Is a MTB tire the fastest and best tire for Gravel racing?

Well DJ’s latest video opens this up again, and I’m glad it does… if anything to show that you have to remain open minded and sceptical, a few studies do not make science.

With cobbles being an extremity for ‘bounce’ the right tyre is a much more nuanced decision than many here have suggested.

It’s a shame he added so much anecdotal evidence at the end though. The testing said a lot and he should have left it there.

Dylan’s new video has a lot of good info in it. And it absolutely shows that races where I live that can be 50/50 road/gravel do not need mtb tires. I get it for Big Sugar and Unbound, but you really have to look at the course you will ride or race on and make the best choice. So the answer for the thread title is, it depends. Case closed.

Also the majority type of the gravel, the surface at critical race moments, etc. It’s clearly a spectrum and different tyres will perform best on different sections. The harder packed, the more it leans towards a narrow tyre (where speed is also faster) and vice versa. I’m glad this will never have an absolute answer.

This really shouldn’t come as a surprise…a lot of us have been saying that for awhile.

Heck, even Dylan himself has noted that running MTB ties in BWR NC last year was probably a mistake since he got dropped on the road section.

IMO, your tire choice need to reflect the course, with a deference to running the widest tire you can and then sizing down depending on the characteristics of the course.

Right, it’s not a surprise at all. Most of us have been saying this all along, but there has absolutely been a contingent that was all in on mtb tires as the overall best choice, including Dylan when he made that mistake at BWR NC. He ran the WRONG tires because he had an all or nothing mindset versus the more complicated shades of gray that actually exist.

What I’d like to see now is the results Dylan had used to make charts for 50/50 gravel/road, 30/70, 70/30, etc… The 50/50 seems easy. You take the pavement RR figure and add it to the cobbles RR number and divide it by 2 since both would be half the course. I think? Then you get a RR number for the total course and can choose what is best. How can we do that for other percentage breakdowns though?

Yup, I mentioned this as one of the flaws in his previous testing (admittedly form a few years ago). He did some testing at Unbound on some segments but then used it for the analysis on the whole course. Well if you only test on the chunky stuff, but there is a fair amount of tamer gravel or asphalt, you may not be making the best tire choice.

Similarly, the gravel that I normally ride is (at best) Cat. 1 gravel…so a MTB tire may not be the best choice.

All that said, I think the real change in thinking here is that we generally used to start from a narrow tire mindset and then start adding width if the course was chunky. Based on recent data and testing, it seems we are now tackling the challenge from the other side - assume the widest tire you can run and then narrow down if needed.

The BWR NC race is more complicated than he made it out. He got dropped on the pavement after unpaved Pinnacle Mountain road. Given the state of that unpaved section it’s as likely, perhaps more, that he would have been dropped there or earlier on the pavement if he’d been on smaller tires.

DJ and the Bonk Bros have a fair understanding of what the testing says, but they all seem to struggle with the actual factors that are at play in the real world and the tests are trying to tease out as proxy. Or at least they struggle to explain on the podcast.

As was said above “a few studies do not make science” and it’s hard to draw a concrete conclusion from one instance in one race by one rider. I rode larger tires for the races that I felt called for it this year and so far my results are better than years past, with about the same fitness and otherwise equipment/position.

If you go back and look, my first post in this thread was a “no” to the thread title, which became a “yes” the more I read and rode. I’ve been a flip-flopper on this for a long time so DJ’s current vid is more information to obsess over, which I like. Gravel tires are getting much better and it seems clear that in the future we will see more clearly delineated bike types, and tire choice metrics.

I agree with the “it depends” comments.

My first thought about calculating for mixed surface courses (e.g. 70% road, 30% gravel) using simple math would be to weight the different resistances based on time spent (not distance) on each surface. So you also have to make an assumption about average speed on each surface. But that shouldn’t be too difficult to estimate.

While I agree with others about potential “decisive moments”, this is trickier because it’s not just about the moment, it’s about everything you do leading up to it that matters as well.

And ill add my long standing comment, its not 100% about straight line speed, tech downhill and twisty singletrack do appear on gravel courses and can create gaps if you have the wrong tires.

The video is somewhat confusing.

It is said that BRR and Silverstone both overstate the wattage difference between tires.

BRR has the 40mm Cinturato & 50mm Cinturato at 1.5w difference.

Silverstone has them at 13w difference.

This doesn’t seem to follow?

The pedaling efficiency rig seems like it requires it’s own evaluation and right now doesn’t seem very useful in comparison to BRR and perhaps virtual elevation testing.

The advantage or penalty for using Race Kings at 36kph, compared to 35mm Cinturatos, is -40w or +33w depending on surface?

Race Kings have a 32.6w rolling resistance (exclusive CRR not factoring aero) penalty over 35mm Cinturatos on pavement? This seems an order of magnitude greater than expected based on real world/real surface testing.

Cinturatos aren’t even fast tires, what would be the Race King pavement penalty compared to the Hutchinson Caracal Race? or GP5K AS TR? I’ve done long paved rides on all three and I cannot imagine or see a 30w+ difference.

Don’t take this the wrong way, I think this is useful and interesting. I wish there was more information on the pedaling efficiency rig, it seems at odds with everything else.

It it humorous that this debate has entered a phase where discussion is between two types of roller testing.

If BRR “inflates” the differences between tests of tires because their roller is too small of a diameter, the 5 fastest 40mm labeled tires are only 3.4w apart. In reality they would be expected to be closer?

Agree, without any data on correlation of the SSE rig to real world I am having a hard time believing any of that. At least with BRR we have quite a bit of evidence that it correlates well to pavement Crr from Chung testing. I don’t think those numbers would hold up when testing those same tires on pavement or gravel outside.

Not only that, but you don’t know for sure what the “decisive” moment will be…is it a road section, is it a descent, is it a climb? Or is it when a counter-attack forms that ends up chasing someone down and then winning the race?

Tactics play a huge role in what becomes “decisive” and you can’t necessarily plan for that.

Outside of professionals… Who is averaging 22-25 mph in a gravel race?

That’s just semantics though.

No it isn’t….it is a complete reversal in approach.

Which ever direction you go at it, you settle on the tyre that is most appropriate for the race you’re doing (in your opinion). The starting point is irrelevant.

No because the “optimal” is now viewed diametrically different than before. Previously it was essentially “narrow as possible” while now it is “wide as possible”

Your assumption that they reach the same point is flawed.

Also, since the closer you get to “optimal”, the smaller the differences you can notice (or measure), the reversal of approach means you land on the widest tire that isn’t super slow, vs the narrowest.

E.g.based on DJ’s testing, you might have ended up with a 40 for race going smallest to largest, but now you’ll end up with the 50 for the same race.