Polarized Training Discussion (Fast Talk podcast & Flo Cycling podcast)

Great thanks for the advice.

Thanks for the detailed post, I will try again soon and be a little more conservative with my pacing.

I’m always keen on a new gagdet. A quick google threw up this:

https://www.praxisdienst.com/en/Laboratory+items/Devices/Blood+sugar+monitoring+devices/Accutrend+Plus+blood+sugar+monitor+mmol+l.html?cur=3&speed=1&gclid=Cj0KCQjw9JzoBRDjARIsAGcdIDXvwL8pIJy5VpE8pbIoubIZSad4zfrMf2LIlUq2grFqxd1BB-WVnb8aAmKwEALw_wcB

Ouch, that’s steep enough to get you thinking about the investment!!

Mine was $280 for the device and the test strips run a bit under $2 per sample. I run tests for myself and a handful of close friends.

Locally if you wanted a bog standard LT test (not MLSS) folks charge anywhere from $75 to $200. I figured it was a reasonable investment for myself plus the crew have had a lot of fun with it and some utility too.

Cheers,

Mark

Abr state 40k tt on Sunday, abr regional 40k in July, and USA cycling 40k in august if you live in Illinois lots of opportunities for an “easy” way to get a few in the next 8 weeks.

Do you test/prick yourself? This works at higher intensities? How do you ensure no contamination of the sample?

Unfortunately these devices are so expensive here as well.

Yes for some tests I’ll do it myself. Heart rate drops quickly but the lactate measure is fine for the purpose.

For some tests I will get my wife if she is available, or a pal to take the sample. It’s a lot nicer to just ride and have someone else take the measure. But don’t always have a willing helper.

The device records readings so can hop off, sample, hop back on fairly quickly.

Contamination hasn’t been an obvious issue. You wipe the finger, get a blood drop, wipe that off and take the sample from a second drop. Once things are flowing you get a good rhythm to the sampling either solo or if running a test for someone else.

FWIW, with a good FTP estimate from power testing can get close to MLSS. What I’ve found testing 5-6 experienced riders is their power test FTP is more than good enough for zone setting. What is more interesting is how some guys can’t take the mental pressure of really riding an hour at MLSS. So in 40k TT they are leaving some potential in the tank. That helped a couple fellows to new PRs and better training this season. Kinda fun to see data and geekery actually translate to performance.

Mark

Hi there. I’m very new to POL training having decided to give it a try after having followed SS plans for a few years. One thing I’m not clear on is how to periodize training through base, build and race phases (more volume, intensity or both?) or whether this even applies and I should simply stick with the same workouts throughout the year and build FTP)? I generally have between 10-12 hours a week to train and was wondering how best to plan out my sessions. Given most of my races are 2-2.5 hours on the road with a good proportion of time spent at tempo (POL Z2), should I be introducing more time in training in this zone as my races get nearer?

Sorry, probably too many questions but really interested in your thoughts!

Periodisation is not directly part of the POL concept. But a very common strategies to that early in the season you start with a big volume oft LIT and plenty and not so hard HIT session. Then progressive increase in HIT toward the competition period with a reduction of LIT. Where the HIT becomes even harder and the LIT more easy.

A alternative approach in block training.
see also:

Or there is the “reverse” polarised approach as per Steve Neal’s appearance on the Flo Cycling podcast discussed above, where he talked about starting out with a very polarised model, then introducing more and more tempo work as the event got closer. This might be most appropriate for a multi-stage race.

I also depends much on the race series and of course one can mix different approaches. The evidence can’t show clear advantage for periodisation (spezific order) over variation.
And of course many of use who live in regions with real winter wiht short days that make a lot lit at least uncomfortable. Either indoor, nor riding in the dark is much fun. So early in the year, or even in December I foucs on HIT, including HIT blocks and when days become longer I introduce more and more LIT.
Towards the TT season my HIIT becomes also more specific and my intervals become longer and closer to race tempo.
Seiler found no evidence that a this periodisation have any impact

his study suggests that organizing different interval sessions in a specific periodized
mesocycle order or in a mixed distribution during a 12-wk training period has little or no effect on training adaptation when
the overall training load is the same.

https://www.researchgate.net/profile/Oystein_Sylta/publication/309252992_Sylta_et_al_2016_Periodization_1/data/58073ea608ae5ad188167646/Sylta-et-al-2016-Periodization-1.pdf

However, i make it anyway to become comfortable with race pace. And of course there is also no evidence that it have any disadvantage.

Overall, one is very free in organize the training, as long there is enough variation and all systems are touched. And most of us have also social constraints take into account

Well at the 3rd attempt I finally managed to complete the hour, I paced it pretty well tbh, I realise it’s meant to be the max you can do for an hour but over such a time frame you gotta be realistic and employ a degree of pacing.

Dr Seiler has said that if he’s at ~90% HRpeak at the 15 to 20 min point he knows he can sustain it to the end, I possibly undercooked as it took me longer to get to that point. Anyway, I had my FTP set to 240 and I achieved 246 so there’s my new, accurate figure.

Hi, you sound like you might be UK based, is that right? If so where are you? I’m kind of interested to know if I am actually around the 1mM mark at easy power, it’s something I’ve heard Dr Seiler say, some people have to down train to get to this low level even at an easy pace cos they’re so used to training in the dead zone.

Close. I live in New Jersey on other side of the pond.

Cheers,

Mark

Yeah exactly and as we all know most people over estimate their true abilities.

There is a lot of info in this thread and a lot of speculation. However, this comment by @Nate_Pearson definitely stands out as a potential hard data point backed by what likely amounts to an abundance of data.

Nate can you expand on this a little? You mention 2-3 watt/kg riders do less 2-hour rides than 4-5 watt/kg riders. So if a rider at 3 w/kg wanted to get to 4 w/kg, is there a set number of 2-hour sweet spot rides that you would add/prescribe based on the data? Your bullet point says “more” so I’m just curious if you can elaborate a little in terms of the quantity of those 2 hour SS rides.

Thank you!

I don’t know the exact amount. My gut says “more volume = better watt/kg”. We are on the hunt for that very answer though :smiley:.

Fun follow up would be to determine differences between two riders with the same watt/kg at distances over (for example) 1.5hrs, but more like >3hrs. Watt/kg gets those two riders in the same general category, but it’s not the whole story at longer distances. I know you don’t want more speculation, but it ain’t FTP (obviously, as they are the same).

Just to add more muddyness to the conversation, but if you’re really following a polarized system, power prescriptions are more based on an individuals response and not on Coggan’s levels. You have to separate yourself from the power levels when going polarized and get used to HR levels, as Seiler’s descriptions of the work is almost always based on HR targets for the workout. I still get about 25% of time at “tempo” in my long rides, but HR usually never goes above 75% of max and keep a steady breathing pattern, indicating at or below LT1 since it correlates well with VT1 where respiration starts to really increase.

So I’m confused about the TTE component of these tests. You do a warmup, then 10 minutes at 95% of what you think the target would be, then 30 minutes at 100% and then spend ten minutes (or to exhaustion?) increasing power and then take the average of those 50 minutes as your ftp? Do I need WK04 for any of this?