Just wanted to share my experience since I just sold a road bike via Pro’s Closet. I tried selling on PinkBike and only got lowball offers or people who wanted me to ship from US to Canada. I didn’t want to go that route because shipping and customs was $500 or so on a bike I was trying to sell for around $2500. Mine was probably a tougher sell than most because it was a big bike…I bet a 54/56 would have sold overnight.
I got a very fair offer from Pros Closet that was only a few hundred less than I’d listed the bike for on Pinkbike, they sent the prepaid label, I shipped in a free box from my LBS, and I had my money 2 days after they got it.
I checked the site to see what they’re selling it for, and the markup isn’t as huge as I thought it would be especially since they cover my shipping. I promise I’m not a shill for them or anything, but it was an easy, painless and fair process all around.