Depends. I already said that I would not consider the one that started this thread as easy.
Those bursts can add up over time.. ![]()
They are always an option if you’re feeling bit spicy. They should be available in Workout Alternates.
I just saw this video recently posted on the RCA YouTube channel. Since it has some relevance to James, I thought I’d post it here. It’s not too long, and the referenced study was done on runners, but it might still be applicable to cyclists. (And it doesn’t sound like it would make a James ‘alternative’ any less boring, but it should make it less fatiguing.)
Yep, linked the study up thread but I dont know how many people read it. Hopefully makes people feel less guilty about reducing the intensity of the TR prescribed z2 rides that are right at 74/75%.
@Jonathan has TR looked into this at all, or considered lowering the FTP% for endurance rides? I know that TR has lots of data from which the methodology for determining the ‘best outcomes’ has been derived but, with winter in the northern hemisphere setting in, maybe there’s an opportunity for an experiment where James, and similar Z2 workouts, are replaced with something similar, but at a 60-65% FTP level. ![]()
Reducing the effort level of these endurance rides might even help to reduce or eliminate the yellow days thar seem to be planned into our calendars. I mean, I get having a yellow day if I exceed the plan for some reason, but why would there be multiple yellow days on my calendar in the next few weeks if TR is supposedly giving me the ‘right’ workout every day? ![]()
Here is a good breakdown from Steve Magness. As always, it depends…. And it doesn’t matter. For some, long and slow is more draining…it depends on what stage of training you are in (more intensity in base is beneficial, during specific work less so…how you recover, etc. in the end it doesn’t matter and you just gotta do what works for you.
One nit pick from me..
10-15% below vt1 might actually be zone 1. I know for myself in the bike from lactate testing that it does not increase until I get above 65%
They mention a huge power range for z2, but i seriously doubt anyone has that shape of a lactate curve. Any pace or power where lactate had not increased above baseline is z1. (Same with respiration rate, since respiration is in response to blood co2 concentration)
People should learn where that border is to help manage their overall training stress.
There’s definitely some subjectivity when using the standard delineations for the different zones. The 55%-75% for Z2 is pretty wide and, as you mention, really isn’t based on the individual’s metabolic response to the stimulus.
I would think that, without knowing the lactate response, maybe somewhere around the middle of the standard range (say 65%) might be the safest bet, as the vast majority of people would then not be falling into Z1, or exceeding to Z3, and it would still be less fatiguing than trying to push up to the 70%+ level.
And, of course, all of this is predicated on the person having a reasonable FTP on which to base all of the zones. Maybe someday lactate testing will be as simple (and inexpensive) as measuring HR, but until then we just have to use what information we have (which seems to always be changing),
As someone who does just about all his endurance riding at 65% of FTP, I endorse this message.
I even made a little calculator to take an endurance workout prescription at a percentage of FTP above 65% of FTP and convert it to a ride at 65% of FTP only extended by an amount of time to mean the two rides would be equivalent in terms of kJ or TSS. IIRC, 90 minutes @ 75% is near as dammit 120 minutes @ 65% … and I much prefer the latter.
I don’t test with lactate much since I’ve been using respiration rate as a proxy. Similar to a talk test to monitor the boundary, but I use rhythmic breathing to monitor paces/power targets.
In the study they used vt1, which should be pretty easy to estimate. Rpe should always be part of the equation for prescribed power or pace.
Has technology around lactate testing improved?
I remember watching some of Lionel Sanders videos when he was trying to use the Norwegian method, he kept contaminating the strips with his fingers and the strips and tool were pretty expensive.
I assume since I am not getting flooded with marketing that they are still cost ineffective for most.
Not really, it still has plenty of issues.
Day to day variability, what you eat and how hydrated you are makes a difference in the readings. Add the contamination of the strips and interpretation of the data and it becomes a much bigger hassle than any potential gains imo.
Ventilatory rate is more interesting as a method to get real time data but there are a lot of issues with it currently unless you are willing to ride with a mask on your rides.
I almost beta tested a new device that uses lactate excreted in sweat to monitor and set training zones. It was crazy expensive though, the consumables wouldbe 1-2000 per year if you wear the device daily. Plus the technology isn’t as robust, being impacted by sweat rate.
I will agree that self testing is not that practical, as it is much easier to get a faulty reading.
Definitely something we look and and will continue to do so.
In terms of yellow days, it’s totally okay for yellow days to be predicted in the future and occur when an athlete is following a training plan. Remember, a yellow day does not mean something is wrong; it just means that you are accumulating enough fatigue that you don’t want to incur another big dose of training stress. For some athletes, they may get the best improvements training close to their limits like this, while others may get better results further from that.
What causes a yellow day varies from person to person, and will evolve as their training load evolves.
For context, I’ve found that when I am really consistent with my training and pushing the limits of what amount of training stress I can absorb and adapt to, I typically have 2 or sometimes even 3 yellow days per week. My schedule during these times typically is as follows:
Monday: Hard day
Tuesday: Endurance day
Wednesday: Hard day
Thursday: Short Endurance day
Friday: Long Hard day
Saturday: Long Endurance day
Sunday: Rest
When I’m pushing my limits, I typically see yellows pop up on Thursday and Sunday, but sometimes on Tuesday too, but that’s usually when I’ve added in extra somewhere, hehe.
But back to the point of the endurance rides being higher in Z2 than you’d like, you can always use alternates to pick something lower. That’s one of the reasons why we built the alternates function ![]()
This should be highlighted more somehow! I’m 100% guilty of this - like many driven folks, I want to do what’s on the schedule and more if possible. This year I’m allowing myself to downgrade workouts if I think they are too hard, or if I’m just not mentally into it - particularity the Z2 stuff. Even reducing the Z2 from balanced to one step below in the training approach custom option seems to help quite a bit.
For me a big part is motivation - If I do a hard session on Tuesday, and then I’m straight into 70-75% on my other days, and then back to a hard day, I never feel like I’m getting a proper mental break. As we all know, the best training plan is the one you can stick to consistently - keeping the motivation and mental approach high is my priority this winter.
Yeah, I think we could do more to make alternates more prominent. That said, it’s a bit of a fine line to walk, because many athletes may lack the intuition and experience you have, so making alternates more prevalent may overwhelm them or put them in a spot where they are over or under training due to manual adjustements.
Always tricky, but something we’ll look into.
Yes, good point. I can see where this could become a negative for the athlete. Just manipulating the individual zones in training approach, and combined with some instructions around that, could be a safer way.
I find that doing alternates, particularly for endurance, makes very little impact on future FTP prediction as long as you aren’t downgrading to something crazy.
In fact, I’d say that I probably do (the majority?) of my endurance sessions on the trainer as pure Free Rides. I personally despise how often Trainerroad endurance rides have like a 5 minute warm up then jump straight into like 74% FTP or whatnot. I understand you might be able to extend the warm up? But I am already cutting it tight with my 90 minute rides.
I love the flexibility of doing the free rides for endurance rides on the trainer, and have never found it to make my program or FTP prediction wonky. It seems to read the rides just as what the comparable endurance ride would be. I do try and target a similar IF of what the endurance ride may be.
I also noticed this that changing to a lower alternate doesn’t seem to impact the predicted FTP much if any. That being said, I have chosen a lower FTP anyway, so I’m not seeing the predicted number now.
The day after a hard day in particular, I def don’t want to do 74% FTP efforts, but I still like a lower level structured TR workout, so I seem to have come up with a nice balance.
