Endurance vs. Easy: Does TR Treat Them Differently?

It annoys me too and I just override my recovery week manually. On top of prescribing rides at 0.74 IF (which are difficult to execute correctly outdoors because you inevitably drift into Zone 3), it cuts my Sunday rides down to just 45 min to get the weekly TSS right. So I have to rebalance the durations and intensities myself to keep my weekly TSS ~40% lower than during my build weeks and have slightly longer and easier rides.

This is what I often see, and it was the motivator for creating this post to begin with. Why would it not simply recommend Leach? Still 2:00 hours of quality endurance work, but at 55-56%, which would greatly promote recovery and is likely better than not riding at all.

While doing Dans this morning (endurance) the instructions were on.
It said some people can recover at 70% and some at 40%
Then it said any effort longer than 1 hour is not recovery.
:person_shrugging:

To be clear, I am not actually complaining. This is my typical seasonal pattern: over summer i do quite a lot long distance riding, mostly below 65% of FTP (still structured progressive overload) and during autumn I start shortening rides + increasing intensity, so current top of Z2 rides are appropriate for me.

Still, I agree with you, it feels like AI does not consider/prioritize upcoming weekly key workouts when suggesting current day endurance ride.

Couldn’t agree more. Every endurance ride or easy recovery week ride is near top of zone 2 with tr. I’ve asked them about this multiple times and never get a clear answer on why…

I wonder if TR differentiates in strategy for endurance prescriptions between someone riding 4 hrs vs 15 hrs?

Not to over simplify, but it seems that if there’s no real differentiation, something could be implemented to distinguish between 1-4 hrs, 5-8 hrs, 9-12 hrs, etc.

All that in mind, it’s really not that big of deal to simply change a .74IF endurance ride to one around .65IF. In my case, it rarely if ever even impacts predicted FTP.

Even furthermore, I do a LOT of “freeride 90” for my endurance rides on the trainer. That way I can pick my own intensity, length of ‘interval’ section, etc. I have been very vocal in the past how I hate having an endurance ride give me like a 5 minute warmup then jump straight to the top of Zone 2. I’d much rather have it go .55/.75./.55/.75, as opposed to the opposite.

Doing all these free rides, I’ve very rarely, if ever, notice a negative effect on my predicted FTP vs doing the prescribed endurance workouts.

I just tested out adding a 60 min endurance AI selected ride into my scheduled 13.5 hr week (outside rides) next week and it gave me a workout of IF .62 and 38 TSS between 50-70% intensity that I would consider easy. You do have the option, at the bottom to choose a different workout to the one chosen, the same, easier or harder, shorter or longer. Perhaps it thinks you can cope with the workload and knows I couldn’t, as it is supposed to take account on what you have done before. Also perhaps if you keep changing them to easier workouts, it will learn that is what you want. I have stopped expecting this to be perfect and I just try to make it work for me.

I just tried the same thing, but added a 5-hour endurance ride on my ONLY DAY off next week (Friday), and it gave me an IF .65 and TSS 210 suggested ride. :face_with_raised_eyebrow:

This is an interesting thread. I too have been trying to stick to the plan .IF for these rides and in recovery weeks and it’s great for a bit and then I slowly get baked over time. I wonder if TR could specify these rides with a HR range as well as a power or .IF range instead of just one .IF number.

One thing I have found is that if I do these rides outside and tend to be in the HR range that I know is in my mid to low Z2 range (just from a respiration rate mainly) that it doesn’t seem to have a big impact on predicted AIFTP… as long as I nail my intensity rides.

I think TR could give more guidance for these endurance rides especially when we are doing them outside but equally if you are indoors and your HR is out of whack for the target power it gives you an incentive to dial it back instead of keeping on.

“James” is brutal for this. 2 minutes and bam you’re at 74% for an hour and a half. Its fine after about 10min but that opener is a bit of a shock.

Perhaps the intention can be dictated from the expected RPE. If any workout has the highest percentage of being moderate or hard, then the intention is to stimulate adaptation, yes? If it’s expecting 70% easy then most likely not expecting gainz?

Whether it actually feels easy or hard will fluctuate obviously, and some time just down to how people want to measure it.

Here’s my thoughts from a previous, similar thread this year:

I’m a winter only TR user, and last year I had the same issue - the endurance z2 rides I felt were just too hard and TR always gave me the top of the range. My plan this winter season, assuming it does the same thing giving me all top of range, is to substitute for easier ones sometimes. If anything, I just found it mentally taxing knowing these sessions aren’t chill and still require concentration. The mental break is as important as the physical break.

@JMGant I’d be happy to take a look at your training plan.

If I remember correctly, you’re extremely consistent with your training and well-trained, so maybe there’s something that’s causing you to always bump up against the top of Z2.

How are you setting your FTP?

Also, just to clarify, we do understand and believe that there are benefits to all types of endurance training, and not everything needs to have or should have an IF of .7+. :sweat_smile:

If anyone has concerns about the workouts we’re prescribing, please let me know and I’d be happy to take a closer look and let you know my thoughts. :+1:

1 Like

I just posted about this in a new thread, but you have articulated it better than I did. I’m at 372w, and the simple calorie demands of riding at 74% of that for extended periods are huge! Almost 1000kcal per hour

I just checked my last recovery weeks and nothing is below .7 if.

I also used the RPE explanation, which was posted in this thread and that’s why I still rate them as easy, even though they are not “easy”. In comparison to some sweetspot rides, which I rate moderate, they are “easy”, though. Like the OP, I feel like the system doesn’t distinguish between easy and endurance rides on my calendar and I get prescribed the same intensity, on both easy and endurance rides.

Especially in recovery weeks, I don’t feel recovered after a 2h ride at .7 if.

“Recovery Week” does not mean recovery rides. I think the term “recovery” week is a poor one. My understanding is that those weeks would be better referred to as “Deload Weeks”. You are still doing work, just lower volume and lower intensity focus (endurance, and endurance+). You may still have a Moderate endurance workout (especially those in the .7 range) but overall your body is recovering because the recovery and intensity is comparatively lower than weeks with more riding days and much higher intensity.

The first reply is going to be “is it ok for me to discuss this here or would you prefer to discuss privately?” You’ll get a faster answer if you add that answer to your question.

True, I will just message Eddie directly.

Yes, I follow the plan prescribed and am consistent. As of right now, I have ignored TR’s suggested 334 FTP because 318 is relatively recent and a stretch at times. I consider the suggested FTP, but take it as a suggestion and consider everything. I used to always accept it, but I don’t anymore, as I feel like the AI FTP is often optimistic. At this stage in my cycling training career, a 5% increase in 4 weeks would be a miracle. I am always open to having someone look over my training and give feedback.

I agree. I’m beginning to regret accepting my last AIFTP which is 245w (up from 235) in a deload week but quite daunted by my upcoming over unders. I think it’s about 5watts too high. Which makes a difference at relatively lower ftp (<250w) values.