Is a MTB tire the fastest and best tire for Gravel racing?

K cool. So with that temp swing, speed increase on the second lap is two fold.

Few watts from air density AND a few watts from actual tire rolling resistance getting faster with warmth.

How much total? About 5 watts.

The weather impact is really interesting. Thx for the detail.

1 Like

Hmm, didn’t even think about the rolling resistance change with temp. Makes sense, but I assume that curve is a lot flatter than air density impacts?

Actually the opposite! Air density vs CdA and implied CRR relationship is very much linear where the air temp vs tire CRR relationship is a bit more progressive.

Meaning as it gets colder and colder tires get slower faster than the air around you gets slower.

Temperature impact on rolling resistance

4 Likes

Thanks for sharing! When you test again I’d suggest using the Chung method as it doesn’t require holding the same power and you can do short tests where the conditions are the same. You can test gravel/pavement/aero bars all separately as well.

2 Likes

Yep, I thought about it. I used to be a big golden chetah user (including the embedded chung testing), just haven’t played with it in years. Probably need to reinstall and remind myself how to use it. Or are there better tools these days for doing Chung testing?

Yesterday was just opportunistic with my planned 2 lap ride and near perfect testing conditions. And I’m usually really flat with wattage on easy endurance rides, so no challenge there. I was checking periodically, but not watching it constantly.

1 Like

Bad wording on my part, probably should have said non-linear. I was meaning flat like a power curve (once it gets past the early steep part, it gets very flat with additional time). I assume rolling resistance and temp is some thing (a freezing tire is really slow, but once you get past a reasonable temp the curve is pretty flat).

I looked at the study and didn’t see a curve and was too lazy to run any numbers, but my assumption is that a 73f tire wouldn’t be that much slower than a 82f tire (but that’s just a guess on my part).

Correct, like 5% slower rolling resistance at 73 degrees. Not much.

BRR had a test on temp also.

Sub freezing is where it really slows down tires, but even at normal rising temps it’s enough to skew tests so it’s often on my mind.

1 Like

TB 2.1’s successfully mounted on my Crux….plenty of room because they only measured 49mm once inflated. :thinking:

We’ll see if they widen a bit with age / use. @jkarrasch indicated over on the EC Discord that they will and that is my suspicion as well.

But even if they blimp out to 51 or 52mm, there should still be ample room.

5 Likes

What rims did you put them on?
I put them on a 25mm internal and they measured 53mm :confused: way too little clearance for me personally. Didn’t get a small batch :rofl:

2 Likes

Enve 3.4’s w/ 25mm IW.

:man_shrugging::man_shrugging:

1 Like

After reading about the Hutchinson Caracal Race 40, I’m interested in buying them. I’m wondering though if my 29mm internal, 40mm external Nextie NXT45AGX wheels would “stretch” these too much since my 42mm Pathfinders are already being stretched to 46mm on these wheels..?

2 Likes

I think it is a bit unfortunate that the BRR tested the rolling resistance only in warmer temperatures. Many northern hemisphere riders spent significant part of the year in temperatures between 5 to 10 degrees C, so it would have been nice to get figures for those temps too.

1 Like

Looking at the BRR data, the Caracal is very similar to the PF42 in terms of sizing*. The casing width is 2mm smaller, while the tread is 2mm wider. The casing width will translate to roughly 1mm less tire width. The wider tread cover is great because it means less exposed sidewall. I think the Caracal on those wheels sounds like a super fast combination. It will look fantastic too.

If you’re not having problems with the Pathfinders on those wheels, I would definitely try the Caracal Race’s. You are definitely giving up some puncture protection though.

*The two tires had the exact same measured width on the BRR rim.

2 Likes

Thanks for the detailed explanation, exactly what I was hoping for!

I read about people flatting them quite easily, but the puncture protection is the same as for the Vittoria Mezcal 44s I was running this winter and I haven’t flatted those, also not in last weekends race where I hit tree stumps and there were stretches with a lot of pebbles. So not sure how worried I should be here.. The PF42 has been flawless as well, no flats.

2 Likes

It’s ok. They all get slower as it gets colder. Fast tires are still whatever amount faster than slow tires

It was interesting this winter - I went out on an ice free morning at about minus 8-9c. I was running G-Ones - an Ultrabite on the front and an R on the back. They felt wooden and generally awful, and no faster at all than my usual Suomi studded tyres.

2 Likes

Interesting. Mine were around 51 when first installed on my 27 internal wheels. After leaving them around 30-35 psi for a week and several rides, they now sit around 53-53.5mm. I’d bet yours will eventually bump to around 51ish. I’d knock them up another 10 psi over what you will run them while they’re sitting and it’ll probably speed up the process a bit (if you weren’t already).

Have you measured that clearance? Looks to be 3-4mm and way more than a lot of pros seem to have. I wouldn’t hesitate to run that one bit in dry conditions. Looks similar to my TB on front.

Yeah, they were sitting at 40 psi yesterday and I usually run tires this size ~20psi. Will check them before I ride today to see if there is any change (not likely this soon, but we’ll see).

A few thunderstorms rolled through early this AM and dropped a ton of rain, so looks like I’ll be checking mud clearance sooner than I thought! :winking_face_with_tongue:

1 Like

Yeah mine have stretched to around 51.5-52 on 23 iw rims. I think they were also sub 50 when I bought them.

I run mine with 3mm clearance, even in mud and rain - no chunky mud around here though. I’ve run this setup throughout the winter with no issues.

I did recently install frame protection tape around the chainstays, seatstays and fork just for peace of mind.

1 Like

It was 3mm or less including the little hairs. I know pros are running that type of clearance but I’m not a pro and something tells me they don’t care about frame rub as much as I do :wink: