Endurance vs. Easy: Does TR Treat Them Differently?

I wonder if that is part of the issue here.

Maybe you using a lower FTP than we’re recommending is what’s causing us to bump up your workouts’ IF. If that’s the case (I’ll have to dig in a bit more) then that would be an undesirable side affect of setting your FTP manually.

How are you rating those workouts?

We don’t recommend using that chart. It has caused issues for athletes in the past. The official RPE chart is shown below.

How to Rate Your Effort

  • 1 - Easy
    This ride felt easy and non-taxing, requiring little effort or focus. You could repeat the ride and pass it without issue.
  • 2 - Moderate
    This ride was somewhat comfortable but required some focus to complete. You felt a little challenged but had confidence that you could finish. If the ride had an additional set of intervals, you could complete it.
  • 3 - Hard
    This ride required effort and focus and was challenging to complete. It felt tough, and you looked forward to the ride ending. If there were an additional set of intervals, you could have done it with significant focus.
  • 4 - Very Hard
    This ride was very difficult to complete, and it tested you. If there were one more set of intervals, you wouldn’t have been able to complete it.
  • 5 - Maximum Effort
    This ride was extremely difficult. It pushed you well beyond your abilities and took a massive amount of energy and focus to complete. You felt like you barely made it to the end of this ride, and that you had to pull out every mental trick in the book to finish. If you had to pause during a workout to catch your breath or adjust the power demand down, the workout was likely a maximum effort.
    • If a workout was a maximum effort because of external factors like illness, poor sleep, or fatigue, be sure to add that detail in the follow-up question.

When you say “I still rate them as easy, even though they are not “easy”. In comparison to some sweetspot rides, which I rate moderate, they are “easy”, though” I get a bit confused and worried.

Why aren’t you rating the workouts as they actually feel?

If a workout feels moderate in effort and you tell us it felt easy, then we’re going to assume that any workout of a similar difficulty will also feel easy, and you might not ever get truly easy workouts in that zone..

I’ll take a look for your DM and see what I can find with your account.

Question on the ratings.

When rating workouts, are you rating against how the “intent” of the workout, or how it actually felt?

For example, I may have a 9x2 vo2 workout where I feel for what it was, a vo2 workout, it was moderate. Not a breeze but could’ve done a few more ok, or could’ve raised the watts on each interval and still been ok.

Alternatively, if I did a longer .74 if endurance workout, for “endurance” it might feel much more exhausting than a .6F workout, but still nothing compared to that moderate vo2 interval session.

How are these treated? I’m always reluctant to rate any indoor endurance ride more than easy, even though obviously a .7 if endurance ride would really feel moderate compared to .55 if.

You shouldn’t rate workouts in relation to anything, just that session, just that day.

A vo2 workout shouldn’t ever feel moderate I don’t think if your FTP is set correctly.

I’m curious as to what you have rated hard or very hard?

for my FTP, I’d consider myself very strong in interval ranges like 3 min and under. I am lacking in the threshold and sweet spot range where I feel like they’re harder than they should be. I plan to make them more of a focus this coming season.

Incorrect. The problem is the wrong model of the athlete and the perenial sin of anchoring vo2 work to FTP.

even so, the effort required at VO2 intensity is not an easy or moderate one - it is by definition the point at which your body is taking out oxygen loans it can’t pay back :grin: - that hurts and requires focus to push through.

Always rate the workout based on how the actual effort felt.

Don’t think about anything else.

Simply answer that question of “How did this effort feel?”

3 Likes

Oh, your body can pay them back, just need a recovery interval, then you can hit that effort again. Not sure I would ever describe them as hurting; you just know there is a limit to how long you can hold the effort.

When you think you cannot sustain 90% of your max HR for 5 minutes, remember that elite marathon runners can do it for 2 hours.

For reference, my VO2 workout on 3/16 was San Cristobal - 9x2 at 324 watts. It was challenging, between moderate and hard, but I rated it as moderate. I also did a very heavy leg workout that day as well.

Two days later (so not even fully recovered from the two-a-day). I decided to try an all out effort on a 10 minute climb that I ride and hate regularly. This was my 2nd time ever trying a 10 minute all out effort. I didn’t really prep for it, and it was 2.5 hrs into a very climb intensive gravel ride. I averaged 337 watts for that 10 minutes. That was an all out, contemplate quitting, eyeballs about to burst, effort.

The fact that I can do 337 watts for 10 minutes at all out, should tell me that 9x2 minutes at 324 watts is uncomfortable but being ‘moderate’ is pretty reasonable.

Fair

Not VO2 max inducing

It depends…

A few 60 second efforts at VO2 may feel moderate. After 20 of them probably not.

So 9x2 at 108% FTP is not a VO2 Max workout?

VO2 max is a physiological state, not a specific power target or range.

Additionally there is a quite large variance in efforts >FTP on an individual basis.

So for one person 108% might be enough to induce VO2 max, for another it might be nowhere close.

The fact that you can do a power that is notably higher than the 108% and hold it for far longer than 2 minutes would mean its almost assuredly not inducing VO2 max.

I’ve probably said this 1 million times, so here’s 1,000,001…it is problematic that we have a workout power zone named VO2 Max and also have a fitness measure named VO2 Max. People arguing about “VO2 Max” are often not noticing that one person is talking about the first while the other person is talking about the 2nd.

The fact you can do 112% of the AI FTP for 5 times as long, says no, it is not.

But back to what he said before.. at least for me, that 9x2 as you described would not put me at vo2max physiological state. 9x2 would be need to be at least 5 to 6 minute best, maybe even higher. But that would depend on the rest intervals. So your moderate sounds right, but was it really vo2max?

Agree.

TrainerRoad defines the VO2 max training as 106% to 120% of the FTP. 108% falls into that range.