here is your specific 1x setup:
Does the off the shelf Shimano/SRAM 2x drivetrain work with a bigger casette than intended by the manufacturer? No, you’d need a longer cage or a different derailleur. So I don’t know who is comparing apples to oranges when you are the one arguing hacked together setups and I’m comparing off the shelfs combinations.
I don’t know why my comments ruffled your feathers - I nevery attacked you personally so I don’t understand what problem you have with me? Attack the idea not the person. In the end we’re arguing about semantics. Everything has been said in this thread about 1x or 2x. It’s friday - have a happy weekend.