movie to finish. :slight_smile:

My FTP is what the AI has decided it is, I haven’t touched it since AI FTP became a thing.

haha i’ve lost all hope. although this week it seems that my recommended workouts are just about right.

Those predicted RPE scores are a function of how you personally score workouts.

Looks like you either rate workouts easy/moderate or fail them?

Does that sound right? Is that what happens?

If so then this seems to be working as expected?

Out of interest… what was the last workout you rated hard or very hard?