I have no clue if that type of bacteria are bad. I do want to eliminate artificial sweeteners from my diet, so this was a good wake up call that I haven’t don’t that yet.
There was a major study that came out a couple years ago that correlated one of the big nasties (dementia or alzheimer’s) with artificial sweetener intake.
There are a few studies showing that sweeteners can affect gut biodiversity. I can’t remember how big the studies are or if they are even human studies.
This podcast is a fairly good listen on the topic:
There were two studies last year that threw some shade on probiotics. I think they also throw some shade on parts of the ubiome. The applicable part of them was they found that when they actually tested people via endoscopies and colonoscopies to get mucosal samples of gut biomes they varied from older stool based studies.
In short: You poop out your probiotics. Older studies were looking at stool and assuming it corollated to gut biome. Turns out it doesn’t as much as we thought. So, take the findings from this stool based collection with a bit of salt, especially for edible probiotic bacteria like the pickle/kraut.
My wife looked into this and it looks like my insurance will cover 6 tests and we just need to pay the $30 shipping. So worth investigating insurance options.
I agree that this stuff is interesting, but that NO ACTION should be taken in response to it. Unfortunately, that’s just what Nate and others seem to want to do. Hopefully, they will simply be wasting their time and money and not adversely affecting their health.
There is a lot of good research going on in this area, but there just isn’t enough known yet to use these tests to take any action. Much of what is provided is based on correlations that have been made, but correlation is not causation.
For example, you should not care at all whether or not you have the microbes they identify as “gluten-digesting,” unless perhaps if you have celiac disease or are diagnosed with gluten intolerance. Genetics play a role as well, but is not determinative either.