I think this is the correct take. They’re good tires. It’s not like they’re trying to sell us crap tires. They’re up there at the top. I think a lot of the backlash is that they hyped them up as being the absolute BEST tire ever made. They told us that other brands cut corners and that they used the top materials to justify the price. They marketed them as being the best, so when they don’t live up to that hype, people are rightly a little irritated. That doesn’t mean they’re bad tires by any means. I think Silca could have gone about marketing a different way and they would have had a better response. But I think Silca at its heart is a marketing brand. That’s their schtick. Which rubs people the wrong way sometimes.
He said exactly what I have there in quotes. I can’t tell you what he meant by that exactly, but that is what was said.
Just got an email and they’re back in stock. Set of 3s on the way for my Lauf. I’ll see how the roll against the Race Kings.
Results for the RCG-3 45, functionally the same result as the Pathfinder 45. Bottom third for that size tire at BRR.
Unfortunately Silca doesn’t seem to have produced the radical innovation promised by their marketing. Perhaps the bigger sizes will test better.
While the RCG-3 in 45 definitely missed the mark, the tread/traction of the RCG-1 would probably be more comparable with the 45 pathfinder.
also, John K’s testing of the Silca tires has them at very fast. Not the absolute fastest, but in the top few, relative to the size tested. On Cat 1 the 55’s are faster than the thunder Burt, which is generally regarded as the fastest tire people regularly use.
Granted, the new 55 pathfinder is right up there as well. Seems both the pathfinder and Silca tires are not as optimal in the smaller widths.
Sure, but the marginal difference is not at the magnitude the technological marketing indicated. The RCG-3 is 0-2w faster in the VE testing than the SG TB, which of course is very good; but to meet and not exceed by any meaningful margin a tire design from 5-6 years ago falls far short of expectations.
Personally, for me (a rather mid MAMIL), the big sell on the RCRs is whether the carbon bead lives up to Silca’s hype about being easy to mount. I have’t had much trouble with my gravel tire/wheel combos, but I’ve never been able to get a tire mounted on my road wheels (Enve SES 4.5) without insane amounts of effort, cajoling, cursing, and, occasionally, blood. I’ve mounted (or tried to mount) Contis, Pirellis, Vittorias, even Enve’s own (garbage) tires.
So I bit the bullet picked up a pair of the RCRs and put them to the test. True to Silca’s word, they’ve been the only tire I’ve been able to mount on these rims my without a tire lever. They were tight, but manageable.
Took 'em out for a shake out ride and they felt pretty good.
They didn’t feel as lush as the Vittoria Corsa Pros, but if you blacked out the branding I wouldn’t be able to tell the difference between these and Conti GP5000s. Not saying there isn’t one, just none that a punter like me could immediately notice. Given that they lived up to Silca’s hype about being so easy to mount, if they prove to have an acceptable level of puncture resistance and durability, the RCRs might just be my new go-to tire even if it means giving up a couple of watts.
We’ll see what the long-term review looks like, but at this point I’m sold.
It seems every companies new tire is “so much faster and more technologically advanced” than their previous tire or all the competitors. Most of those tires still suck and are 5-10+ watts slower than the fastest.
While Silca’s aren’t light years ahead, being one of, if not the fastest gravel tire of their size is pretty dang good.
I haven’t bought them nor are they anything I’m excited about, but will consider them when I need new tires.
I remain interested in how the results turn out for the larger sizes.
I wonder how long it will take for Josh to put out a video discussing BRRs testing and results and give his explanation as to why it isn’t showing Silca at the top.
Im just a middle of the pack dude, but just completed Big Sugar 100 on the Silca RCG-3 and they were flawless. Loads of grip, no punctures, and they seated on the rim with a floor pump. I ran them with Boyd wheels in the 50mm at 24 PSI.
38 RCR tests out. Not the greatest. Not even top 5 for the same widths. Pretty disappointing.
Overall not terrible but agree a little disappointing. Seems very little reason to not go with the GP 5000 S TR in 35mm, which measures the same, has similar weight, and rolls faster.
It received a 4.8/5 and a highly recommended rating.
they give everything at least a 4.5
@IamLeven Filter all road tyres for rating. The 4.1 - 5 bin contains 95 of 182 Results
If it’s not 5/5 it’s not worth buying. Half kidding, but there are probably close to a dozen competitors that got 5/5 and cost less. GP5000 S being one of them.
Well, the same site that gave other tires a 5/5 is also highly recommending these. There are other variables to take into consideration when making a purchase. That said, I ride GP5000’s and have been on them and their predecessors for years. Not sure how I came to that conclusion but more than happy with them.
I agree. It will be interesting to see where they go from here.